6 ms·
Man Prosecuted for Price Fixing on Amazon Marketplace
- fragsworth 12y agoIt's odd how there's prison time for price-fixing collusion between competing entities, but obtaining a monopoly (and therefore price-fixing) is far worse, but usually doesn't get punished or even questioned until the public starts having problems with it.
- Nav_Panel 12y agoBut the government does. Often mergers between large companies will be prevented if they'd create monopolies. Is there something in particular you're thinking of? One exception in particular is patents.
- smt88 12y agoWhich monopolies are you talking about? In the OP, some small fish were colluding. The only unregulated monopolies I can think of (Google search, Apple App Store, Monsanto, Boeing) are very large and powerful, and they'll certainly have many national politicians in their pockets. So I don't find it odd that large monopolies aren't busted very often. It's a predictable outcome of a money-driven political system.
- steve19 12y agoPeople frequently confuse price-fixing with monopolies. There is nothing illegal about having a monopoly. What is illegal is forming cartels and collusion to create restraint/constraint of trade [0] Patents are an example of government granted monopolies (on an idea). The government also grants monopolies to certains businesses or organizations [1]. Government is itself a monopoly of sorts (they don't offer or allow you a choice in Law Enforcement provider). Boeing may be a domestic Monopoly, but only because the size, scope and IP of the organization is hard to replicate. What would have been illegal if they had colluded with Communication Sat providers or NASA to prevent Musk from starting SpaceX. There is no evidence I can see that would prevent a sufficiently motivated entrepreneur from competing with them in the Aerospace Defense sector. Politicians are equal opportunity providers, they accept brides (donations) from anyone with a big wallet ;) [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restraint_of_trade http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restraint_of_trade [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Postal_Service http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Postal_Service
- simoncion 12y ago> they accept brides ... from anyone with a big wallet ;) Tee hee. But, seriously: > [Government doesn't] offer or allow you a choice in Law Enforcement provider. The rise in private security firms and private offender-rehabilitation firms [0] kinda act as defacto law enforcement for some of the lower class. [0] http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2015/02/shoplifting_at_whole_foods_or_bloomingdale_s_pay_corrective_education_company.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2015/0...
- paulornothing 12y agoWell it's more like private security. People don't pay much attention to this mainly because stealing is bad in most people's eyes. People are not so concerned if it's actually legal or not to detain someone and basically blackmail them.
- baddox 12y ago> There is nothing illegal about having a monopoly. What is illegal is forming cartels and collusion to create restraint/constraint of trade. That sounds like a description of a somewhat sane legal system, but it's not a description of United States "antitrust" law. See, for instance, United Staes v. Alcoa. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Alcoa http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Alcoa
- fragsworth 12y agoI was mostly thinking of the ISPs, who actively try to destroy competition, and are charging rates that would be absurd in other (competitive) markets. Other monopolies will probably emerge in the near future.
- cdr 12y agoI guess if your point of comparison is "Google search, Apple App Store, Monsanto, Boeing" the poster market on Amazon is "small fish", but this guy was the former director of Art.com (fired because of the price-fixing investigation, I take it?) - almost certainly a multimillion dollar business.
- XorNot 12y agoGoogle search is in no possible way a monopoly. And the apple app store is questionably one.
- TaylorAlexander 12y agoPeople can't tell there's a monopoly until they see the alternatives. Most monopolies today are so good people have no idea other things are possible. This seems to be a theme with historical monopolies too, which means simply inspiring people to think out of the box is critical to showing people the possibilities.
- taeric 12y agoI don't think your parenthetical can be taken as is. I agree it is more likely to result, but is it really a given?
- joshjdr 12y agoI question what justice is being served here. This doesn't appear to be monopolistic control of the market or price fixing. Consumers are allowed to use price analysis, communication, and deal finding tools, so why not sellers? If this is truly the first DoJ action prosecuting e-commerce, it makes me wonder if this is a case of someone being effectively forced into a plea, similar to what gets outlined here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9323758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9323758 This seems like peas compared to some of the recent alleged price-fixing scandals, i.e. Apple & e-books.
- anigbrowl 12y agoTopkins was accused of conspiring with other poster sellers to use algorithms, for which he wrote computer code, to coordinate price changes, and then share information about poster prices and sales. How is that not price fixing?
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThat is exactly the kind of machine we must nip in the bud. This guy was organizing a cartel from the ground up.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoKeeping consumers safe from the horror of an international poster monopoly? His mistake wasn't creating a cartel, it was using big league price-fixing tactics while being a minor league player - or for impersonating a giant corporation while being a little person. That will get you a nasty sentence if you try it and get caught. Actual price-fixing by corporates is hardly rare, and it doesn't seem to attract much regulator interest. See e.g. http://www.computerworld.com/article/2485343/technology-law-regulation/hp-sues-seven-optical-drive-makers-over-price-fixing.html http://www.computerworld.com/article/2485343/technology-law-...
- onion2k 12y agoActually his mistake was sharing the information. Had he only used it himself to automatically undercut the competition where there was still a profit to be made he could have built himself a nice monopoly.
- anton_tarasenko 12y agoDoesn't Amazon itself violate the Robinson–Patman Act with its dynamic pricing? [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robinson%E2%80%93Patman_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robinson%E2%80%93Patman_Act]
- elmin 12y agoWhat evidence is there that Amazon sets different prices for different users for the same goods?
- anton_tarasenko 12y agoThis, for example: "We do, however find some price variations for Kindle ebooks on www.amazon.com, depending on if the user is logged in to the site or not." [http://arxiv.org/abs/1307.4531 http://arxiv.org/abs/1307.4531] Also see Figure 1 for the evidence of prices highly varying over time. It implies that different users pay different prices within small periods of time.
- tzs 12y agoOne of the elements is that "the effect of such discrimination may be substantially to lessen competition or tend to create a monopoly in any line of commerce". I don't think Amazon's dynamic pricing satisfies that element.
- anton_tarasenko 12y agoThat's up to government commissions to decide whether Amazon "tends to create a monopoly" with dynamic pricing. Amazon discloses nothing about its technologies to the public. What we see is, (1) Different prices for different users; (2) The conflict of interest with the merchants Amazon.com hosts, as Amazon serves both as a host and a reseller; (3) Amazon has an access to other merchants' traffic and prices, and is able to diminish their chances to compete with the service.
- BorisMelnik 12y agocan someone ELI5 exactly what he did (from a technical standpoint) and why this is wrong both ethically and legally? not being facetious genuinely asking. I read the whole article, I get that he changed the prices but why is that wrong? Don't people change prices all the time based on algorithms?
- elmin 12y agoHe colluded with other sellers to 'fix' prices. In a fair market, individual sellers set their own prices. This works to limit the ability of one seller to price gouge. If they charge too much, a competitor will undercut them, gradually lowering the price to a fair deal for both buyers and sellers (in theory). If the sellers all collude however, they can set whatever price they want. This can force buyers to pay more than is 'fair'. In the US, following some major issues with the railroads, antitrust laws were inacted. These laws make getting together with your competitors to set prices illegal in some cases. Some people think this is just a part of doing business. Others believe it's a necessary protection for consumers to maintain a fair market economy.
- sireat 12y agoCollusion on price is the same behaviour that is seen across produce markets(also swap meets et al) across the world. TV teams usually do their yearly investigations but nothing happens. Let's not talk about price collusion in hard drives, pencils etc etc. https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1755&dat=19540206&id=kyAhAAAAIBAJ&sjid=0mQEAAAAIBAJ&pg=2996,789994&hl=en https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1755&dat=19540206&id=... In fact it is quite natural for sellers to try to price-fix if you think about it. The regular sellers at the produce market do not want to piss off each other and realize that selling at the bare minimum profit (or loss) would hurt them all and slowly collusion is reached. Sure a few outcasts would try to lower the prices but they quickly learn if they want to survive and be there for a longer time. It happens because the cost of goods is very similar to all sellers and competing on price alone is not going to make anyone happy(not even buyers). What always confused me about collusion in marketplaces like Amazon is that it seems that it would be much harder to find everyone to agree on pricing and that rebels and rule breakers would be more prevalent.
- modeless 12y agoThat this is prosecuted in a world where Comcast can say "oh, our service areas just happen to exactly not overlap" and "we'll install 2 gigabit service but only where it's absolutely required to undercut our newest competitor and nowhere else ever", is a travesty.
- steego 12y agoIt's the same world where the government will fine you a hundred million dollars for price fixing, but then prop you up with billions of dollars in subsidies. Lysine Price Fixing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysine_price-fixing_conspiracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysine_price-fixing_conspiracy Cato's Study in Corporate Welfare http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-241.html http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-241.html Time and time again, it seems that paying fines are simply a small cost of doing business if you're large and influential enough to have friends in government.
- joshstrange 12y agoYeah the line: > “We will not tolerate anticompetitive conduct, whether it occurs in a smoke-filled room or over the Internet using complex pricing algorithms,” Assistant Attorney General Bill Baer of the Justice Department’s antitrust unit said in a statement. “American consumers have the right to a free and fair marketplace online, as well as in brick and mortar businesses.” Made me ill. No, you will not tolerate small fish but the big fish? Keep turning a blind eye. Great you caught this guy and hit him with $20K... That's NOTHING when you look at all the other instances of price fixing happening with massive corporations...
- marincounty 12y agoAmazon needs to keep an better eye on third party sellers. The make a big deal about the initial credit check(which is easy to get around), and seem to turn a blind eye to customer complaints? Yes, I'm glad our current administration goes after Price fixers. Price fixing is wrong, and frustrating. I don't find it cute at all.
- pmorici 12y agoHow did this even come to their attention. The guy was selling posters of all things. You would think there are bigger fish to fry within this category of crime.
- downandout 12y agoThe interesting thing about this is that the collusion made it illegal, but collusion was probably unnecessary. If someone released an open source pricing tool that would modify prices based on the pricing of the other sellers and and sales data/profits for the individual merchant, the effect would be much the same but it wouldn't be illegal.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> a man has agreed to plead guilty to conspiring to illegally fix the prices of posters he sold online So correct me if I'm wrong, but we don't actually know whether he was guilty or not, right? He may just have pleaded to avoid the costs and the hassle of longer process? (I don't want to spin it into a discussion about plea bargains - it's just that I'm not from the US, I just want to know if I understand the phenomenon correctly.)
- paulornothing 12y agoWell if you plead guilty you are saying you are guilty. You are correct there could have been a deal struck and it was just better in the end to not take the chance in court.