6 ms·
The Selfish Ribosome Theory
- ars 12y agoThere is far too much personification of evolution. It shows up in sloppy science writing, that then shows up in the way people think about it. "what DNA (or evolution) really wants" "Eventually, some pre-living ribosomes would have associated with bubbles of fatty acids" - as if they have wants and desires, or ability to act with intent. I think evolution is a kind of alternative religion for many people.
- ThomPete 12y agoYeah it's like Dawkins says in The Selfish Gene. It's not that the genes are in fact selfish but rather that they act as if they are selfish.
- IgorPartola 12y agoI studied physics in college. This is how we talked about it there too: "The electron wants to find a positive charge", "the wire wants to rotate as it moves through the field", "the system wants to find its lowest energy state". The chemistry department that I worked with (my research was in quantum magnetism, which sounds cooler than it is) used the same style: "the free radical wants to find a pair". I don't think there's anything wrong with this language. The problem usually is people who don't know what they are talking about misinterpreting it as though atoms/molecules/cells/etc. have feelings.
- ars 12y agoThere's a difference between deterministic actions like an electron, and random events. Using that language with events that always happen doesn't lead to problems. But as soon as you use it with events that only happen sometimes you cause your thinking to be skewed. There is also a difference with complexity level - using "want" for single step events is not the same as using it with multi-step complex events, that only as a final result "want" something. Doing that leads you to personify the system. > The problem usually is people who don't know what they are talking about misinterpreting it as though atoms/molecules/cells/etc. have feelings. Exactly. Which is why you should not do it.
- IgorPartola 12y ago"The quantum wave wants to collapse into one of two states. The spin will either be up or down." Quantum mechanics is unpredictable as it gets :)
- andrewflnr 12y agoNot in a way that helps your argument. The result may not be determined but the collapse itself, which is what your quote said the wave "wants", is pretty much guaranteed.
- IgorPartola 12y agoYou are right. I suppose a more complex system might be a better example where there are several competing forces. "X wants to go to state A, but Y wants X to go to state B" with some relative probabilities of each. Then again, I just don't buy the argument that our big problem here is that the language here is somehow misleading the general public, and that's really my main point. If we accept that we can't say things like these, we then should also stop using terms like "greedy algorithm" because they sound so sinister.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoWhen I think of deterministic things in science, the behavior of a single electron is right up at the top of the list.
- DanAndersen 12y agoAgreed. There is a tendency to write about evolution as if creatures evolve in order to achieve some purposeful goal. Yudkowsky's "An Alien God" talks about this: http://lesswrong.com/lw/kr/an_alien_god/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/kr/an_alien_god/
- svachalek 12y agoYou can go the other way and say that everything we do is a cascading result of chemical and physical reactions and thus we do not act with "intention" either. It's all a matter of perspective.
- Terr_ 12y agoThe issue isn't evolution, nor any other area of knowledge, the issue is how humans use language (or at least English.) In many many areas, we use personification to easily abstract complex behavior and rulesets. It's a signal to the reader/listener that we are deferring discussion about exactly why or how something happens. The oxygen "wants" to bind to the iron to create rust, because we're glossing over electron orbitals. The T-cell "thinks" it has found an intruder, because we're not tracing it's internal algorithm. The computer "guesses" when to retransmit a packet, because the details of exponential backoff are outside the scope of my explanation...
- pointernil 12y agoSure. I see a problem with this when ppl. who are not scientifically trained use the same metaphor or get this presented by science journalism as it is "pushing" them into wrong 'beliefs' about intentionality of non conscious matter. Most of the time your kind of descriptions of the "how" are not presented thus ppl. mis-conceptualize. Sometimes I think it would be best science used its very own language partly like Latin in medicine is used.
- azakai 12y agoIt's normal in biology to talk that way. It's only incorrect if you understand it literally. I don't think scientists make that mistake, although some philosophers have argued that they (rarely) do. It is very likely that laypeople reading such articles might, though.
- BadCookie 12y agoThis comment made me think of the book What Technology Wants by Kevin Kelly (founding editor of Wired magazine). Despite the title, I wouldn't call the book sloppy at all. It explores the idea that technology is headed in an almost predetermined direction. I read it years ago and my younger self definitely recommends it.
- ergothus 12y agoI have a healthy interest in genetics, but I'm failing to see how having ribosomes begin as independent entities "upends" (to quote the current title) anything about evolutionary theory as a whole. Even allowing for hype, can someone give this some clarity?
- chadillac 12y agohttp://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022519314006778 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022519314... Was linked in the article, might shed some light on your question.
- ergothus 12y agoSkimming this, it doesn't appear to argue for any upending, just a "missing link" role (which, granted, would be a great discovery if it's supported, but doesn't upend anything). Or did I miss something?
- DougMerritt 12y agoThere is a long term question in abiogenesis that is quite similar to "what came first, the chicken or the egg?" -- what was the first self-replicating entity? Modern cells are vastly complex; self-replication must have started with something orders of magnitude more simple. Some of the components that appear essential are, on the other hand, too simple to self-replicate, such as DNA. A popular notion alluded to elsewhere on this page is the "RNA world", that RNA, not DNA, is where it all started, but the arguments along those lines have truly major gaps in what the original machinery would have been. This paper apparently shows some decent evidence (not proof) that ribosomes are capable of being the original self-replicators. Since ribosomes are critical machinery, but not usually considered the primogenitor, this up-ends mainstream thinking in a chicken/egg sort of way. Edit: here's the key part of the article regarding that: > Under this radically new view of the origin of life, genes only became independent of ribosomes because ribosomes began using them to gain an advantage over their rivals—while traditional theory says that ribosomes were only created and refined because they gave genes a more efficient way of affecting their surroundings and outcompeting their rivals.
- julienchastang 12y ago"But there’s a glaring hole in this plot: ribosomes themselves are made up of proteins" Ribosomes are made up of proteins and rRNA! And the Peptidyl transferase catalytic reaction which forms peptide bonds is entirely conducted by the rRNA[1]. Proto/paleo ribosomes were probably entirely RNA in the RNA world, long ago. Dawkins alludes to this (though I cannot remember the precise language since I don't have the book in front of me now). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peptidyl_transferase http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peptidyl_transferase
- Lanoteu 12y agoCatalytic RNA species have their place in the RNA world hypothesis, yes. But to suggest that rRNA itself can catalyze peptidyl-tranferase reactions without the use of ribosomal proteins in today's organisms may be far-fetched. Even the most primitive of organisms have ribosomal proteins to accompany the rRNA.
- julienchastang 12y agoFrom the wikipedia article referenced earlier: "Peptidyl transferase activity is not mediated by any ribosomal proteins but by ribosomal RNA (rRNA), a ribozyme. This RNA relic is the most significant piece of evidence supporting the RNA World hypothesis."
- driverdan 12y agoWhat a terrible linkbait headline. This has more to do with the origins of life and very, very early evolution than evolutionary theory itself.
- sctb 12y agoThanks, we updated the HN title to be less bait-ey.
- tacos 12y agoFor real (and cooler) information on the ribosome, check out the amazing work by Joachim Frank at Columbia. http://franklab.cpmc.columbia.edu/franklab/ http://franklab.cpmc.columbia.edu/franklab/ Nerd trivia: his son is Ze Frank.
- stenl 12y agoHaving never heard of Ze Frank, I had to check Wikipedia: "Ze Frank (born Hosea Jan Frank on March 31, 1972) is an American online performance artist, composer, humorist and public speaker based in Los Angeles, California. He was a pioneer of the vlogging format and is considered one of the most influential people in the field, inspiring such shows as the vlogbrothers, Philip DeFranco and Wheezy Waiter. He is currently executive vice president of video at BuzzFeed." Now I'll have to google "vlogging format"...
- swagasaurus-rex 12y agoI'm interested in learning more about this topic, specifically about the RNA world, the mechanism behind DNA replication, gene recombination, ect. Does anybody have good literature I could read into?