4 ms·
Is it just me or is the large Hadron collider really scary in how it can start a black hole chain reaction?
by EGreg 12y ago
Is it just me or is the large Hadron collider really scary in how it can start a black hole chain reaction?
- ufmace 12y agoNo, and here's a really detailed explanation as to why this couldn't possibly happen: https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/could-the-lhc-make-an-earth-killing-black-hole-886d9e600c28 https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/could-the-lhc-make-an-... TL:DR: 1.) If these miniature black holes exist, the Earth has been getting hit by them for billions of years, and it’s still here. 2.) If you do create a miniature black hole, they will decay, via Hawking Radiation, on ridiculously small timescales. 3.) You can compute the rate at which a black hole eats matter, and it’s not even close to being as small as the lifetime of our planet.
- blackMatterFood 12y agothe rate at which a black hole eats matter... ...it’s not even close to being as small as the lifetime of our planet. So the duration of time in which any given black hole might eat an amount of matter takes a lot longer than the age of the earth? I think it's important to note that these things being discussed would potentially be micro-singularities, smaller than anything that might be visible to the naked eye. Otherwise, it's pretty obvious that a planetary-scale black hole could handily destroy the earth in short order, by way of mere collision, whether consumes all of the earth's matter beyond its event horizon or not. ...anyway, yeah, the LHC's capacity for stranglets is otherwise negligible, and not very worrisome at all.
- mitchty 12y agoCan you explain? The LHC produces energies that are less than what the earth has been bombarded with from cosmic sources since time immemorial. Also what exactly is a "black hole chain reaction"? How are these black holes possible exactly? The energy involved in a single proton are not enough for a stable microscopic black hole to form. This is presuming it even CAN form (its at best a hypothesis) given our understanding of gravity.
- sebastianconcpt 12y agoI guess is fear to unknown and unanticipated phenomena. Crazy high unpredicted outputs happened before (google operation Castle Bravo) so is not totally insane to consider a worst case scenario. We don't have exactly a kickass theory (that's why we built the LHC in the fisrt place) and all we can talk (predict) about black holes formation is merely hypotetical. I don't think we are in danger with this experiments other than draining taxpayers money at virtually zero ROI
- akiselev 12y agoWe do have a kickass theory, two in fact: the standard model and general relativity. We still have a lot to learn about both (which is why we built the LHC) but to suggest that high energy particles with energies and densities many, many orders of magnitude smaller than of our sun can create a black hole (which itself is an order of magnitude too small to collapse into a black hole) requires some serious mental gymnastics falling well outside of observed physics.
- sebastianconcpt 12y agoWe have a multiparadigmatic-conflicting set of models to try to explain (parts of) the observable Universe. If a theory can't explain nor predict origin of Black Holes, Dark Matter and say what Gravity actually is and why happens, then that doesn't qualify as Kickass in my book. Show me teleportation and controllable antigravity and we can talk kickass again.
- mitchty 12y agoExactly, the energy of one particle is the same as how much a mosquito puts out if I remember correctly. The black holes formed from this, and this is presuming its possible to do so mind, wouldn't have enough energy to pull in other matter. Could our theories be wrong here? Sure, but worrying about this is just like the scientists worried we would ignite our atmosphere with nuclear testing. That is, its unlikely at best and needless worry in general.
- sebastianconcpt 12y agoA sustained chain reaction requires a lot of things that here don't look likely to be set. On the other hand, some ants playing with insecticide indeed searched for a sustained chain reaction and yieled x3 the anticipated output during operation Castle Bravo https://medium.com/war-is-boring/those-who-witnessed-castle-bravo-looked-into-armageddon-fa7610578413 https://medium.com/war-is-boring/those-who-witnessed-castle-...
- r721 12y agoThe safety of the LHC: http://press.web.cern.ch/backgrounders/safety-lhc http://press.web.cern.ch/backgrounders/safety-lhc
- nn3 12y agoIt is just you.
- bluedino 12y agoDid some people theorize that testing a nuclear weapon could cause the entire atmosphere of the earth to ignite?
- edmccard 12y agoYes, at one point Edward Teller ("father of the H-Bomb") thought that thermonuclear weapons might set off a self-sustaining fusion reaction in the atmospheric nitrogen. I only know about this because as a kid I read a lot of pre-space-age sci-fi, and there was a story either by Heinlein or Asimov where the solution to this "danger" was to put nuclear fusion plants in orbit.
- Someone 12y agoThe magic search term for this is "Konopinski report". That gives you, a.o. https://fas.org/sgp/othergov/doe/lanl/docs1/00329010.pdf https://fas.org/sgp/othergov/doe/lanl/docs1/00329010.pdf Safety factor to get some nitrogen ignition is a worrying 1.5 when using fusion bombs of a thousand cubic meters, but even then, the reaction will fizzle out (at least, that's what I get from the abstract)
- maxander 12y agoPhysicists have looked at all the angles on this, and are pretty certain there's nothing the LHC could do that would pose a threat to the world. On the other hand, the universe still looks pretty empty of extraterrestrial civilizations, despite the availability of nice planets and so forth. Perhaps they were all pretty certain too.
- cryptoz 12y agoYou can watch the live stream of the webcam on location if you are concerned about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JYkMhQ9gf8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JYkMhQ9gf8
- cletus 12y agoThis reminds me of one of my favourite Google doodles ever: http://www.google.com/doodles/large-hadron-collider http://www.google.com/doodles/large-hadron-collider
- grey413 12y agoNope! Cosmic radiation causes much higher energy collisions in our atmosphere every microsecond of every day. Even if those collisions form black holes, our continued existence as non-singularities is evidence enough that they're not an issue.
- deelowe 12y agoNo one ever made those comments seriously. This is similar to the "atomic bombs will ignite the atmosphere" comments that are misquoted. A scientist makes a fanciful comment in jest and the media just runs with it. There's nothing to be concerned with going on at CERN. We can't even come close to the energies nature produces every day.