3 ms·
Work, in the form of a job, is the basis for our economy. If you provide work to someone with capital then you get capital in return. Critically, basic necessit
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
Work, in the form of a job, is the basis for our economy. If you provide work to someone with capital then you get capital in return. Critically, basic necessities are part of this economy, so food, water, shelter etc... are traded in the same markets as t-shirts, toys and printer paper.
What basic income proposes at it's root is attempting to decouple basic necessities from the larger market economy. The mechanism that this works through attempts to retain the structure of the "market economy" and in general terms would set the basic wage at the market basket rate for necessities. Previous experiments on this have been either limited in duration or scope and would be argued could not be extrapolated to an entire national or world economy.
I think however that fundamentally we will need to change our moral attitudes broadly to actually embrace the "post scarcity" world. My guess is that workers will be displaced faster than our systems can catch up.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> What basic income proposes at it's root is attempting to decouple basic necessities from the larger market economy. I don't think of it that way. I think of it more as establishing common ownership of the social foundation on which the entire market depends, charging rents on them, and distributing the rents to the owners (i.e., all members of society equally). > I think however that fundamentally we will need to change our moral attitudes broadly to actually embrace the "post scarcity" world. I think "post scarcity" is a bad term -- its not a post scarcity world, and if it was, we wouldn't need to worry so much about how we distribute resources. Its just a world in which the nature of the market opportunities is such that the problems with our current manner of managing distribution of resources become even more pronounced.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoestablishing common ownership of the social foundation That is exactly as I said, decoupling certain aspects from the market. In effect you are socializing some portion of the market. I don't mean that as an epithet either, just a defining term. I also don't disagree that something like it should happen. if it was, we wouldn't need to worry so much about how we distribute resources. Ah, actually that's not true at all and is a foundation of this debate. If an individual had a machine that created infinite bread for free the person, under the current market, could restrict access and distribution all they like. I think in practice this (not the bread thing) is what will happen with certain goods where marginal costs go to zero.
- onnoonno 12y ago> Ah, actually that's not true at all and is a foundation of this debate. If an individual had a machine that created infinite bread for free the person, under the current market, could restrict access and distribution all they like. I think in practice this (not the bread thing) is what will happen with certain goods where marginal costs go to zero. Funny how the optimists throw out all the law of conservation of energy and the 2nd law of thermodynamics to make their points. Quite an interesting kool-aid you drank there...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]