3 ms·
RMS is supporting buying the book directly from the publisher. But what if they are running IIS on the server, or Flash on their front-end? Doesn't this mean th
by bdcravens 12y ago
RMS is supporting buying the book directly from the publisher. But what if they are running IIS on the server, or Flash on their front-end? Doesn't this mean that he is recommending the use of proprietary software?
- teddyh 12y agoSuppose that RMS supported something like buying organic food directly from farmers. Would you then pose the question “What if a farmer is a mass murderer or a terrorist? Would that mean that RMS is supporting terrorism?”
- dragonwriter 12y agoI think what you miss is that RMS has argued against other things on the exact kind of indirect support for non-free software argument as was directed at his recommendation to buy directly from publishers; it rests on RMS's use of that criticism rather than the assumption that the criticism is valid.
- teddyh 12y agoThe argument as you descibe it sounds silly, and to believe that RMS used it I would have to see a citation. Even so, if he used it, he would be wrong. I argued against the argument as presented, I can’t be expected to know whether it was subtle sarcasm or not.
- bdcravens 12y agoRMS has been pretty cut-and-dry about proprietary software. For instance, he won't use document types that encourage proprietary software use (even when free alternatives exist). So to answer your question, if RMS was a staunch anti-terrorist advocate, and it was guaranteed that a percentage of organic farmers were terrorists, then it would be perfectly reasonable to pose that question.
- teddyh 12y agoThe analogy breaks down thusly: The non-terrorist farmers are neutral, but the web servers not running proprietary software are, by definition, running free software – i.e. they are not neutral, they are the opposite of proprietary. The web is not something that, inherently, suggests use of proprietary software, so I don’t see a similar reason for RMS to discourage use of the web in the same way he discourages .doc format files. A .doc file or a .swf file very much suggests specific proprietary software, even though free alternatives exist. Not so with .html, .css and .js.