5 ms·
I won't down vote you for that, I have no problem with questioning the political reasons why wars are waged. But that doesn't stop me also honouring the men an
by jgrahamc 17y ago
I won't down vote you for that, I have no problem with questioning the political reasons why wars are waged. But that doesn't stop me also honouring the men and women who fight in them. To me these things are quite distinct.
So, I might think that Britain's involvement in Iraq was a mistake and should not have happened, but I would shake the hand of any British serviceman who served there and thank them for doing so.
- Periodic 17y agoI think some don't realize that they should separate the soldiers who fight the wars from those who make the policy and decisions about where and when and what to fight. Our service men and women are committed to fighting to better our country and the world. They trust their superiors to make the right decisions. You can disagree with the bad decisions of those superiors, but the service men and women will be there fighting regardless of whether it was right or wrong because the cost of missing the right call is too high. Honor the troops, not the politicians.
- prodigal_erik 17y ago> service men and women will be there fighting regardless of whether it was right or wrong because the cost of missing the right call is too high Thank you, this is the first time I've seen it argued the people enlisting realize and accept the country is likely to squander their time and risk their lives over nothing worthy of them. I could never reconcile their somehow overlooking that with the dedication they bring to the work.
- david 17y agoAs if the cost of carrying out the wrong call isn't too high either? The worst case isn't that soldiers' time is squandered or that they risk their lives over nothing worthy, it's that they kill and destroy needlessly, but I guess we don't really tend to come to terms with that fact as well as the people we're fighting.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoYou can disagree with the bad decisions of those superiors, but the service men and women will be there fighting regardless of whether it was right or wrong Apologies for invoking Godwin's Law, but this is quite precisely where the analogy is applicable. From The Twilight Zone episode "Death's Head Revisited": "They just heard you offer the apology for all the monsters of our time . We did as we were told, we functioned as ordered, we merely carried out directives from our superiors. Familiar, is it, Captain? It was the Nazi theme music at Nuremburg. The new lyrics to the Gotterdammerung. The plaintive litany of the master race as it laid dying. We did not do, others did, or someone else did it. We never even knew it was being done or We did it, but others told us to." I now cringingly await the downvotes.
- david 17y agoThe politicians only exist because of the troops. The republican party isn't going to launch an attack against you themselves just because you didn't follow the rules.
- gloob 17y agoI'm rather the other way around; I've never really understood why some people see them as being meaningfully distinct. For example: would we make the same distinction between the bureaucrats and policymakers in China, and the programmers who make the Great Firewall actually work? From my perspective, the person who actually carries out the action, not the one who tells them to, is the one who is responsible for it, good or bad. We don't praise politicians when a firefighter does their job; why should we blame the politicians when a soldier does theirs? Not that I pretend to understand any of it, mind you. God knows I have no bloody clue what it's like to be in a war, so perhaps I'm entirely off-base.
- gcheong 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment
- gloob 17y agoMilgram's experiment, provided it is correct, demonstrates that people like to pretend they are not responsible for their own actions. This result is orthogonal to the question of who is responsible (not who we want to think is responsible) for the action. Edit: We are, of course, assuming the existence of some objective notion of "responsibility" here, which is a point that could be debated. That said, I think I'm going off topic now, so I'll be quiet.
- wizzard 17y agoUnfortunately a lot of people can't afford to be picky about how they earn a living. I bet a lot of people on HN have stories about working for sleazy companies and having to do things they didn't believe in. People enlist in the military for many different reasons. I've never heard anyone say they joined because they enjoy killing people.
- gloob 17y agoApologies if I came across as being judgemental about it - I'm not, really. My personality doesn't suit the military, and I'm lucky enough to be able to find employment elsewhere, but obviously there are people for whom one or both of those is not true. Fair enough. (As an aside, I'm not going to comment on the moral legitimacy or lack thereof of soldiers, wars, etc., because in this context it's more a matter of personal moral beliefs than anything else.) What bothers me is the notion that people are not responsible for their own actions.
- qc 17y agoI have never followed that logic. If a mob boss orders a henchman to kill a rival, who should be prosecuted for murder? I would feel that it should be both. I cannot see how it should be the mob boss and not the henchman. I also struggle to see how the henchman should be honored.
- andreyf 17y agoThe henchman should be honored, because without the honor, there would be no reason for the henchman to kill - the personal risk is too great, and the personal reward too little. But the mob as a whole clearly benefits from killing rivals, so by introducing honor (which, for someone without it, is worth a lot), everyone can expect a positive payout (except for the rival). I think you'd probably object to my ignoring the totality of the situation - a murder has been committed. But what's the harm in murder as long as it's happening external to "our civilization"?
- TrevorJ 17y agoPacifism works if everyone in the world is a pacifist. Barring that, there always exists the possibility of a situation where you will have the blood of many on your hands by refusing to take action against a single person.
- Radix 17y agoPeriodic hit on it when they said "the service men and women will be there fighting regardless of whether it was right or wrong because the cost of missing the right call is too high." I believe those who hold that logic, myself included, have different expectations of the responsibilities of the soldier and the henchman. The soldier is in a strict hierarchical organization that demands its members follow orders for the organization to continue operating. Members lower in the organization are expected to begin working before they understand why, so they aren't held responsible for everything they do. The henchman may also be a part of an organization like that, but he is just another citizen, working for his organization and own betterment, and is expected to be responsible for his actions. Also, he can hardly say that his organization is working on behalf of his entire nation, as the soldier can. edit: I should add, that this perspective does eventually reach a breaking point as time passes servicemen begin to see what the goals of their leaders are, and if they disagree with them then they may be obligated, morally or otherwise, to excuse themselves or switch sides. Looking back at your comment I see that you're speaking of henchman and mob bosses only, but as a proxy for state leaders and the military. But my point is that people don't see them the same.
- joecode 17y agoWhile, say, the outright cruel attacks by some anti-Vietnam protestors to returning vets was unhelpful, I don't see why I should celebrate people who are fighting wars of conquest for the sake of oil. I don't think they're bad people, and understand that they probably imagine they are fighting to protect our freedom, but I think, if anything, I do them a disservice by honoring their violent actions, however well-intentioned they may be.
- david 17y agoThat doesn't really make sense. The only reason Britains involvement in Iraq was possible is because there were a bunch of servicemen ready to go out and murder for the man. What exactly are you thanking the serviceman for if not for carrying out acts you oppose? And how are we ever going to stop politicians from starting some pretty horrendous wars if we can only thank the armies who's job is to carry out their orders, no matter how awful.