4 ms·
Amen, I don't trust BitTorrent (the company) at all. Sync was a MASSIVE let down and it feels like they've backtracked on decentralization and are just trying t
by joshstrange 12y ago
Amen, I don't trust BitTorrent (the company) at all. Sync was a MASSIVE let down and it feels like they've backtracked on decentralization and are just trying to slap their name on a bunch of products that leverage bittorrent (the technology) in some way even when the products don't align with what, I feel like, the majority of BT users want (open/decentralized).
- lewisl9029 12y agoSilently bundling cryptomining software with uTorrent is what crossed the line for me (not that I had very high regard for the company in the first place). I've since then switched to open-source alternatives of their products and will not touch anything else they make from now on, and advise everyone I know to do the same (unless they eventually open-source their products, which I highly doubt would ever happen).
- ryanlol 12y agoWell, they weren't doing it "silently", users had to agree to install the miner.
- dmix 12y agoSyncthing is great though, which is an OSS clone of Sync. After I saw the awful security review for BT Sync, which is a massive closed-source C++ codebase, I switched to Syncthing which that is written in Go and posted on Github [0]. I find it has a better UI and it's more reliable than Sync in terms of connectivity/syncing speed. Maybe some people will be inspired by Maelsto, create a nice clone, and release it open-source. [0] https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing [1] http://2014.hackitoergosum.org/bittorrentsync-security-privacy-analysis-hackito-session-results/ http://2014.hackitoergosum.org/bittorrentsync-security-priva...
- danieldk 12y agoSyncthing is great though, which is an OSS clone of Sync. It doesn't offer anything near the features of Sync, requires that you have control over the firewall or the firewall is set up to use uPnP (which is not true for many networks I use on the go), is be difficult to install for friends or family I would want to share files with, and doesn't offer sharing invitation links. Syncthing is great for a subset of use cases of BTSync, it's mostly pre-1.4 BTSync (minus the trackers and relay servers to make it usable when you do not have control over the firewall.). After I saw the awful security review for BT Sync, Well, it was mostly the security review that was awful (did you read it, of course BTSync accesses the update server). iSec Partners also did a review of BT Sync and found it to be secure. Disclaimer: relatively happy user of Bittorrent Sync. Just not too happy with their monetization model, would have preferred purchasing the software, rather than a subscription model.
- jszymborski 12y agoSee, the advantage of BT Sync over Dropbox/Drive/OneDrive was that it was secure and I didn't have to worry about my private files being spied on. With that main use-case in mind, why would you lock down the client to closed source? Why should I trust it at all? Instead of all these audits that don't have much to go by, we'd have real audits with real results. For me, I'm on ownCloud atm. I used BT Sync exclusively before I used ownCloud with VPS I have. It's serving me well, and the full-time availability is a plus.
- danieldk 12y agofeels like they've backtracked on decentralization You can still use BTSync completely decentralized. 1.4-type shares are still available (shift-click '+') and you can disable tracker/relay server use. But it would've been better if they continued on the open protocol/source path and earn money by offering encrypted read-only peers.
- joshstrange 12y ago> But it would've been better if they continued on the open protocol/source path and earn money by offering encrypted read-only peers. Yes this would have been ideal. I had issues when I tried BTSync before with too many shares bogging everything down so I stopped using it.