6 ms·
The part I've always found weird about this story, and the meta-reporting about it, is that the article is long. There's the story about Jackie, which is a hook
by geofft 12y ago
The part I've always found weird about this story, and the meta-reporting about it, is that the article is long. There's the story about Jackie, which is a hook to get you reading and appropriately horrified (and at least in my circle of acquaintances, often the spot where they stop reading because they can't any more...). But the rest of the story is about a university that can't deal with so many problems of a similar nature, and that makes up the bulk of the article. Jackie or no Jackie, is the article accurate that, for instance, the university is nicknamed "UVrApe"? And where did that come from?
It feels to me like, if Rolling Stone had merely decided not to go for the shocking opening story, and decided to call it something other than "A", singular, "Rape on Campus," they'd have had an excellent, well-fact-checked article about many rapes on campus. Which is a far more important problem for the university, the alumni, the local police, and the wider community to worry about than the details of Jackie's story. And the author acknowledges that: "Maybe the discussion should not have been so much about how to accommodate her but should have been about whether she would be in this story at all." In other words, there would have been a story either way.
Am I the only one who reads it this way, and thinks there still is a story even as the article was written? CJR calls Jackie's story "the main narrative in 'A Rape on Campus'", but it doesn't feel like the main narrative at all. If you read a news story about a kid with some horrible childhood disease, and the third paragraph opens "Billy is not alone. Thousands of children across the US have been diagnosed with...," is Billy's story the main narrative? If Billy turned out to be misdiagnosed, does that affect the story?
- brighteyes 12y ago> Am I the only one who reads it this way, and thinks there still is a story even as the article was written? Well, if you read the full report that came out today, then it is clear that there was at least one other major problem in the story. It said that the university did a poor job of handling rape accusations, cared more about its reputation, and so forth. But that turned out to be wrong. Specifically, the report details how the university president and other officials were barred from discussing cases for legal reasons - confidentiality of students and various other federal statutes. What to the reporter seemed like a coverup or negligence, was in fact doing their proper diligence as per the law. Furthermore, the report mentions that several rape survivors they talked to (in the course of making the report) said that UVA had good policies in place for handling rape cases. They have good resources to give to survivors, and they do care about them. Somehow Rolling Stone missed those.
- geofft 12y agoThanks, I missed that. That's good to know (and also good to hear).