4 ms·
Everyone did. Developers he stole from stole it from someone else, the whole social game space was a clone war. But Zynga was consistently succesful in it. Do
by golergka 12y ago
Everyone did. Developers he stole from stole it from someone else, the whole social game space was a clone war. But Zynga was consistently succesful in it.
Do you remember the tower-breaking game on Kongregate and iOS that Angry Birds cloned? Or Backyard Monsters that was the original Clash of Clans?
- freehunter 12y agoCrush the Castle! I used to play that game during classes on my netbook back when WebOS was still a thing. Is it even possible to be nostalgic about something that happened 5 years ago?
- zaguios 12y agoCrush the castle wasn't even the original version of the game. It's actually inspired by another flash game called Castle Clout which almost nobody has heard of. (The developer of Crush the Castle listed the attribution in the first game's description on Armorgame's)
- jonursenbach 12y agoSo because everyone did, that makes it okay?
- weixiyen 12y agoI think the point is -> why is Zynga singled out?
- golergka 12y agoMorality is not the point of the argument. Commenter above said that “original moves were impressive”, and I completely agree with him — HOW Zynga cloned games was really effective, unlike all other competitors on the market.
- GoodIntentions 12y ago>Everyone did. Developers he stole from stole it from someone else Except perhaps the dev with the initial idea? Stealing someone else's idea might be widespread, but it doesn't make it right.
- paulhauggis 12y agoI suppose this goes against the common idea here on HN that the idea doesn't matter and you should share it with everyone, even during the early stages of a startup. Zynga shows me exactly why I don't share my ideas early on: A company with more money and more resources can bring the idea to market much faster than a 1 or 2 person shop. I think the people that keep spreading this idea have the resources and money to 1) create their own ideas quickly and 2) take someone else's idea.
- amirmc 12y agoThey were not ideas. They were working versions. At some point you have to put your ideas/implementation/whatever out into the open (you might even have to advertise its existence). At that point, anyone better resourced than you can probably just mimic your work. What alternative does anyone really have?
- golergka 12y agoThat's the point: every game idea was a clone of a clone of a clone, and on each copying something changed, but not significantly enough to call it a new one. However, the emd results differed from the originals drastically.
- im3w1l 12y agoThat sounds like some kind of intellectual property right that needs to happen.