3 ms·
I am taking it seriously, else I wouldn't have bothered replying to a blank 'i disagree' post with a polite request that you contribute to the discussion. The q
by nailer 17y ago
I am taking it seriously, else I wouldn't have bothered replying to a blank 'i disagree' post with a polite request that you contribute to the discussion. The question is quite genuine - where in your view does the need for redundancy stop?
- jacquesm 17y agoBraces have a very practical level of redundancy, they cost literally next to nothing in terms of effort and reduce a whole class of errors to 'impossible'. Let me give you a simple example, in two psuedo languages, one with and one without braces: if a > b a = a + 5 b = b / 2 if (a > 0) { a = a + 5 b = b / 2 } vs if a > b a = a + 5 b = b / 2 or if (a > b) { a = a + 5 b = b / 2 } Even though the text is similarly corrupted (for whatever reason) the redundancy in the second example makes it clear that something is amiss, you could even lose the second brace and still at least know that all is not kosher in that segment. That's not 'ascii art', that's functional. Redundancy definitely has it's uses. I'm going to do some digging later on and find a bunch of examples of broken code due to cut & paste problems, some of it on the django site, no less. That's something that would never happen in C or any other 'overspecified' language. And regarding 'finding that matching bracket' that is exactly what they're for, if you can't match the bracket chances are that you really do have a problem in the code.
- nailer 17y agoIf you've spent any time with Python, it should be immediately clear that: if a > b a = a + 5 b = b / 2 is quite different from: if a > b a = a + 5 b = b / 2 Without needing a second markup for the compiler to emphasize the point.
- jacquesm 17y agoOf course it is clear that they are different, that was not the point of the argument... The point is that you can't know which one was the one that was meant to be written there in the first place, and all that changed is some literally invisible characters are gone. It's like with comments and code, if a comment says 'add two volumes' and I see that the code does not do that then I have a hint that something is not correct. It could be the comment or it could be the code, but there is something smelly there. Redundancy = good.
- nailer 17y ago'all that changed is some literally invisible characters are gone.' Er, no. That's not the extent of the changes at all: the very visible code has shifted to the left. I refuse to believe you cannot see that with your own eyes. 'The point is that you can't know which one was the one that was meant to be written there in the first place' In any language at all, the lack of indentation makes it quite clear the intention is different.
- pohl 17y agoYou've lost sight of jacquesm's premise, which is when 1) the intention is not accurately reflected by the indentation, and 2) does not break the syntax of the language. You asked what benefit might come from the redundancy of a curly brace, and this was a scenario in response.
- nailer 17y agoWhen the intention is not reflected by the indentation, you need to fix that, in every programming language. Python also has the handy benefit of telling you this immediately. jacquesm's statement about the visible difference is obviously false. However I don't think it's doing anyone any good to keep contributing on this topic. All I was doing was making a suggestion to improve something. The troll who posted 'no' with no arguments has a bunch of supporters, I'm being moderated down to nothing. You're not responding to my points, and you seem to think I'm not listening to you, though I'm trying to understand what you're saying. I give up, this isn't worth it.
- pohl 17y agoI'm only guessing, but the downmods may actually be because of disingenuous rhetoric. Example: "you need to fix that, in every programming language." This problem only exists if indentation is significant in the language as a way of demarcating blocks. This is exactly the reason for the suggested syntactic redundancy. A reasonable person can accept the tradeoff, but it's not reasonable to insist that the tradeoff isn't there at all. Edit: the proposed scenario is readable code. It is, in fact, disingenuous to ignore that. It isn't candid to claim apathy, either.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]