3 ms·
How come who was behind it is important but who says what on HN is not? One could have extra information right beside each submitter/commenter's name (e.g., ..
by amichail 17y ago
How come who was behind it is important but who says what on HN is not?
One could have extra information right beside each submitter/commenter's name (e.g., ... founder, Google employee, PhD in ..., etc.).
- tspiteri 17y agoYou can say that who is behind it is important because you do not need to add extra information besides their names, their names stand on their own.
- DougBTX 17y agoThere are some usernames I will recognise, and their comments do mater more to me. Also, if someone does say something interesting, you can often learn more about them from their profile page should you wish to.* And, yes, it would amuse me for a couple of days if everyone with/working on a PhD were encouraged to append their thesis titles after their usernames. * though yes, for people I don't recognise who are not posting particularly interesting comments, it does not matter who posted them. Such as this comment I assume, anyone could write it.
- amichail 17y agoImagine someone commenting on Google but you don't take his/her comment seriously and post a reply indicating that this person is mistaken. You later find out from his/her profile that this person is a Google employee and is in a position to know what he/she commented about. It might be too late by then to take back what you wrote.
- unalone 17y agoToo late for what? This is the Internet. You're allowed to make an ass out of yourself sometimes. I remember when I came on here and criticized Delicious and got in an argument with joshu because I didn't know who he was. If anything, I'd like more anonymity, because the people I do know I sometimes tiptoe around.
- fragmede 17y agoThere's also follow through and prolonged effort which matters on a project vs. points for discussion. On HN, the idea is the point each comment makes should be considered on its own merits. On the opposite end of the spectrum; the project should stand on its own merits. However, those merits are likely to be derived from the choices of the person(s) working on the project, so the person(s) involved in the case of a not-yet-finished project is relevant.