4 ms·
Does anyone have any thoughts how Xylitol or Erythritol might fare under a study like this? They're currently my go to sweeteners. I'm not sure why they're no
by mrfusion 12y ago
Does anyone have any thoughts how Xylitol or Erythritol might fare under a study like this? They're currently my go to sweeteners. I'm not sure why they're not more popular.
- drawkbox 12y agoAdd to that sorbitol. I like gum and and many brands like Orbit use it. Biggest side effect is it is actually a laxative in larger doses and some people have abdominal pain probably due to that (http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/568700 http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/568700). Erythritol seems like the best sweetner though with minimal side effects under 50mg per day.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoBoth of those are sugar alcohols, and as such have laxative effects, among other things. But no idea how they'd fare under this sort of study.
- AndyNemmity 12y agoXylitol is not more popular because a tiny dose will kill a dog. I use it as well, but am very careful with it. I treat it essentially like poison.
- amputect 12y agoSugar alcohols can have some unpleasant side effects, which make them unpopular for general use. They can cause bloating, flatulence, and diarrhea if you consume too much of them. The pop-culture example of this is the review section on http://www.amazon.com/Haribo-Sugar-Free-Gummy-Bears/dp/B008JELLCA http://www.amazon.com/Haribo-Sugar-Free-Gummy-Bears/dp/B008J..., or in a less ridiculous form at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xylitol#Safety and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythritol#Side_effects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythritol#Side_effects. That's not at all to say they're bad or poison; I love sugar-free gum a lot, but the amount of sugar alcohol in each piece is very low. The problem is just that the side effects mean that if they're widely used, eventually someone is going to crap themselves and blame your product, and almost nobody wants that.
- mrfusion 12y agoI put two tbsp of xylitol into my smoothies and I've never had a problem. It's also supposed to be good for your teeth. I do wonder how something can be so dangerous for dogs and safe for humans. Aren't our cells almost identical?
- amputect 12y agoYeah, xylitol inhibits bacterial growth in the mouth. I like it in gum, it seems to help me. It seems like different people have different tolerances for xylitol to some extent; I know that my wife, who is much smaller than me, has a higher absolute tolerance than I do (i.e. if we eat the same amount without accounting for body weight, I will experience discomfort and she will not). I'm not a vet but I'm waiting on some batch tests at work so I did some reading. According to http://veterinarymedicine.dvm360.com/new-findings-effects-xylitol-ingestion-dogs http://veterinarymedicine.dvm360.com/new-findings-effects-xy..., dogs absorb Xylitol much more quickly than rats or humans do. Xylitol also provokes dogs to release insulin, but not people. The reasons behind that are not completely clear to me, but since they quickly and completely absorb Xylitol, they end up producing a ton of insulin very quickly which tanks their blood glucose levels. That's dangerous without any complicating factors. Additionally, dogs metabolize xylitol differently, and it's thought that a side effect of the metabolization is to deplete adenosine triphosphate in the liver, which can cause liver necrosis (obviously very bad news). Humans don't absorb xylitol well (it's only partially digestible and some of it acts as dietary fiber, sort of), and we don't metabolize what we do absorb very efficiently. The difference is likely in both the dose relative to body weight, and the intensity (since dogs metabolize it much faster and more completely). That's all secondhand info though, I don't have a JSTOR or equivalent account so I couldn't read any interesting primary papers. If we coincidentally have a vet wandering through I'd love to learn more about this.
- lnufnu 12y agoYou can adapt to xylitol in your diet. It is best to introduce it slowly into your diet. Chewing gum is a great way to use it daily and increase your intake over time. Dental recommendations are 6-10 grams per day, but most people would experience discomfort starting off at that amount.
- lnufnu 12y agoXylitol is probably the best sugar alternative you can use. Dr. Ellie Phillips promotes it in her book Kiss Your Dentist Goodbye because the reseach has demonstrated that harmful bacteria are unable to utilize it for energy. I would assume since this is why it is beneficial to use in oral products, it would also provide the same benefits for stomach bacteria. It seems that erythritol is also unable to be used for energy. This is not true for all sugar alcohols; after exposure to sorbitol over a short period, bacteria can adapt to use it as an energy source. It also can contribute to reflux.