6 ms·
Forcing farmers out because new residents weren't smart enough in scouting their new home location is stupid. That said, I'm not sure I can muster any indignat
by kbenson 12y ago
Forcing farmers out because new residents weren't smart enough in scouting their new home location is stupid.
That said, I'm not sure I can muster any indignation that hunters can't hunt as much, or that the first day of hunting season is not "literally a school holiday" anymore.
- chrisbennet 12y agoI used to belong to a local Fish and Game club that had skeet shooting fields. (Skeet are fun to shoot but the meat is very tough.) The club was forced to close the shooting ranges due to neighbors that moved into the area around the club because they didn't like the noise. The club had been shooting there for 80 years before that...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- avn2109 12y agoVery, very tough.
- kbenson 12y agoMy apathy stems from the act of hunting a live animal. While I understand hunting for food for survival, hunting for sport or hunting for food when it's not essential doesn't sit well with me. As for an overpopulated animal, I imagine there must be a better way to deal with that than allowing people to shoot them. Don't get me wrong, I'm not some bleeding heart when it comes to animals, they aren't all perfect snowflakes of uniqueness, I don't don't see the reason to cause an animal that can feel pain to feel that pain without a good cause. To me, "we've been doing it for generations" is not a good cause. Edit: I'm still interested in having this discussion, but preferably along one of the established threads sprouting from this, unless the point of view hasn't been covered in a reply. There's as little point in me replying the same thing multiple times as there is in having multiple replies to this stating the same thing, but that doesn't mean there aren't interesting things to be said on this topic.
- ta82828 12y agoWould it help if someone pointed out that wild animals will eventually die in pain whether hunters shoot them or not? There are no vets in the wild to give them morphine to put them down when they get too old to survive. They will either get sick, starve, or get eaten.
- kbenson 12y agoFirstly, that's a rather odd argument. I wouldn't assume I could kill some old or sickly person in some remote region of the world where there were no doctors. Why does the same logic not apply to an animal? It may not apply, but at least make the case, rather than leaving it an assumption. Secondly, I'm not sure how we can assume that the old and sickly animals are the ones being killed when humans hunt. I would assume it's a statistically higher percentage of them, but I would also assume it much less statistically relevant than with a bow, and that less than with a spear. On the other end of the spectrum, I would imagine killing deer by dropping a bomb on them would result in no statistical difference in the kills compared to the normal herd make-up. Technology lessens the "we kill the old and sickly" argument.
- baddox 12y ago> As for an overpopulated animal, I imagine there must be a better way to deal with that than allowing people to shoot them. Any ideas? I imagine the main causes of death for deer are predation (by humans, or other animals depending on location), and getting hit by cars. I imagine the latter is at least as painful as the former on average, and the latter also kills and injures a lot of humans.
- kbenson 12y agoWell, the problem is that we messed up the ecosystem by removing the predators. I'm not sure how well reintroducing the predators would work, I'm sure there's some evidence to be found. It's an interesting, and hard, problem. I was very specific in my wording. It started as "There are better ways" and changed to "I imagine there must be a better way" before submitting precisely because I think it is a hard problem, but I'm confident there's some answer that's better that shooting with guns. Even if there isn't, it's a worthwhile thing to study, IMHO.
- chiph 12y agoCharlotte Rifle + Pistol club has a solution for that. When the real estate developers discovered that the land around them was cheap (because of the noise, mainly), the club put up a huge sign by their entrance: "Your friendly neighbors since 1913". The house-shoppers couldn't help but notice it.
- john_b 12y ago> "I'm not sure I can muster any indignation that hunters can't hunt as much" Once a rural area with an overabundance of deer becomes re-zoned as a "residential area" the hunters often can't hunt at all, and a heavily overpopulated species becomes effectively a protected species in that area.
- MattGrommes 12y agoA lot of times it isn't that they weren't smart enough at all, they intended to move into the area and push out the farmers. Think of it as 'rural gentrification'.
- Spooky23 12y agoThat's a great personification of the problem described. Folks with more "urban" attitudes show up with contempt for the folks around them. You had a situation where generations of people kept things in balance. Farmers got rid of the wolves, hunters naturally managed the herd of deer. Many people relied on venison as a staple food. Then people show up who are afraid of hunters/guns/noise/etc and do dumb things like feed the wildlife and call the cops when they become a nuisance.
- kbenson 12y agoIt's not contempt. I feel that if you're going to cause pain to something that can feel pain, you should have a good reason. I don't consider "we've been doing this for generations" a good reason. Repeating something because it was done before is hardly ever a good justification. It may be there are good reasons to repeat earlier actions, and we just don't know enough to fully explain it, but that doesn't remove the responsibility people have to justify their actions. That's not to say someone won't come up with a justification that I'll fully accept. I didn't say "oh, hunting is horrible, how could a person ever do that!", I said I didn't have much sympathy, and that's because I don't agree with the justifications I've heard to this point. My personal point of view is that wildlife are both a natural resource and living animals., As a natural resource, the usage should come with some sort of associated cost, to account for the damage it's usage and/or removal causes to the environment (e.g. burning coal has negative externalities that are poorly accounted for to this point). As living animals that feel pain, I think there should be a reason to cause that pain, and or kill them. It needs to be justifiable, but for me the bar is not impossibly high. "I needed the food to survive" is fully capable as a justification in my eyes, while "It's fun" is not. obviously there's a fuzzy space in the middle, which I'm not sure the details of.
- ta82828 12y agoIs "they're tasty" a valid justification? Perhaps you're a vegetarian, but if you aren't there's a logical inconsistency there. If you are, kudos for walking the walk.
- 12y ago
- swashboon 12y agoHunting is a vital part of wildlife management and a healthy ecosystem involving humans. Not having hunters being able to provide population control is bad for local wildlife and the people who live there in situations where humans are the only dominate predators around. It's our responsibility to fill this role in the 'circle of life'.
- baddox 12y ago> I'm not sure I can muster any indignation that hunters can't hunt as much Why not?