4 ms·
That quote is a bit misleading when taken out of context. Early in the war, there were a lot of conservative Northern Democrats who felt that, while crushing t
by smacktoward 12y ago
That quote is a bit misleading when taken out of context.
Early in the war, there were a lot of conservative Northern Democrats who felt that, while crushing the rebellion was a valid war aim, going beyond that to emancipation of the slaves was not. They felt that insisting on emancipation would poison any chance of ever reintegrating the South into the Union. Since Lincoln was the first President ever elected by the then-new Republican party, which had a strong pro-emancipation faction, these conservatives tended to view Lincoln as a potentially dangerous radical whose ideology could potentially sabotage the war effort.
At the war's opening Lincoln tended to agree with them. But a year of hard fighting that saw a string of Northern defeats changed his thinking. He began to feel that only by embracing a higher goal than political union could the North seize the moral high ground it would need to keep its people from giving up in frustration. So he slowly began to swing towards emancipation.
However, it was critical while he was making that swing that word of it not leak out, since if it was revealed prematurely, without the right buildup, it could shock the conservatives into bolting from the national unity coalition of Republicans and Democrats together that he had assembled at the start of the war. So even as he was drafting what became the Emancipation Proclamation, he was furiously insisting to anyone who asked that he intended nothing of the sort. (The quote you cited comes from an open letter Lincoln wrote during this period to a prominent conservative New York newspaper editor named Horace Greeley as part of this PR effort -- see http://www.nytimes.com/1862/08/24/news/letter-president-lincoln-reply-horace-greeley-slavery-union-restoration-union.html http://www.nytimes.com/1862/08/24/news/letter-president-linc...)
It worked, at least as well as it needed to work; while the conservatives never really trusted Lincoln, they couldn't ever pin him down on the slavery issue either. And by the time he revealed his shift, it was clear to everyone that the conservatives' dream that the South could be reconciled with sweet words and restraint was a fantasy -- the South was in earnest, they were playing for keeps, and the only way they would be brought back into the union was with fire and sword.
- vacri 12y agoThis being said, there is a big difference between 'ending slavery' and 'full equality'. For example. white women in the US at the time weren't slaves, but they weren't 'fully equal'. They couldn't vote, for example.
- smacktoward 12y agoWell yes, and the question of what exactly emancipation would mean in practice would eventually end up splitting the Republican Party between "let 'em up easy" men like Lincoln who advocated imposing as little change on the South as possible, and "radical Republicans" like Thaddeus Stevens who wanted to go so far as erase the old Southern states off the map and divide the conquered South into military districts run by the Federal government. (After Lincoln's death the Radicals won the argument by default, and more or less ran things for the next ten years.) But that didn't come until a couple of years later.
- shaftoe 12y agoIgnoring the issue of slavery for a moment (which the North was not initially attempting to abolish), did they have any right to force the South to "be brought back into the union with fire and sword?" Can lawfully elected governments not dissolve political bonds? What makes a government not even 70 years old so important that cities must be razed and hundreds of thousands killed to preserve it? Was it even preserved when half the country was in a military dictatorship?
- pnut 12y agoThe entire US Civil War was the asking and unambiguous answering of your question. What makes a government of any age so important is that a military rebellion was attempted directly against the national government, and was brutally put down. I can't imagine any US President just standing aside, it would be a treasonous abdication of constitutional responsibility.
- mikeash 12y agoThere is ultimately no law and no right between nations, except persuasion and force. The moment the South separated, they willingly subjected themselves to that. If they wanted someone to step in and say, hey, you can't do that, then they should have remained a part of the system that provided exactly that. You can't declare yourself a separate nation, then get upset when you're treated like it.
- selimthegrim 12y agoIf you try to ground Southern secession in standard international law principles of self-determination and consider it at the state level you run into problems of both white franchise and....er another 3/5th of a problem rather quickly....
- Apocryphon 12y agoWell, one could always say that the South fired first by shelling Fort Sumter. They drew first blood.
- xenadu02 12y ago
- ancap 12y agoI don't see how the quote has been taken out of context. That quote among many others make it very clear that Lincoln never was in favor of "full equality for black citizens". At the beginning of his presidency he promoted an amendment to the constitution which would have permanently protect slavery and forbid it from being outlawed. On another occasion he suggested that blacks should be exiled back to Africa. I could cite many more of his words making it abundantly clear he was not in favor of black equality. If Lincoln did not hold this "most ambitious aim" for the war, then who, having any say in the war, did? Why did not the persons holding this alleged aim, stop the mass rape and murder of "freed" slaves in the south by the Union liberators? Even the much extolled Emancipation Proclamation did not end slavery--only in the confederate states. It was a military strategy. >...national unity coalition of Republicans and Democrats Why, if there was such a coalition, was it necessary for Lincoln to ignore the supreme court's decision against the illegal ending of habeus corpus, arrest and exile a congress man, and imprison countless northern journalists who wrote opposing the war?
- smacktoward 12y ago> At the beginning of his presidency he promoted an amendment to the constitution which would have permanently protect slavery and forbid it from being outlawed. There were several such measures being mooted during the "secession crisis" of 1861, when the Southern states were still in the union but threatening to pull out. (See, for example, the Corwin Amendment: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corwin_Amendment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corwin_Amendment) They were all desperate attempts to forestall secession by pre-emptively giving the South what it was thought they wanted. Once secession went from being a threat to an actual fact, there was no point to such measures anymore, and they were all quickly dropped. Given the scope of the tragedy that the war would bring, it's not hard to have sympathy for leaders who grasped for something, anything, that could stop it from happening. But that's all these proposals were -- frantic attempts to head off a looming disaster. They don't reflect actual policy preferences. > On another occasion he suggested that blacks should be exiled back to Africa. Indeed, he did raise the issue of "colonization" (as it was called at the time) at several points early in his presidency. It's not like he invented the idea; it was a common proposal among Northern conservatives, among whom the only thing less popular than black slavery was black people themselves. But he never pushed it hard, because it was the conservatives' idea, not really his; and besides, nobody was enthusiastic about it, least of all Northern blacks. His Administration never put the muscle behind it they put behind, say, passing the 13th Amendment. > I could cite many more of his words making it abundantly clear he was not in favor of black equality. You're conflating black emancipation with black equality, which to white 19th century Americans were two very different things. Emancipation was broadly popular in the North, but that didn't mean Northerners saw blacks as their equals in any real respect. They thought they were inferior creatures, but inferior creatures who shouldn't be enslaved. Lincoln never got to the point where he embraced equality as strongly as he embraced emancipation, but by the end of the war he'd gotten closer to it than any other American statesman of his age -- or of the next 100 years, for that matter. Certainly he felt more for African-Americans as human beings than did any President for decades after. > Why, if there was such a coalition, was it necessary for Lincoln to ignore the supreme court's decision against the illegal ending of habeus corpus, arrest and exile a congress man, and imprison countless northern journalists who wrote opposing the war? Because there was a civil war going on, and as a practical fact he had to keep border states like Maryland and Kentucky from being dragged out of the union if he wanted to win it. There was no way around that fact. To lose the border states would have been to lose the whole game. So, when hardness was necessary, he was willing to be hard.