4 ms·
Amazing. The solution of "give out less PhDs" is not even broached.
by dnautics 12y ago
Amazing. The solution of "give out less PhDs" is not even broached.
- bkcooper 12y agoCutting back on PhDs generated would be a good idea, but is probably an even harder sell (so much cheap labor!) If postdocs are so prized, then one obvious solution is to reward them. Both the 2014 National Academies report and earlier reports urged US lab heads to consider creating senior staff scientist, or ‘superdoc’, positions. These would be higher-paid, permanent jobs for talented postdocs who have no desire to start their own labs. This type of thing becoming more common would fix a lot of academic career problems. I think it would also be a very good first step in actually reducing the number of incoming PhD students, since the productivity of such a researcher will usually exceed the amount of graduate student you could replace them with.
- irremediable 12y agoSo much this. I feel scientific careers suffer from a similar thing to technical careers: to progress, you're forced into management and away from the science/tech. There should be a track for people who don't want to do much management stuff, and just want to work on the stuff that got them going in the first place.
- chriskanan 12y agoAs someone who had to work really hard to get into a PhD program, but now has a great job as a research scientist and is going to be starting a professorship in August, I have to disagree with giving out fewer PhDs as a solution. People that want to pursue careers in research should be allowed to get the necessary training. What we need is to have considerably better mentoring and training in jobs outside of academia during the PhD: science communication, industry, entrepreneurship, teaching, science policy advising, and consulting. I think a postdoc's value largely consists in improving one's credentials for academia, so only the few PhDs with a realistic chance of getting a professorship after their PhD should spend more than a year or so doing one.
- dnautics 12y agoIt used to be that there was no such thing as a postdoc, and you would go into a faculty position directly after your PhD. Obviously, you can claim sour grapes in my case, but - I finished up my PhD which was somewhat middling but I did accomplish some important things - and had two very productive postdocs in disparate fields. What I observed was, consistently, PhDs getting degrees that probably shouldn't have. About half of the PhD thesis defenses I went to at The Scripps Research Institute (consistenly ranked in top 5) were, in my opinion, undeserved, possibly including mine. The situation was somewhat worse at the University of Maryland where I did a postdoc. My second postdoc was at the Venter Insitute, where there were no PhDs; we had a grad student intern in my lab that my boss selected that couldn't get a simple molecular biology procedure to work. The undergrad with no lab experience that I trained did it 50 times in 1.5 months. The grad student got his PhD, and is now a postdoc at LBNL. Opinion aside, fact of the matter is that the academic system is broken for a simple, mathematical reason. There is an 'exponential growth' mechanism where you have professors with labs with, say, three postdocs, and four grad students (note that the grad students stay for longer than the postdocs). You can't expect to 'copy/paste' this tree indefinitely, even with a modest attrition rate, because ultimately this growth is unsustainable. You have to be willing to cull, and cull hard. Confounding factors include: an unwillingness to cull because it makes the program look bad; sometimes you have to grant the PhD because you're afraid the grad program will be sued (insert anecdotal story of a student who nabbed a nice severance including a trip to Albert Hofmann's 100th birthday party); PhDs being sold as 'the next step' for listless students who don't know what to do with their life next because all they know is schooling; PhDs having a 'social status' cachet; nationalistic measuring contests where countries try to project greatness as measured by how many PhDs they produce - aka race to the bottom. The 'jobs outside of academia' for PhDs has basically come about as a relief valve for this exponential process and now that relief valve has likely been saturated. That postdocs appear to be underpaid is a symptom of the market failure; there are too many of them around and so you can pay them less. Moreover, because so many crappy PhDs are produced, it becomes difficult to differentiate between them. This basically creates frustration for genuinely smart PhDs, and so they go into finance on wall street and cause stock market crashes by making the assumption that markets are normally distributed when they're actually levy distibuted.
- 12y ago
- ylem 12y agoActually, the string theory group at Rutgers rather impressed me. Given the extremely weak job market for string theorists, they decided to limit the number of students that they took on to the very few that they thought would have a chance at finding a permanent job eventually...
- gaius 12y agoIt works very well for the other kinds of doctors (MDs) who have well paid, secure careers.