5 ms·
>>This fall Yale will import Harvard’s most popular course, an introductory programming class called CS50 -- a move the department called innovative while stude
by ch4s3 12y ago
>>This fall Yale will import Harvard’s most popular course, an introductory programming class called CS50 -- a move the department called innovative while students have characterized it as humiliating.
Oh, tell me more...
- tashoecraft 12y agoI think it's incredible smart. More universities should do this. Harvard has produced a terrific course with a very good professor. Instead of trying to compete against it, why not utilize it into the classroom. Although if I was a Yale student I would probably think it was humiliating.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoThe concept of an Ivy League institution not having at least a good computer-science department should be humiliating. Imagine a university saying that students shouldn't bother with mathematics because pre-law or accountancy are what are really important!
- munchbunny 12y agoIf you speak with actual Yale CS grads who are now programmers, I think you will find a very different story. Yale's CS curriculum is quite the opposite of weak, but the department is certainly stretched thin on people to teach it because the administration hadn't given the department the budget to hire more professors. I was a Yale CS undergrad and the curriculum taught me quite well. The classes never taught me Rails or Node.js (trending when I graduated), but I did have a rigorous education in algorithms, systems, networks, firsthand practice with a variety of paradigms and concepts (functional, multi-threaded, continuations, etc.), plus the discrete math and graph theory to think about the concepts analytically. By all accounts that is a very thorough though somewhat classical approach to CS, but it certainly sets you up for long term success as a programmer. If anything, the department's philosophy is actually "you don't need pre-law to become a good lawyer, we'd rather teach you logic and make you a strong writer first." Having enough people to execute on it is a different story.
- sukilot 12y agoNote that this article is about the high demand for pre-programming, not theoretical computer science.
- wlesieutre 12y agoHarvard and Yale have a rivalry going, so the students are uncomfortable with the fact that Harvard has a great computer science course and Yale has to borrow from them. It makes way more sense than creating a new one from scratch, so props to Yale's faculty for taking this approach. There are places where experimenting and working on different teaching methods is a great idea, but I don't think this is one of them.
- ch4s3 12y agoAhh, I read it to mean they thought the coursework itself was humiliating, hence my confusion.
- wlesieutre 12y agoI'm honestly just guessing at the meaning (I live in New Haven but have very little association with Yale). There's definitely some history between them. Like the time a group of Yale students dressed up as "Harvard Pep Squad" and got Harvard to do this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Harvard%E2%80%93Yale_prank http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Harvard%E2%80%93Yale_prank
- wffurr 12y agoI took at look at the syllabus[1] and it sure seems to throw students in the deep end! The first week's lecture includes threads and event handling. Later on they cover all kinds of domains such as TCP/IP, tries, and MVC. Those who survive the pace and workload seem like they will have a broad introduction to just about every area of CS. Program By Design[2] used by a bunch of other great CS schools feels gentle by comparison. [1]: https://cdn.cs50.net/2015/spring/lectures/0/w/syllabus/syllabus.html#lectures https://cdn.cs50.net/2015/spring/lectures/0/w/syllabus/sylla... [2]: http://www.programbydesign.org/ http://www.programbydesign.org/
- sukilot 12y agoCS50 was famously changed from "deep end" to "shallow end" several years ago, to make it more accessible to actual newcomers, not just kids who were experts in high school. "Threads and events" are covered very very lightly in lecture 0.
- munchbunny 12y agoStudents characterizing that as humiliating? Sounds a lot like sensationalism. Certainly a Yalie won't want to admit that Harvard got it right, but a good curriculum is a good curriculum.