7 ms·
A Harvard Professor Has Mixed Feelings When Students Take Jobs in Finance
- dnautics 12y agoDoes the professor have similar mixed feelings when students take jobs in politics? What about in the academy? In the sciences 'Grantsmanship' is so often a euphemism rent-seeking.
- sseveran 12y agoI wonder if he has mixed feelings for students who take jobs getting people to click on ads...
- pen2l 12y agoHe does. He's expressed those feelings before (though in a limited manner).
- Balgair 12y agoWhere?
- pen2l 12y agoIn a talk I attended which had him as a speaker. Sorry I don't have a linkable source. Maybe he's written something about it too, I'll link something here if I find something.
- danbruc 12y agoThe entire article is about that. It's not against a specific profession, it's against people happily taking every opportunity to make $101 instead of $100 for themselves even if that additional $1 for them may cost society as a whole $1000.
- throwawaymsft 12y agoIt's easy to trivialize the value that Google, etc. provide, but think about how many businesses can now reach customers (with measurable ROI) that couldn't before. In a previous era they were paying 10-100x as much for newspaper or magazine ads they couldn't track.
- techtivist 12y agoThis reminded me of a great piece in the Atlantic a while ago looking at the cause: "Elite students with few marketable skills are perfect forms for financial firms to mold." http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/02/why-do-so-many-ivy-league-grads-go-to-wall-steet/253245/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/02/why-do-s...
- HarryHirsch 12y agoRequired reading: Karen Ho, Liquidated: An Ethnography of Wall Street https://www.dukeupress.edu/Liquidated https://www.dukeupress.edu/Liquidated
- goodcanadian 12y agoI like the fact that this article identifies that finance serves a purpose, that it can do a lot of good. At the same time, it also recognizes that not all finance is useful or good from a societal point of view. This distinction always seems to get lost in the arguments that result when articles like this are posted on HN. Take HFT, the perennial point of controversy. It is true that it provides liquidity (though, I would suggest not necessarily when you need it), but is it true that more liquidity is always better? At some point, I would argue that the market is liquid enough, and continually pushing the limits of HFT is quite simply rent seeking and may have other detrimental market and/or societal effects. To bring my comment back to the article in question, I have to agree with the author that it is somewhat sad to see people pursue careers in fields of dubious societal value, but if I were offered the paycheque, I would almost certainly take it, too.
- HarryHirsch 12y agobut if I were offered the paycheque, I would almost certainly take it, too One would think everyone would take the paycheck if offered a position on Wall Street. There's almost nothing left that pays equally well.
- tsotha 12y agoI'm not so sure the pay is that much better after you factor in taxes and the cost of living. The difference would have to be enormous before I moved to NYC.
- goodcanadian 12y agoThere are plenty of people for whom money is not the driving factor in their decisions. However, for me, finance is a very interesting field, and I would probably quite happily play the game for a fat paycheque regardless of what I think of the societal value of what I am doing.
- xxxyy 12y agoWell, considering: the extreme working hours (that can in extreme cases result in death, or a psychiatric disease), high risk of exposure to drugs, the fact that the starting banking positions do not pay that much money, the fact that you often do things you absolutely do not care about, well, the answer is not that simple. http://www.businessinsider.com/wall-street-to-silicon-valley-movement-2014-1?IR=T http://www.businessinsider.com/wall-street-to-silicon-valley...
- bduerst 12y agoKind of disappointing. They go on explaining the agency effect side of capitalism's double-edged sword, but never really give any alternatives or solutions. Sure, certain economic behavior, that may not align with the good of society, becomes necessary to survive in a given industry or market - but how would they recommend fixing this? Surely they aren't suggesting that their students throw away rationally beneficial opportunities? I was hoping by the end of the article they would propose something.
- danbruc 12y agoSurely they aren't suggesting that their students throw away rationally beneficial opportunities? They probably should, this is somewhat at the heart of the problem. Economic theory suggest that you will act in the best interest of society if you act in best interest of yourself. But this is obviously not true, there is nothing that justifies the assumption that maximizing your gains will simultaneously maximize gains for society. Quite the opposite is true - improving your gains a tiny bit will often decrease gains for the society as a whole by a disproportional amount.
- icebraining 12y agoEconomic theory suggest that you will act in the best interest for society if you act in best interest for yourself. There are many economic theories, but I don't know any that asserts that in such a general way.
- danbruc 12y agoRight, I was referring mostly to capitalism as we see it in the real world, not economic theories in general. The idea goes back all the way to Adam Smith. And you are of course also correct that if you look closely at what people have said you will not find such a generic assertion because it is so obviously wrong that nobody would dare to assert it. But then look at reality. People cherry-pick the bits and pieces that make their actions look good and ignore the rest.
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- HorizonXP 12y agoAt the end, the professor writes about the fact that lower income folks typically have variable income levels, yet still have to pay rent, forcing them to resort to payday loans. There is a startup called Even that is trying to help with that problem: https://whatiseven.com https://whatiseven.com
- mrdmnd 12y agoResisting urge to register https://whatisthisicanteven.com https://whatisthisicanteven.com.
- icebraining 12y agoInterest-free loans to people with low incomes for $12/month. I wonder how they're financing that, and still making money.
- technotony 12y agoIt depends on the loan size. If the loan is $1000 then that's 1.2% interest per month. They can make money with that, and maybe their average loan size is smaller than that in which case the effective APR is even higher.
- dragonwriter 12y agoEven expressly does not provide loans; since it uses an undisclosed algorithm to calculate "averages" that are expressly not actual averages, they can probably guarantee that they are more likely to be taking in funds that are above the "average" than paying out for below "average"; with an undisclosed algorithm, they could even guarantee that you can never receive more in "Boosts" than you've paid in previous deductions. They also don't seem sure what their fee is -- their ToS says $5/week, other parts of the site say $3/wk.
- mzzk 12y agoThis will not cure any "low income folks" woes. Simply averaging the paychecks will not help the fact unexpected issues arise... or the fact that they don't earn enough to live a simple life. This service at $3 is silly.
- jpmattia 12y ago> But the winners of the 1956 Nobel Prize in Physics, John Bardeen, Walter H. Brattain and William B. Shockley, who have been widely credited with inventing the semiconductor, did not receive even a fraction of the wealth that their invention would help create. I don't know about Bardeen or Brattain, but this was not because Shockley was an altruist. The fact that he could not capitalize on his inventions like he thought he should was a source of frustration for him. Source: Conversation with someone he expressed frustration to.
- jeffwass 12y agoOut of curiosity, has anyone heard similar frustrations from the authors of major open source code bases? Eg, has Linus ever felt frustrated by all the millionaire tech company founders that built their product using Linux and/or Git, but didn't open it up as he did with those two projects?
- eldude 12y agoThere's a presumption here that there's an objective "good" for society, likely as defined by this professor. One of the primary virtues of capitalism is that it makes no such presumption and empowers and frees disparate tribes to pursue their own "good" within the bounds of a constructive construct. Correspondingly, one of the vices(?) of socialism is the presumption of a single societal good. This of course makes sense when we have non-reproducible/limited resources like the environment or rights that could conflict like the use of force, but for all other resources like how we spend our lives, what we build, where we go, what we enjoy, freedom by definition means a subjective "good". I always find it curious when postmodernism (skepticism of societal mores) presumes any form of objective truth.
- netheril96 12y agoI was once adamant to become a researcher in physics, until I realized how difficult it is for any one to stay in that field. There are so many much more intelligent people vying for a single professorship, and most have no stability as they constantly hop from one post-doc position to another. I left physics to become a software developer and I did not regret a bit. So the truth is, the world does not need or can afford that many people researching cancer, teach and inspire the next generation. Quit lamenting that people are leaving these fields. They are already overcrowded.
- rwallace 12y agoI agree with your last sentence, but not your third last. Society could easily afford to invest far more in research than it does, and the investment would be repaid many times over; unfortunately it has not chosen to do so. I don't believe this is a fundamental choice. People really do want things like clean energy and cures for cancer. It's just that the issue of adequately funding such has slipped down the cracks of politics. If your comparative advantage is in politics, I would recommend that as the single most important potentially solvable problem of our time. If your comparative advantage is in STEM, mind you, I think it's perfectly sensible to stay out of the rat race for the handful of physics professor jobs and become a programmer or petroleum engineer instead.
- dnautics 12y ago> People really do want things like clean energy and cures for cancer. No, people SAY they want these things (because maybe it makes them feel good or because it gives them social capital). But when it comes time to actually put their hands in their pockets and give, they come short. I know this since I tried to crowd-fund for cancer research. It was hard. I got barely enough. I'm still backing the project out of my own pocket to the tune of 10-20%. I've had my nonprofit website (with a donation link) on my lyft line profile for a week. I've had about 10-20 good conversations about what i'm doing. My conversion rate? 0%. In this time, I have had zero dollars donated to my nonprofit. It's ok - I am well within budget for my project.... But I'm just saying that it is facile to say people want these things but in the end one really wonders. Fact of the matter is, that politics is not very good at funding these things either. A lot of grantsmanship goes into twisting your expertise to allow the bureaucrats to dispense their money into your project. There is very little accountability, and the administrators are trained in the same system that creates the professors, (and reviews the journal articles) so it is a bit of an echo chamber.
- kelukelugames 12y agoI wonder how all of my EE professors feel that I dropped out of the academia track to be a code monkey for $$$.
- marincounty 12y agoIn my little world "Rent-Seeking" individuals have always been around. Personally, I couldn't stomach making money off the poor, animals, or the environment, but for some people it just doesn't matter how they make their money. "If it's legal, I see nothing wrong with it?". They are in such denial, some think they are cute? The one's in my little world think no one knows, but we do know. You can be the Doctor who charges too much for addictive meds, the non-profit director who makes a very comfortable living off other people misery.(free preview Guidestar.), or the rich kid who made millions off plastic tooth picks(which don't decompose) and moved to another state to get away from daddy(inventor, funder, bank, cheerleader), dodge taxes, and act like Horatio Alger. What I want to talk about is Payday loans. We need something else. My first introduction to these leach pits is when I drove a co-worker to the pit. She cashed a check for under $200 and was charged close to twenty dollars. (I tried to explain how she was being exploited, but she was just tired. Tired of life. I didn't give her a lecture. It was not the time--she just climbed out of Homelessness.) Elisabeth Warren has a good idea on replacing PayDay loans. http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2014/02/03/3239261/elizabeth-warren-post-office-financial-services/ http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2014/02/03/3239261/elizabet... (Sorry about the popup, and remember Payday loans are not always dischargable in Bankruptcy court. The payday loan lender may challenge the discharge of its debt, and it might violate the law if you've written a post-dated check.)
- iAMjoseph 12y agoI wonder if this is more of a higher education ecosystem problem of survival. Smart Universities know the winds of change are coming. Up until recently, Ivy League educations acted as a "proxy" of future success to employers in the industrialized world. Once more short-term apprenticeship-type learning start getting "accredited" (hack reactor, Udemy, etc.) and talent recruiters adopt the new reality - the traditional University will begin to become irrelevant. Their only hope to survive is to make surefire bets on privileged background applicants who will become alumni gifters to keep the veiled Ponzi scheme going. An assertion can be made that these types of candidates following a rote program for their life since birth may have wrote about how they want to change the world in their applications (or hired somebody else to write them). But, this very same background created an entity that no longer can think creatively and keeps following the path. Some awaken. Most do not. There is a strong argument that transformational leaders who truly change the world and are not good at what "school" says what we should be good at, and don't think about education in this way. For example, many of these folks surely would not have been accepted at the Ivy Leagues: ( http://www.onlinecollege.org/2010/02/16/50-famously-successful-people-who-failed-at-first/ http://www.onlinecollege.org/2010/02/16/50-famously-successf... )
- alexashka 12y agoLooking through the comments here, I can't help but feel like folks are missing the forest by looking at individual trees in the article. It doesn't matter if you go into finance or washing cars - it's the mentality that you have toward life and others. It is the short sightedness that we are born with, that breeds selfishness and leads us down the path of ignorance that the author laments. The idea of 'get mine, worry about the rest later' attitude. That's a child's attitude. When there's unrest in the minds of parents, they worry and urge their children to go for the sure thing. That's ok. But do they remind their kids that once you land a good job and make a living, that there's more to it than that? That if you're going to do something, do it well? That if you're in a good place, be nice, be humble? I don't know. I've seen the mass media apparatus grow more and more desperate, risk averse and pathetic to please their lords of 'More money, more! Or else there's somebody else in line who will make more and replace you!' It's become so bad even the modern billionaires (Bill Gates, Warren Buffett and others) are devoting time to trying to fix the system. We're going toward recognizing we have to be supportive of one another and Americans have poisoned their own well of compassion while fighting against the Soviet Union. 'Communism' is a bad word and as soon as you speak of doing something positive and broad for others without getting 10x returns on your investment, people associate it with communism and have a sour taste in their mouth. There's no quick solution that I can see in sight but the idea of only doing things for profit has to go. Just stop, be nice, be humble, learn, give and receive. When you get sick, that money isn't going to buy you friends and family who sit by your side and care for you.
- jamin1 12y agoTestimony how i got my loan from Taylor Walker in US. I’m Jamin Rodger by name. I live in CANADA, i want to use this medium to alert all loan seekers to be very careful because there are scam everywhere. Few months ago I was financially strained, and due to my desperation I was scammed by several online lenders. I had almost lost hope until a friend of mine referred me to a very reliable lender called Taylor Walker Loan Company from US, who lend me an unsecured loan of $75,000 under 24Hours without any stress. If you are in need of any kind of loan just contact him now via email: 3067516878@qq.com or info.taylorwalker@qq.com or SMS them at: +1 (302) 5853970 I‘m using this medium to alert all loan seekers because of the hell I passed through in the hands of those fraudulent lenders. And I don’t wish even my enemy to pass through such hell that I passed through in the hands of those fraudulent online lenders,i will also want you to help me pass this information to others who are also in need of a loan once you have also receive your loan from Taylor Walker Loan Company from US. I pray that God should give him long life. Once again contact them via email: 3067516878@qq.com or info.taylorwalker@qq.com or SMS them at: +1 (302) 5853970 thank you.