3 ms·
It doesn't sound like he's talking about the "future" of broadcasting but the present; specifically, that broadcast music in 1931 is worthless because the repro
by PhasmaFelis 12y ago
It doesn't sound like he's talking about the "future" of broadcasting but the present; specifically, that broadcast music in 1931 is worthless because the reproduction quality is too poor. He doesn't say anything specific about the future of broadcasting, but he seems fine with the idea of music reproduction in general, so we can only assume that he would be happier with broadcast music of a higher quality.
- pfunk 12y ago> 'On this account alone, I deplore the present depression in the gramophone industry. It is a curious fact that when I began working for H.M.V. ten years ago business was excellent, though only indifferent records were available. Yet today, when we have first class recording, business is worse than it has ever been. For this, I can only think that the universal craze for radio is to blame. ' He's blaming the recent success of radio for poor record sales in 1931. Much like many were/are blaming streaming and youtube for the decline of record sales now...
- __david__ 12y agoSure, but he's not lamenting the fact that his record sales are down, he's annoyed that something with crap music quality (in his opinion) is supplanting something with superior music quality. Luckily, radio's gotten better since then. :-)
- gpvos 12y agoInterestingly, he seems to only speak of live concert radio broadcasts, not about playing gramophone records for broadcast, which would have the same artistic advantages (choosing the best recording) that he described. In 1931 they only had AM broadcasting, which indeed has crap audio quality, especially when the radio band is crowded. FM broadcasting started in the late 1930s.
- gwbas1c 12y agoI wonder if he used to make multiple takes and then pick the best one? Perhaps back then there was a lot of trail-and-error in the recording process? Certainly, if radio was glitchy or temperamental back then, there was no way to go back and do another take. In contrast, today's "live" recordings can be edited afterwards.
- untothebreach 12y agoFrom the article: > If once, twice or three times I do not play as well as I can, it is possible to record and re-record, to destroy and remake until, at last, I am content with the result.