3 ms·
> The best thing about typing on a mechanical keyboard, by far, is the sound. The satisfaction for the sound is most likely a result of the tactile feedback. T
by zamalek 12y ago
> The best thing about typing on a mechanical keyboard, by far, is the sound.
The satisfaction for the sound is most likely a result of the tactile feedback. The 'clackiest' switches tend to also have the most pronounced tactile feedback. Pinning it to sounds is misrepresenting the advantages of mechanical keyboards and makes them sound like a novelty (which they are definitely not).
The satisfaction of mechanical keyboards comes from the feedback of knowing when the key has been pressed: enthusiasts claim (and I agree) that bottoming out keys is tiring for your fingers. The tactile response helps build muscle memory toward this goal.
One of the most sought after switches (Cherry MX Clear) are evidence of this: they are almost silent but have a strong tactile response.
> I’m not sure how my Das Keyboard 4 stacks up against the competition.
For a typist (or programmer) the switch is the most important feature of a keyboard. A Cherry MX Brown feels the same no matter which keyboard it is featured on - the only discerning feature on keyboards is their build and operational features (such as NKRO on gaming keyboards).
One final point: it might be a better idea to stick to a single type of switch everywhere. Mechanical keyboards are about building muscle memory - having different switches (which have different activation forces) probably works against you building it. I the long run your muscles will learn, but you will hit the plateau faster if you stick to one switch.
- chao- 12y agoAgreed on multiple points, but especially the muscle memory. Years ago I had a board with Cherry MX Reds, acquired in Japan when they were still almost unknown on any consumer models. Felt like a huge accomplishment in a keyboard geek pissing contest to say I had the board, but it wasn't useful in practice because I was so used to my MX Browns that shifting to Reds, even after a week of use, resulted in this huge increase of typos, an an overall discomforting feeling of uncertainty with the tool I was trying to use. I eventually gifted the board to a friend who had never owned a mechanical keyboard. I still type on MX Browns to this day, but the next board I buy will definitely have MX Clears (or who knows, maybe I'll splurge on something Topre). I've never been one for the sound, though. Distracting when I use one, and outright raises my blood pressure when it's someone else.
- zamalek 12y ago> I was so used to my MX Browns that shifting to Reds, even after a week of use, resulted in this huge increase of typos I also erroneously purchased a red keyboard. A coworker now uses it. The reason is likely that reds have NO tactile response, but medium sound.
- technomancy 12y agoCherry Red switches are designed for gaming. Most of the time with games, you hold the key all the way down for a while instead of tapping on it and releasing it as soon as it actuates. So they're really not intended for typists. (Because of this they actually make great modifier keys even for typists though, because modifier keys aren't meant to be tapped and released either, so they don't benefit from a tactile response.)
- yohoho22 12y agoThe reason that red switches are popular with (some) gamers is that they can be pulsed quickly right at the actuation point with very little rebound between presses. The tactile switches, on the other hand, have to be allowed to return quite a bit more before they can activate a second time. Whether of silent design or not, they have to unclick before they can click again.
- technomancy 12y ago> The satisfaction for the sound is most likely a result of the tactile feedback. Obviously this is deeply subjective, but I have to provide a counter-example. I have built several keyboards with Cherry blue switches and several with Cherry clear switches, but even though the Clears have a more pronounced tactile bump and stronger springs than the blues, the blues are much more satisfying for me to type on. Of course it's not practical to use blues in a shared space, so clears are a great choice there. > For a typist (or programmer) the switch is the most important feature of a keyboard. This is true of conventional layouts, but there are several designs that feature improved staggering arrangements (vertical staggering instead of horizontal) or modifiers on the thumbs instead of the pinkies; both of these can contribute to significant improvements in comfort.