6 ms·
I was always doubtful about David Brin's views on privacy and surveillance[1], mostly because I didn't want it to be true. But I'm increasingly coming around t
by nl 12y ago
I was always doubtful about David Brin's views on privacy and surveillance[1], mostly because I didn't want it to be true.
But I'm increasingly coming around to think that it might make sense to explore his model more.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI haven't read the book yet (planning to), but there is this thought I keep thinking about and I've mentioned here a few times, that our choice might be that between privacy and continued progress humanity. There are great benefits to the same technologies that "enable mass surveillance", and I feel this angle is underexplored. (And yes, every time I mention this I secretly hope someone will argue with me, explaining the reasons to fight for so strong privacy we enjoy now (relatively to all the history of humanity) that are different than just belief in the privacy as a basic human right - an axiom which I don't really recognize).
- pyre 12y ago> relatively to all the history of humanity I'm curious how you think that privacy is stronger now than any other time in history? While the "small town" / "small group" effect was definitely present in the past, if you ran afoul of said group, you could always leave it (and the stigma) behind. Now the Internet allows people to inspect your history wherever you go. It becomes inescapable. This is something that has never existed in the past (aside from becoming so super-infamous that news travels between disparate groups, I guess).
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI meant the "small group" effect. I agree it's more difficult than ever to start over after you fall out with your group, but an ordinary person living ordinary, conforming life enjoys more privacy and more expectation of privacy than before.
- pyrois 12y agoI'm not sure how easily one could leave a small town in, say, feudal Europe. Most serfs lacked travel rights, and while one could escape from their lord's land and move to a city (depending on the country), the cost was prohibitively high[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serfdom#Villeins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serfdom#Villeins
- 6d0debc071 12y agoI feel like that stigma would, to a large degree, be associated with the identity of "outsider" that you'd acquire in leaving the original group. If that group didn't want you, why would we?
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoThis wouldn't work for me at all. Actually it would put me right into a psychiatric hospital - repeatedly. I expect it would do that for lots of other folks. The last little while I've been thinking of buying a car or maybe a motorcycle. For quite a long time I've enjoyed the fine public transit we enjoy here in Vancouver and Portland, but I'd like to go camping in the desert. The reason I haven't already done so, is that I know from experience that when you drive a car, the police find all manner of reasons to pull you over. The cops don't always have evil intent in doing so; consider that Timothy McVeigh was pulled over for expired registration a few days ago after he bombed the Oklahoma City Federal Building. I expect everyone was getting pulled over back then. I was appalled just a couple days ago to learn that the Feds have - or maybe they are working on - a nationwide license plate reader database. Even were I completely law-abiding, drove my car legally, my physical location would be in that database. No matter where I travelled in my car or on my motorbike, my entire path would be in a computer file. I've thought about that quite a lot; I am simply unable to tolerate such a thing, even today. By contrast, one does not need a license plate to ride a bicycle. I'm rather out of shape but back in the day I used to ride my bike fifty miles on a regular basis. I'm not dead certain but I might ride my bike from Portland to Burning Man this year. That's mostly desert, much of it mountainous. To do that wrong could be life-threatening but to do it right would be quite cool.
- nothrabannosir 12y agoIn many countries public transport is now next to impossible with only cash. You need an NFC enabled device. Often, discounts or monthly subscriptions are impossible if you take an anonymous one. Recharging with cash is time consuming at best, and very hard if the machines do not accept bills. I tried, and eventually caved. Please enjoy your anonymous public transport to the fullest for me. :(
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoYeah that's starting to happen around here too. There's not a whole lot one can do to prevent it. My take is to convince a whole lot of people to swap their cards with each other. That is, you and I would each purchase a $20 card. Say you and I worked at the same company - when we arrived at work, we'd trade cards. When I got home, I'd trade my card with my neighbor. That would enable The Man to cut down on his cash handling expenses, which really are quite significant when you handle quite a lot of coin and currency. But it would make a total rat's nest of any attempt to track transit riders by tracking our payment cards.