4 ms·
Replacing all airplanes with pilotless planes is likely as a bad plan as replacing all car with driverless cars. Its not the a single step, nor has all situatio
by belorn 12y ago
Replacing all airplanes with pilotless planes is likely as a bad plan as replacing all car with driverless cars. Its not the a single step, nor has all situations which a driver/pilot has to deal with been automated to the point in which a computer can do all the work successfully.
It is however a great goal, one which spells safer, faster, and consecutive safer technology with every step. Modern cars already has some forms of brake systems which can take control away from the driver during a crash-like situation, so the same concept for planes could be applied if it can be made safe enough. We also have kill-switches in cars which can be triggered remotely, so I could easily see a similar system be implemented which locks a plane into auto-pilot with a per-determined height and GPS direction.
Neither will replace pilots overnight, so they continue having low blood pressure and know that they still got a job tomorrow. Flying in bad weather, imperfect position technology, security, and complex traffic is going to take a long time to solve.
- innocenat 12y agoYou already spelled a problem. If automation failed and you kill-switch an airplane to fly at specific height and direction (assuming, of course, that altimeter and compass/gps unit hasn't failed), how do you land that plane and get passenger off safely?
- TrevorJ 12y agoAlso, if the failure is with the GPS network, you've now got every flight trying to occupy the same airspace at the same time.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoADS-B includes TCAS support: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_collision_avoidance_system http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_collision_avoidance_sys...
- frenchman_in_ny 12y agoNot to pick on you, but hearing "per-determined height and GPS direction" makes me a bit nervous with anything related to human life. People follow GPS blindly and that's OK on roads with a driver, but in other applications it can lead to tragic results due to Dilution of Precision. The Flinders Islet crash is a prime example. [0][1] [0] http://www.sailingmates.com/your-gps-can-kill-you/ http://www.sailingmates.com/your-gps-can-kill-you/ [1] http://www.yachting.org.au/sport-services/safety/major-incident-reports/flinders-islet/ http://www.yachting.org.au/sport-services/safety/major-incid...
- belorn 12y agoIf it is used only in emergency situations, akin to the use case for kill switches, I think problems with Dilution of Precision and GPS hacking then become a lesser problem. As with any lock-out mechanism, the use of such restriction need to be done with human safety in mind depending on the situation.
- return0 12y ago> replacing all car with driverless cars Actually replacing all cars with driverless cars is a much safer bet , but the key is that they would all have to be replaced simultaneously.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoNo. If you read about the recent Audi that went from SF to NY with Delphi's automation and Google's self driving vehicle intelligence, both are design to handle not only aggressive drivers, but also pedestrians and cyclists. There is no reason to replace every car at once, except that it would save more bad drivers from themselves.
- aij 12y ago> It is however a great goal, one which spells safer, faster, and consecutive safer technology with every step. Not quite. Too much automation leads to bored humans who aren't used to doing things themselves. If they then have to take over in an emergency, it often doesn't go well since they haven't even been practicing under normal circumstances. At some point, it's probably best to take the human out of the loop entirely (even in emergencies), but where that point is will depend not only on the task at hand, but also on the individual human. I expect we're at the point where a computer can do a better job than a mediocre pilot. For example, see Air France 447. It looks like it would have ended well if the pilots had ignored the emergency and let the autopilot deal with it. It also would have been fine if the pilots knew how to fly the plane with the automation turned off.
- infinotize 12y agoAF447 was flying in "alternate law" with limited (or maybe no) automation capability due to iced over airspeed pitot tubes. The aircraft did not know its speed and could not fly itself, or offer the anti-stall measures that would have normally prevented the confused pilot from stalling the flight from ~40k feet into the ocean.