2 ms·
>As it stands, giving the government the power to read any one particular thing will result in it being abused to read other things that were never intended. I
by slg 12y ago
>As it stands, giving the government the power to read any one particular thing will result in it being abused to read other things that were never intended.
Isn't this potentially the real problem? It is why our original system required courts and warrants, checks and balances. The Internet doesn't have to be completely different than the offline world. The police can knock down my door if there is a threat of child abuse or terrorism, but aren't allowed to do the same for a traffic violation. Why would that system need to be different online? We just need to make the process of acquiring and executing a warrant more transparent. That political debate would take precedence over any technical problem like designing a distributed system that could accommodate this type of request.
- Lawtonfogle 12y ago>It is why our original system required courts and warrants, checks and balances. The problem is that current technology allows the government to hide behind 'you have no proof we did anything wrong' and 'state secret' defenses. Maybe a system that makes it clear when communications are being monitored, but the government is going to oppose that as much as a system that can't be monitored. Also, there are few other considerations: No foreign company is going to kick in your door, but they would be willing to hack your computer/listen to your chatter in an attempt to steal company secrets. Any weak point for the government is a weak point for all others. Also, government is made up of some individuals that I do not want anywhere near any backdoors of my systems. Not to say everyone in government is incompetent. Maybe they are if you are head of R&D for some massive project, at which point you would be taking extra precautions.