4 ms·
From the article: "A good rule of thumb is to hire only people who are better than you. Do not compromise. Ever." Is it only me that sees this as an unsustaina
by r00fus 12y ago
From the article: "A good rule of thumb is to hire only people who are better than you. Do not compromise. Ever."
Is it only me that sees this as an unsustainable goal that will likely lead to idealist driven results?
While, when interviewing, I tend to be impressed with folks who seem more well versed and smarter than me, but realistically I also feel there's a potential risk that those folks may not be sufficiently challenged in our organization.
Wouldn't the (unrelenting) drive to find people who are "better than you" lead to some of the problems in bias-matching and with first impressions dominating your perception?
Sounds a bit dogmatic and contrary to the entire focus of the article which espouses a more rigorous, measurable and evidence-based approach to hiring.
- nostrademons 12y agoHere's a mathematical model of it: http://googleresearch.blogspot.com/2006/03/hiring-lake-wobegon-strategy.html http://googleresearch.blogspot.com/2006/03/hiring-lake-wobeg... The reason it converges to some relative percentile (apparently just under the 90th) is because of the noise in the interview process. If people could reliably measure the quality of an applicant and consistently hired only people better than them, they'd only hire the very best (100th percentile) candidate, who probably wouldn't want to work there. But because peoples' judgments are off, they end up getting folks who are good, but probably not absolutely best - but they also avoid the bozos, because it's pretty unlikely that a bozo would appear better than half the people you know.
- r00fus 12y agoThe rubric presented "hire above the company mean" doesn't align with the dogma in the wired article "always hire people better than you, don't compromise". It's the latter I question. Also the assertion that "it's pretty unlikely that a bozo would appear better than half the people you know" sounds just full of assumptions that may not be valid. Just thinking from a non-Google point of view, not every wants to work at new_untested_startup or boring_postIPO_company. It seems unrealistic to a) set hiring targets and b) keep raising the bar unless you have incredible cachet and a large pool of candidates to work with. So what does the rest of the industry who don't have that luxury do?
- jotux 12y ago>A good rule of thumb is to hire only people who are better than you. Reminds me of another adage: >Never be the smartest person in the room.
- clay_to_n 12y ago>I also feel there's a potential risk that those folks may not be sufficiently challenged in our organization. I think Google is unconcerned with that option. They can get amazing candidates to do run-of-the-mill work by simply paying more and promising more than other companies. For them, keeping a great talent from joining a different company is potentially worth the increased compensation.
- gertef 12y ago> For them, keeping a great talent from joining a different company is potentially worth the increased compensation. This is logically true, but it's hard to imagine how the human interviewers/hiring-committees would consciously consider that.