I don't really know enough about physics to be able to judge, but what you say is nicely in accordance with my priors. I think we're in agreement here. I wouldn

I don't really know enough about physics to be able to judge, but what you say is nicely in accordance with my priors. I think we're in agreement here. I wouldn't argue that 3 was the place the argument most likely fails, merely that there is something here that we don't fully understand and which may be rather important -- hence it's reasonable to call it a paradox.