3 ms·
I don't agree with the fact that programming can't be taught. However, I also can't overcome 12+ years of (mis-)education in one semester. There was an articl
by bsder 12y ago
I don't agree with the fact that programming can't be taught. However, I also can't overcome 12+ years of (mis-)education in one semester.
There was an article posted that showed that you could predict performance in introductory CS from a single test given at the beginning of the semester. There were 3 groups:
1) the group who understood about rules, applying them to a computing system and had the correct interpretation of them--they did well unsurprisingly.
2) the group who understood about rules, applied them consistently, but simply had the wrong rules internalized. They did well after being taught since all you had to do was correct the wrong rules.
3) the group who simply didn't have any logical understanding of how to apply underlying rules to a system--they simply failed miserably. To teach these people CS, you first have to teach these people logical cause/effect thought. This is so fundamental a building block that you can't possibly cover it in a CS course. So, to a first approximation, these people actually can't be taught because you have to fix something else first.
And, that problem, I suspect, is actually buried in the article:
"give me a fake problem, and I don’t think it’s worth my time; my brain shuts off. I suspect a lot of people (especially women) are like me."
When faced with this situation, some of us get told: "Tough. Suck it up. You don't always get to do interesting things, and you have to succeed even if it's boring." Others of us get sympathized with and are allowed to slack with excuses like "Math is hard; I wasn't any good at it either." A couple iterations of this and you wind up with a gap in final achievement even though there is no gap in initial ability.
If I were throwing around stereotypes like the author, I would say that "Men get told to suck it up or get out. Women get sympathy and are allowed to stay and make excuses." And thus you wind up with an achievement gap between men and women.