3 ms·
Sadly, we don't need good ideas for how the system should function – lots of people have lots of those – we need good strategies for affecting change in the cur
by sanderjd 12y ago
Sadly, we don't need good ideas for how the system should function – lots of people have lots of those – we need good strategies for affecting change in the current system toward those ideas.
Just to illustrate using your ideas (which I'm absolutely all for), all three of them cost public money. We would have more trials requiring more time in front of judges, but they would need to be speedier, so we would simply need to pay more judges salaries. A similar calculation suggests we would need to pay more public defenders, and if I'm interpreting your last point correctly, we would also want to pay them 20% more than we do currently. So we need a strategy for selling the tax increases at least at the state level – because the districts most affected by these cost increases are probably the least wealthy – and perhaps the federal level. Not many people will care enough that we aren't treating criminals (which is what people who have been arrested are, to most people) well enough to pay extra taxes.
So I guess, what's the strategy to push us onto a path outside this spiral?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pcurve 12y agoFewer prosecutions. Only pursue cases that are slam dunk prioritized by cases that have highest social benefits. More community service based punishment. None resulting in rap sheet. Drastically reduce jury system. Pay Clawback and impose penalty on judge and prosecutors for wrongful convictions. Hit their collective pay pool.
- ams6110 12y agoPaying for more judges, prosecutors, and defenders might be one solution. But consider that a huge fraction of our criminal justice system is occupied by drug-related offenses. Another large fraction is occupied by violent crimes related to drug trafficking. It would be an interesting experiment to unload that from the courts and then see how speedily the remaining cases could be tried.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoOr we could just stop prosecuting so many people. The US has far more people incarcerated than any other country. Clearly we could function perfectly well without having so many trials that we need to have plea bargaining.