3 ms·
And while we're at it, I'm not currently ill, so why should I have to pay for disability benefits for others? I'm not old, so why should I have to pay for Soci
by emodendroket 12y ago
And while we're at it, I'm not currently ill, so why should I have to pay for disability benefits for others? I'm not old, so why should I have to pay for Social Security?
- ryanx435 12y agoyou are probably being sarcastic, but as someone in their late 20s, I do not believe I will every get a social security payout. either the age requirements will keep getting pushed back as people live longer or the whole program will be abolished by the time I qualify. I don't think I should pay into a system that I will never receive benefit from.
- michaelchisari 12y ago> I don't think I should pay into a system that I will never receive benefit from. What do you propose the elderly living off of social security should do instead?
- ryanx435 12y agohonestly, it's not my problem and I don't care what they do as long as I don't get stuck with the bill.
- jobposter1234 12y agoKeep voting as a bloc and hope the music doesn't stop during their lifetime?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> but as someone in their late 20s, I do not believe I will every get a social security payout. This belief does not seem to be well justified. > either the age requirements will keep getting pushed back as people live longer "Keep"? They've been pushed back once in the history of the program.
- jobposter1234 12y agoWhile I know you are being sarcastic, I have a serious question: do you believe that choice should enter the equation? No choice in getting old, or ill, or injured. But people (Americans) sure have a choice in getting pregnant.
- Retra 12y agoNo, they don't. Some people have to get pregnant or humanity collapses. If you think that is an acceptable outcome, then your moral compass is so far off that your opinion wouldn't merit any respect.
- jobposter1234 12y agoHoly hyperbole, Batman! When did we go from my original statement, "I'm sure it's not shameful. It might bug you, but I don't see it as something worthy of shame" into the utter annihilation of humanity, and me as a bad person for wanting that? It's kind of weird that humanity has managed to procreate without extended, government-funded maternity leave up to this point, isn't it? (I'd also like to mention this discussion is scoped to US Governmental legislation, NOT the debate over humanity's continued existence.) My original point was that it's not shameful to not provide this entitlement. Somehow we managed to go completely off the rails into zero-population Armageddon. I would also ask that you tone down the rhetoric, personal attacks, and broad generalizations for the sake of civility.
- Retra 12y agoI wasn't responding to your original point, but to the comment I actually responded to. Reproduction is not a choice if some of us must do it. Like, I don't have to drink water, I can just eat meat and get my water from that. But it would be absurd to suggest that "drinking water is a choice" because there are alternatives that I could personally take. This is a Hobson's Choice: a choice between one option. You could wrangle that kind of argument into justification for anything! Slavery: "You chose to be a slave because you didn't run away." Rape: "You chose to get raped because you didn't stay inside." Pregnancy: "You chose to get pregnant because nobody actively forced you to have a baby." Never-mind any notion of practicality. Forget about the fact that these things literally need to happen. It's a choice because you don't agree with the politics.