4 ms·
Would you have the same attitude about kiddie porn? What you say is true, but being able to buy guns from Tor will save you a lot of hassle over trying to manu
by collyw 12y ago
Would you have the same attitude about kiddie porn?
What you say is true, but being able to buy guns from Tor will save you a lot of hassle over trying to manufacture your own.
I think I am pretty open minded, but I was fairly shocked at what claimed to be available when I logged onto Tor to see what it was all about.
- golemotron 12y agoApples and oranges. Guns have no victim unless they are used and the vast majority of them, illegal or not, are never used to hurt anyone. Our society fetishes guns enormously. I know some people who would be uncomfortable being in someone's house if they new they had a gun, even if they trust and know everyone in the house. Those same people are never scared by steak or hunting knives in the same house.
- RVuRnvbM2e 12y agoIn my country (Australia) I believe most people would be a little uncomfortable if they knew they were in a house with a gun. I'd certainly think the owner was a bit odd/unhinged unless they owned it as part of their employment (farmer, roo shooter etc.). That said, I don't see this as a big deal. It's always been possible to mail weapons from a jurisdiction with easier access to them. Tor black markets just make it a little easier to organise.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoI aalso live in Australia, and I can offer a different perspective. I grew up in Port Lincoln in South Australia. My father owned a couple of .22 rifles, I've fired shotguns a few times, currently live in Launceston in Tasmania, more than half the 30 odd guys I work with own one or more (mostly more) guns. None of them require a firearm for work purposes, they're all hunters / enthusiasts. Most of the people I know are comfortable with guns. None of the gun owners I know are "odd/unhinged", and I think that is an uncharitable characterisation of gun owners in this country. For many people firearms are amazing creations of metallurgy and machining, and hold artistic values in and of themselves, in the same way some people appreciate knives or swords, or cars or aeroplanes.
- wyager 12y ago> I believe most people would be a little uncomfortable if they knew they were in a house with a gun. And most Americans would be uncomfortable going to a nude beach with their German friends. That says nothing about its morality or safety.
- harshreality 12y agoIf someone isn't comfortable in a house with a gun, regardless of the upstanding character of the owner, that might indicate a harmful phobia of certain kinds of inanimate objects, but it's their choice not to visit a gun owner's house and nobody is going to take that choice away from them. A law against gun ownership is vastly different. Plenty of people don't like drugs, particularly banned narcotics and stimulants. I might even be uncomfortable in certain instances visiting someone who I know has drugs. Presumably if they have them, they use them on occasion. Let's ban drugs, right? Who cares whose privacy and property rights are violated as long as I feel better?
- frapandolf 12y agoI don't think that is a particularly fair correlation. Guns are (historically) tools created with the express purpose of KILLING OTHER HUMAN BEINGS, capitalized for emphasis. Being uncomfortable around them is not indicative of some kind of basic phobia of inanimate objects.
- golemotron 12y ago> Guns are (historically) tools created with the express purpose of KILLING OTHER HUMAN BEINGS, capitalized for emphasis. I've never been able to fathom that argument. Even if a gun was made to kill people (one could equally argue that a particular gun is made for target practice or hunting and often that is true) the intentions of the maker of an object have absolutely nothing to do with whether you should be scared or not. As an example, suppose someone hits you on the head with a hammer. As you sit in the hospital with a concussion is it any solace that the maker of the hammer intended it to be used on nails?
- ta82828 12y agoMaybe it's not a basic phobia, but the grandparent poster implied that anyone who likes target shooting and owns guns for that purpose is "odd/unhinged". I don't understand why people can say, "oh he's a farmer, so he's not insane for having a gun" but the moment someone's not a farmer, they're suddenly unhinged or obsessed with violence, as opposed to perhaps, a target shooter or other kind of hobbyist. It's like they have this mental pattern "grandpa with a gun" where it's ok, and everything else just sets off alarm bells. It's odd, because it's usually liberals (in the US this is a liberal/conservative thing) that have more "openness to experience" but for some reason they are rarely open to the experience of growing up with guns, considering them dangerous but useful tools, using them for sport and hunting, and not being insane while doing so. Weapons of war have historically become objects of sport: it happened with fencing and archery - firearms are no different.
- Mimu 12y agoThe only mean to a gun is to hurt people so comparing it to fruit or other useful tool is not very relevant imo.
- harshreality 12y agoSelf defense tools are not useful? Sporting use or aesthetics are not relevant? There go javelins, bows and arrows, swords, etc. Hunting is not relevant? I hope you don't eat meat, or perhaps you prefer the ethics of factory animal farming to the ethics of hunting with firearms?
- Mimu 12y agoIf I talk about how ridiculous speed limit are because of car racing, will you see my point as relevant or not?
- mathgeek 12y ago> Would you have the same attitude about kiddie porn? Logical fallacy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children
- collyw 12y agoIt was a genuine question, rather than trying to prove a point. I know what you are saying, but most people outside of the US see gun owning as a pretty serious problem.
- Snesker 12y ago>but most people outside of the US see gun owning as a pretty serious problem. A lot of people INSIDE the US see guns as a serious problem. That doesn't make them right. People who can't fathom being harmed, who think their salary and location preclude them from violent acts against their person are people I don't mind not having guns. Being responsible for your own safety indicates that you're ready to be responsible for firearms. Whether they're illegally purchased or personally fabricated, if you care for deploy it responsibly you're only a criminal on paper. I'll toss in also that there are responsible pedophiles, who don't support the child pornography industry with purchases. To the poster who replied to you who mentioned a draconian screening system - In this climate that would result in them being identified and executed. The world isn't ready to handle non-pracicing paedophiles. Some people are even so bigoted they would claim that a non-practicing pedophile doesn't exist. In the first world, I would say they're the most subjugated(lack of a better word) people. They're the only people who, when, they're found out, get harmed and ostracised and there's no undoing it. Picturing the malice of a simple-minded thug who would destroy someone's life over what they masturbate to makes me viciously angry. HN has a climate of wanting to manage humanity with numeric efficiency, and speak casually about removing human rights. I find that unacceptable but I don't have the intellectual capacity to argue with them. I'm fundamentally opposed to all form of societal control. I don't know why I posted this here and I apologize for involving you in it. I'm a bad poster.
- venomsnake 12y agoAnd I am not a US citizen. Just pragmatic. And child pornography is something that cannot be "invented" or "improvised". It requires abusing a child (of course in the current landscape child porn is watered down to "whatever gives this politician a boner" - like teenagers sexting between them or works of fiction) But yeah ... I think that current approach towards CP is misguided. We will be able to prevent the creation of the content if we screen and treat the persons for the mental illness they have. That is the real way to strangle demand.