18 ms·
Using your analogy, ESA wants to ban practicing lockpicking skills in the privacy of your home because once you learned it, you could use it to commit burglary.
by smsm42 12y ago
Using your analogy, ESA wants to ban practicing lockpicking skills in the privacy of your home because once you learned it, you could use it to commit burglary. I think EFF is completely correct to oppose it and completely justified to expose guilt by association and slippery slope fallacies in ESA's argument.
ESA has interest in preventing piracy, but that does not give them any more rights. I have interest in acquiring a million dollars, but it would be a poor argument for me to justify robbing a bank with that interest. In the same way, the fact that ESA is interested in something does not constitute good argument to prevent harmless activities having nothing to do with piracy - because there are much better and less rights-infringing ways to further the same interest.