6 ms·
Suppose that RMS supported something like buying organic food directly from farmers. Would you then pose the question “What if a farmer is a mass murderer or a
by teddyh 12y ago
Suppose that RMS supported something like buying organic food directly from farmers. Would you then pose the question “What if a farmer is a mass murderer or a terrorist? Would that mean that RMS is supporting terrorism?”
- dragonwriter 12y agoI think what you miss is that RMS has argued against other things on the exact kind of indirect support for non-free software argument as was directed at his recommendation to buy directly from publishers; it rests on RMS's use of that criticism rather than the assumption that the criticism is valid.
- teddyh 12y agoThe argument as you descibe it sounds silly, and to believe that RMS used it I would have to see a citation. Even so, if he used it, he would be wrong. I argued against the argument as presented, I can’t be expected to know whether it was subtle sarcasm or not.
- bdcravens 12y agoRMS has been pretty cut-and-dry about proprietary software. For instance, he won't use document types that encourage proprietary software use (even when free alternatives exist). So to answer your question, if RMS was a staunch anti-terrorist advocate, and it was guaranteed that a percentage of organic farmers were terrorists, then it would be perfectly reasonable to pose that question.
- teddyh 12y agoThe analogy breaks down thusly: The non-terrorist farmers are neutral, but the web servers not running proprietary software are, by definition, running free software – i.e. they are not neutral, they are the opposite of proprietary. The web is not something that, inherently, suggests use of proprietary software, so I don’t see a similar reason for RMS to discourage use of the web in the same way he discourages .doc format files. A .doc file or a .swf file very much suggests specific proprietary software, even though free alternatives exist. Not so with .html, .css and .js.