3 ms·
Wow, downthread I got my first death threat / trolling. Nothing to do with you, but it is interesting just how polarising Uber is. Like you said "you don't ca
by lifeisstillgood 12y ago
Wow, downthread I got my first death threat / trolling.
Nothing to do with you, but it is interesting just how polarising Uber is. Like you said "you don't care if they are licensed". Well then that is a debate to have (somehow) in each city. Not to ignore the law and do it anyway.
I can well believe that most taxis in most cities can be beaten by a well trained monkey with a scooter. But doing so by breaking the law is not acceptable. Any business fight that starts by breaking the law is just heading down the road to actual real crime. In London a cab company with many of the qualities esposed by Uber is doing quite well (Addison Lee) and even opening up in NYC. And not pretending they are a lift sharing company.
There are very good valid reasons for opposing bad law. A shiny new business model is not one of them.
- marssaxman 12y agoThe shininess of the new business model is evidence that the existing regulatory structure is broken and ought to be changed, but in absence of a large, growing, profitable company, who would be pressing for the change? The power would all be concentrated in the existing industry. Only because Uber has sidestepped taxi regulation have they grown powerful enough that fixing the law has become a possibility. If they had tried to do things "the right way" they would never have gotten anywhere.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoBut there are large powerful companies who have managed to grow and deliver Uber like services (credit cards, online booking etc) without sidestepping regulations (cf Addison Lee) If the argument is "licensing taxis costs so much that all the profit is driven out, and we have to avoid licensing in order to make our profits" then surely small inefficient taxis would make even less profit than giant, well funded, efficient companies like Uber? So I think the argument is dubious. I will happily admit I don't know enough about the details of Ubers practises, and would be interested in knowing more, such as driver and car checks, fleet numbers during different times of day / week, variations across cities etc.