6 ms·
Is HVEC really used anywhere/by anybody yet?
by zokier 12y ago
Is HVEC really used anywhere/by anybody yet?
- Sevzinn 12y agoMy Vizio p series handles it fine (4K netflix).
- skrowl 12y agoCame here to say "A little company called netflix uses it" but you beat me to it, good sir
- motbob 12y agoAnime groups are playing with it. Anime fansub groups, in general, are hungry for the absolute best in codec technology. Hardware and media player compatibility be damned. An example: their use of 10-bit color. There are some groups in the anime scene whose sole purpose is to take releases from other groups and convert them into standard h.264 video that can play on basically any device.
- ancientworldnow 12y agoI'm a colorist. I spend all day looking at color intensely with very expensive monitors. It makes me really excited to see people who actually care about color reproduction over things like resolution. With that said, I have to ask why these groups are interested in 10-bit when I'm essentially certain they cannot view in 10-bit. Only workstation GPU's (Quadro and FirePro) output 10-bit (consumer GPU's are intentionally crippled to 8-bit) and I can't really think of any monitors that have 10-bit panels under about $1000 (though there are many with 10-bit processing which is nice but doesn't get you to 10-bit monitoring). There are some output boxes intended for video production that can get around the GPU problem, but by the time you've got a full 10-bit environment, you're at $1500 bare minimum which seems excessive for most consumer consumption. So I guess what I'm asking, are these groups interested in having 10-bit because it's better and more desirable (and a placebo quality effect) or are they actively watching these in full 10-bit environments?
- algorithmsRcool 12y agoI am far from an expert on the matter, but i recall the case was made that acceptable color reproduction could be achieved with lower bitrates by using 10-bit encoding. It was about file size, i don't think anyone in the fansubing community expected people to have professional monitors.
- motbob 12y agoIt is a matter of filesize. Testing revealed that using 10-bit allowed for a better picture at similar target bitrates. For an explanation of why this is so, see http://x264.nl/x264/10bit_02-ateme-why_does_10bit_save_bandwidth.pdf http://x264.nl/x264/10bit_02-ateme-why_does_10bit_save_bandw...
- TD-Linux 12y agoMost consumer sources are also-limited to 8-bit precision. 10-bit encodes from these are made using a fancy temporal debanding filter, which only works in certain cases. Keep in mind that there is a range expansion when converting to monitor sRGB. Also several video players now support dithering. So the debanding effect can often be quite visible. Also, x264 benefits from less noise in its references, which means 10-bit gets a small compression performance bump.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- derf_ 12y ago> With that said, I have to ask why these groups are interested in 10-bit when I'm essentially certain they cannot view in 10-bit. The H.264 prediction loop includes some inherent rounding biases and noise injection. Using 10-bit instead of 8-bit reduces the injected noise by 12 dB, which makes a noticeable difference in quality-per-(encoded)-bit, even when the source and display are both 8-bit. I spent some time talking with Google engineers early on in the VP9 design process, and they commented that they had done some experiments, but did not see similar gains by using higher bit depths with VP9. I don't know if that's still true with the final VP9 design, though.
- drewcrawford 12y ago
- praseodym 12y agoiPhone 6 and 6 Plus use H.265 for FaceTime: https://www.apple.com/iphone-6/specs/ https://www.apple.com/iphone-6/specs/ ("FaceTime over cellular uses H.264/H.265")