5 ms·
YouTube's paid subscription offering takes shape
- chatmasta 12y agoNow that ad free is premium feature, how will youtube treat ad blockers?
- farresito 12y agoThere will always be ways to skip ads. I guess going premium will be the morally right way. Look at spotify: any day you want, you can download the mp3 from a million sites, but people prefer spotify (probably because of comfortability, but still I know a lot of people that are willing to pay back to the authors).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- higherpurpose 12y agoThe better question is how will Google treat adblockers in the Chrome store (especially now that you can't install extensions from outside the store anymore)? Google has already banned adblockers on the Play Store. I don't think that will be an easy thing to do though, so I doubt they will actually try that, unless they can come up with a really "good reason" to do it (the NSA gets you through the adblocker!...or something).
- comex 12y agoFinally. Call me sentimental, but ad blocking makes me uncomfortable, especially on a site like YouTube where most creators seem to really struggle to earn a reasonable amount of compensation for their effort. Yet a short while back, I finally lost patience with the ever-increasing duration and prevalence of YouTube's video ads and installed a blocker; to me, personally, their demand on my attention was starting to bring back bad memories of ad-festooned TV shows and just feel truly obnoxious and disrespectful. I will be happy to turn off the blocker and switch to paying with money, which I do not value as much as my brain.
- mattmanser 12y agoI wonder if ads will come back for the subscribers anyway, as happened with cable. Especially once advertisers start pointing out to google that the only people they actually want to advertise to are the subscribers.
- nugget 12y agoBingo. The people most likely to pay are by far also the most valuable user segment to advertisers. Sooner or later some ads will find their way back in.
- tomjen3 12y agoIf they did, why would they subscribe at all? Okay maybe they get special subscriber only videos, but if a channel wanted that Patreon already has that feature.
- slimsag 12y agoHulu comes to mind. I can't fathom why someone would pay for such a service, but I presume that they do.
- tempodox 12y agoMaybe people would subscribe so they could actually find what they're looking for. Good luck finding a specific movie or a series episode right now. It just doesn't work.
- higherpurpose 12y ago"We'll double the rates for your subscribers!" Yeah, that could happen.
- dennisgorelik 12y agoYouTube may introduce multiple premium plans: Less ads / bubble ads only ($5/mo). No ads ($10/mo). More expensive content, like new movies ($20/mo). Premium subscribes would see occasional ads anyway, when they are not authenticated under their premium YouTube account.
- Animats 12y ago"And YouTube's carrot comes with a stick — creators are required to participate in the subscription offering, or every video on their channels will be set to private, sources said." Does this mean that uploading free videos to YouTube for free viewing is dead?
- IanCal 12y agoI don't get that interpretation, unless you mean "ad-free videos" in which case maybe. I'm not sure if you can upload ad-free videos (edit - I mean, I'm not sure if you can do this currently). If you can, then I'd expect this means that if you have ads, then they won't be shown to anyone with a subscription.
- Aoyagi 12y agoIsn't that a similar issue [1] to what Zoe Keating went though not long ago? [1] - http://zoekeating.tumblr.com/post/108898194009/what-should-i-do-about-youtube http://zoekeating.tumblr.com/post/108898194009/what-should-i...
- tomjen3 12y agoNot really, she was required to release her entire back catalog and any future releases too.
- treenotshrub 12y agoThe monetization formula for subscribers and free viewers will obviously be different. It means the channel owner can't just accept the free viewing model exclusively.
- Joona 12y ago> It means the channel owner can't just accept the free viewing model exclusively. I pray that I'm either misunderstanding you, or you are misunderstanding Youtube. Partners must be able to choose whether they want videos to be shown to subscribers only, or for everyone. There can NOT be any forced exclusive deals for subscribers.
- Aoyagi 12y agoBut they will still track and log everything I do no matter what kind of subscription I have, won't they. And the site won't become any less bloated. Well, at least it's a step forward.
- Joona 12y agoIt's great, but very late. I'm unsure about the pricing - $10 is very pricey (I pay ~$20 for internet). I would've /thought/ about it if it was $5, though, to be fair, I'm not a huge Youtube user.
- kmfrk 12y ago$10 is Netflix money. I can't really make sense of it in proportion to lack of premium content. Especially since YouTube have been awful at stringing together a smart way to build a station/feed to watch people regularly. $5 would make a lot more sense.
- IanCal 12y agoThere is a lot of music there, the article sounds like this would be music key + everything else. That would make it an extra cost of $2 for all non-music videos.
- dageshi 12y agoHonestly I'd pay $10 for youtube given the quantity of letsplay/podcasts I watch through yt. $10 is definitely not beyond the realm of possibility.
- prostoalex 12y agoI already pay $2/month for a channel for the kid and then $30 for a random third-party "youtube downloader pro" app that lets me load those videos on iPad for a long car ride, some YouTube use cases are better than others.
- IanCal 12y agoSomething particularly interesting there is the way the money will be split: > Individual partners' cuts will be apportioned based on how much time their viewers spend watching their channels This could provide a nice incentive to have longer videos rather than shorter ones (for quick views). Particularly for full episodes of something. I wonder if that's the route they're hoping to go down? If they had a good selection of films & tv shows then this could be quite nice (much more so with offline viewing!).
- tomjen3 12y agoIt will mean minute physics will get very little and any random let's play will get a lot more.
- IanCal 12y agoThat's one side, but a very specific example. If you pay for views rather than duration you incentivise short videos, if you pay for duration you incentivise long videos. If you go for duration the risk is that you have lots of long easily made videos getting money instead of short hard to make videos. Is that going to harm more things than paying for views? I think I'd rather have a 10 minute lets-play earn 10x more than one minute physics video than have a playlist of the ten funniest 6s cat videos earn 10x more than one view of minute physics.
- BonsaiDen 12y agoThing is though, making one minute of lets-play costs a lot less (time / money) than making one minute physics or crash course or you name it. Also, I probably watch hundreds of hours of youtube every month so the amount that ends up at each channel will be extremely small 5.50 / monthlyHours * oursPerChannel isn't going to be very much in the end. The biggest winners are going to be MCNs (Multi Channel Networks, which most Let's Plays are part of) which take another 20-30% of the revenue generated by each of their partnering channels. If you want to support single channels, something like Patreon is still going to reign superior in terms of actual money received at the other end.
- doctorshady 12y agoOr you could just use a script like youtube-dl and not deal with ads or tracking cookies or anything of the sort. And, y'know, actually get to keep the video.
- Aoyagi 12y agoYes, but I like to reward people whose content I consume regularly and not everyone is on Patreon, sadly.
- HappMacDonald 12y agoChangetip? Find out their email and then Paypal to them? Seriously, I mean they have to have a path to accept money somewhere if you wish to push money at them. Or, "You can lead a content creator to money but you can't make them accept teh cash". ;3
- Aoyagi 12y agoNever heard of anyone using Changetip and not everyone has Paypal. Also not everyone is using their public email as their PP email. I know some people who refuse to accept "donations" for some moral reasons that are unfathomable to me. TotalBiscuit is one of them, actually. https://soundcloud.com/totalbiscuit/maybe-subbablepatreon-isnt-the-magic-bullet https://soundcloud.com/totalbiscuit/maybe-subbablepatreon-is...
- tomjen3 12y agoThat's a giving steep price they are demanding, good luck with that. Netflix is cheaper and has more content of a higher quality.
- jbverschoor 12y agoNext step: http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/singularity/ http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/singularity/
- tempodox 12y agoThere was a time when search worked on YouTube. Then came Google, the world champion of search. And search got worse and more nonfunctional by the day on YouTube. Now they want me to believe that search will work again, after I throw money at them? “Don't be evil” my hind foot. I already drastically decreased my YouTube usage in the past. I guess I will avoid it entirely in the future.