4 ms·
So now we'll have to put our trust in software and drivers? :) PC is open indeed, but for the love of me I can't remember the last time I've actually upgraded
by dogma1138 12y ago
So now we'll have to put our trust in software and drivers? :)
PC is open indeed, but for the love of me I can't remember the last time I've actually upgraded a PC. I usually buy a upper mid-range to lower high end PC (currently running Core I7 5820K, 980) but i actually very rare upgrade them. The ones I buy last me for the 2-3 years of which ever games i play at the time, when i can no longer play them at the graphical level i deem acceptable i buy a new one.
And this is because the upgradeability of most PC's is sort of a myth, if you buy a hardware which is all of the same range when you'll have to upgrade a component the rest will become a bottle neck.
And i don't see this being any different, the added cost of the router and the entire protocol simply writes off the benefits considering that an upgrade will require you to upgrade at least 3 major parts.
On top of that you run the risk of the "router" most likely be turned incompatible within a few years simply because the standard will evolve to allow for additional bandwidth, different power requirements, an improved form factor etc.
Take a look at PCI express for example from version 1 to 4 there were huge changes in bandwidth and power supply, and while some hardware kept backwards compatibility it was in most cases severely hindered by the bandwidth limitations. Put in a modern PCIE 3/4 graphics card in a PCI 1 or even 2 slot and you'll see the difference high end cards lose upto 75% of their performance, some wont work at all due to the power supply differences.
Do you really think that for some reason that protocol would be exempt of that?
We already have a combined creativity of a multi-vendor environment, open your phone it has components from a 100 vendors. There are memory vendors, SOC vendors, sensor vendors, radio vendors, screen cameras etc.
You can have an LG phone with a top of the line Sony camera, and NVIDIA SOC and a Samsung memory in it, do you really need to add a plastic square that says Dr Dre to it?
Not to mention that at least now you have the ability to debug issues with fair ease, if the PC over the past 40 years have not managed to tackle cross vendor compatibility even at a hardware level (just check the accepted hardware list for your mother board for example) not to mention on the software level what makes you so sure that this all of a sudden will?
I would rather much see an easy way to connect peripheral discrete devices to my phone with ease for the extremely rare occasion i would (and atm i can't think of one) need it than to have to select different hardware for my phone hoping it will all work together than having 6 different vendors to get support and claim warranty from while hoping that at least 2 or 3 of my lovely blocks will be compatible with the next years model.
- jaywunder 12y agoI thought they were making an MDK to prevent the issues with drivers, do you know about that at all?
- dogma1138 12y agoAnd how is that any different than the driver development kits, frameworks, hardware development kits and reference design guidelines we have today? With all of those we still got issues, my 600$ creative sound card still doesn't work well with Windows 8, vendors still have to patch BIOS, firmware and micro-codes to sort out compatibility issues, and some hardware compatibility issues are not sorted at all. No matter how well you plan things something will not work, today when a phone vendor designs a phone they can and do ensure that all of the hardware is compatible with each other and that the software works (some do it better than others). Do you really think that every single vendor will be able to test their plug with every other currently in existence? And if they will can you even imagine the cost of such certification process? Motherboard vendors today barely test their boards with 1/3rd of the available memory modules, and on every motherboard manual you'll see warning of at least 5 that don't work at all. All of them follow the exact standard set by JEDEC and still manage to mock it up. On the software level for each motherboard you can see 3-4 BIOS upgrades that patch in support for CPU's additional memory vendors, or increase system stability, this isn't something that i look forward to see on my phone. The only reason why i still don't use an AIO PC is that i play games, and once Steam Boxes come down to reasonable price levels and not 600% branded PC markup I'll probably dump it for one. For the rest of my uses, a laptop, tablet, or some other AIO device will work just fine, and judging by where the market is headed I'm probably not alone in this view.
- rsync 12y ago"I would rather much see an easy way to connect peripheral discrete devices to my phone with ease for the extremely rare occasion i would (and atm i can't think of one) need it than to have to select different hardware for my phone hoping it will all work together than having 6 different vendors to get support and claim warranty from while hoping that at least 2 or 3 of my lovely blocks will be compatible with the next years model." No, I'd like the opposite. I want the ability to explicitly, physically remove pieces of the phone - like the GPS module, the camera module, and yes, the GSM/LTE module. These are largely considered core components of the phone, but I want the ability to remove them and replace them as I see fit. The additive functions of a modular phone are not the exciting part - it's the reductive functions that are interesting.