3 ms·
I have long legs. I already sit literally pinned butt to knees between my seat and the back of the seat in front, if someone tries to recline the full weight of
by Someone1234 12y ago
I have long legs. I already sit literally pinned butt to knees between my seat and the back of the seat in front, if someone tries to recline the full weight of the seat falls onto my knees and it feels like that person is bouncing up and down on them for however long the flight is, I take painkillers when I fly...
So I think it is safe to say I do not support this. In fact I'd fully support a legislative minimum on seat pitch and seat width. Essentially freeze it where it is now indefinitely. Otherwise airlines will feel compelled to compete with whoever has the smallest seats yet further.
And before you say "well Premium Economy!" that's a nonsense argument. It is literally 50% more expensive on most flights and you most assuredly don't get 50% more seat pitch, 50% more seat width, any better food/drinks, or much else. You may get a free bag worth $25-50...
There's no particular justification for the inflated price of premium economy. They just declare it a "premium" product and charge accordingly (i.e. lectury tax). But for those of us who are tall and or with long legs, there's nothing luxury about Premium Economy, it is just "basic comfort," just like most short people enjoy on aircraft.
- maxerickson 12y agoI hope you at least realize that you are advocating that other people pay for more space than they need to ensure that you can pay the basic rate and still be comfortable. I'd be fine with a rule that required them to disclose a couple of the seating dimensions anywhere they advertised a price (rather than hiding them behind the seat class).
- mindslight 12y agoIf they're selling airline seats for people, then crazily enough, a person should be able to fit in that seat. If you're really arguing for a finer accounting of resources, then let the cost be strictly linear. Lets say a base $150 ticket is a 32 inch pitch. Then an additional 2 inches should cost $9.38 extra, available through the exact same sales channels. And if the airline would like to play the game with your width or weight as well, then they either need to calculate based on area or specify how that $150 is divided up for the linear combination. But ultimately the airlines' business is just like ISP's "bandwidth caps" - when limits are set low and overages are at a much higher rate than the common, then it's clear that the business model is based around gouging arbitrary people rather than honest appraisal. (BTW, I've found airplane armrests do indeed swing up, you just have to pull harder than you'd expect to. This is really only useful on the aisle or if you've an empty seat next to you.)
- maxerickson 12y agoSo what about Andre the Giant? I suggested that they should just be required to disclose the spacing of the seats because that sidesteps the whole stupid discussion about what size is appropriate for whatever definition of person happens to be on the table at the moment. It is not an argument for a finer accounting of anything, it simply improves the ability of customers to comparison shop. (I think it is a fine thing to figure out a way for tall people to be able to fly comfortably at more or less reasonable prices. It's a really bad idea to accomplish it by making every single seat large enough.)
- mindslight 12y agoAirlines can either statistically budget a few larger seats, or give an automatic "upgrade" into a seat which is capable of fitting the passenger (most likely intended for a higher fare class). I'm not thrilled at the idea of encouraging the US's obesity epidemic, but it's unavoidable if airlines insist on charging per-person. Or they can figure out movable seats and linearly charge for actual room used. That was a serious suggestion. Disclosure doesn't fix the issue. Price gouging is based around forgoing competition for a small segment of customers (losing a little marketshare won't affect the bottom line). The other airlines follow suit, especially as they all benefit from decommodifying the industry, and you end up with a class of people who can only obtain basic service by paying a luxury rate.
- rtpg 12y agoI think this is very similar to arguments about gov't regulated minimum speed broadband. Especially considering airports and the like are usually built with massive gov't support. And free market arguments do not really apply here I think.If I need to get from NY to Paris in less than 2 weeks, I have no choice but to get onto a plane. I think standard minimums make absolute sense, because there's not a free market, since people are basically forced to travel by plane (at least for international flights). That or getting rid of reclining seats...
- maxerickson 12y agoWhat do I do if I need to get to the moon? Less sarcastically, there are billions of people that are forced to forgo flying completely, because they can't afford it at any price. I think there are probably reasons for the government to subsidize airports and air travel. I'm a lot more skeptical about controlling the price of tickets.