5 ms·
Tales from the Trenches: I was SWATed
- brohee 12y agoThis is only a matter of time until someone is killed... It looks like it almost happened on January 15 when a victim shot home invaders that happened to be SWAT making a no knock entry. http://www.foxnews.com/us/2015/01/19/oklahoma-man-at-center-police-shooting-said-never-made-11-call-that-led-to-raid/ http://www.foxnews.com/us/2015/01/19/oklahoma-man-at-center-...
- Udo 12y agoIf police not identifying themselves is becoming a pattern, it's going to be very confusing and dangerous to ordinary people. I live in Germany, in a completely safe and virtually crimeless idyllic suburb. A couple of months ago I came home at noon and noticed a small group of what looked like thugs loitering at the front door of my neighbor's house. One of them kept banging the door and shouting "open up, or you don't want to find out what happens next" (or something to that effect) in a thick regional dialect. All the neighbors were hiding in their houses, but I was already on the street right in front of them, so I walked over and asked "is there something wrong here?". Two of the thugs blocked my way and the shouting guy exclaimed "move along, there is nothing to see here". This was the point when I was getting out my phone and started dialing the police emergency number, just as two trucks of the fire department and a police van were moving in from opposite ends of the street, coming to a halt in front of the house. Uniformed people swarmed out and joined what I had assumed to be thugs before. Turns out they were plain-clothes officers. In the end, it came out it was a pot raid, but apparently nothing was found. In slightly different circumstances, this could have escalated quickly. The plain clothes officers were clearly looking for trouble. At the very least they were enjoying their effect on the civilians. It's not a SWAT yet, but it's enough to make me uncomfortable; especially considering the history of the country. It's not always been like this here. I do have friends who are police officers, and generally they take pride in the fact that (and I quote) "it's not like in the US", but I'm afraid we might be importing this problem now.
- Rainymood 12y ago>In slightly different circumstances, this could have escalated quickly. You mean, when people have guns? Here in the Netherlands most of the people have a healthy dose of respect towards police officers. Especially with their new shiny uniforms.
- Udo 12y ago> You mean, when people have guns? I mean when police officers refuse to identify as such, ignorantly or willfully creating a situation where civilians think they're in danger. It's not safe for anybody involved. > Especially with their new shiny uniforms. I think they're updating the uniforms all over the EU, making them more alike. They do look snazzy. ;)
- plongeur 12y agoI mean - let's be honest - there is a reason why somebody chooses to become a cop. And more often than not - this very reason isn't about "helping people". It's more likely about enjoying the exertion of power over people. There is a stronger psychological similarity between ordinary hooligans and police men than what is good. It's also always the police who will eagerly suppress people in case a state turns increasingly totalitarian - policemen don't like thinking for themselves - which is why they choose those hierarchical jobs in the first place. They like to have action and the feeling of adrenalin. Also it's worth thinking about this - the SS in Nazi Germany was made up of about 2% of the population. Now this personality type who would do SS jobs didn't just go away - the root is of psychological nature which is most likely more or less uniformly distributed within any population. Now those guys - in that psychological, statistical sense still exist - what do you think what kind of job they will choose? Elder care? Most likely either military or police.
- fenomas 12y ago> there is a reason why somebody chooses to become a cop.. Raymond Chandler: "Police business is a hell of a problem. It’s a good deal like politics. It asks for the highest type of men, and there’s nothing in it to attract the highest type of men."
- josu 12y agoIs this a US only phenomenon or is it happening in other countries too?
- Foomandoonian 12y agoI was wondering this recently. It's hard to imagine this happening here in the UK. The thought of police in riot gear kicking down doors and waving guns around sounds beyond crazy to me.
- iLoch 12y agoNo knock entries are indeed insane - I don't understand the scenario that would be required for a no-knock entry to be the only acceptable option. Are the police scared of the occupants firing guns at them? That would be ironic.
- cperciva 12y agoI don't understand the scenario that would be required for a no-knock entry to be the only acceptable option. The classic example is if the police think that evidence could be destroyed very quickly, e.g., electronic records.
- XorNot 12y agoWhich would be exactly what's not happening if "a guy has a gun". Either someone is in danger, in which case no-knock isn't needed, or they're not, in which case why the hell is a SWAT raid being carried out on the basis of an anonymous tip?
- 15155 12y agoThis is such a bullshit reason: For one, you could detect these no-knocking individuals quite easily: - Cameras on the exterior of the property - Motion lights, motion sensors, motion bells are all quite cheap. And re: destruction/obfuscation of electronic evidence- -"One-click" destruction scripts, etc. - TrueCrypt volumes, everywhere. Circuit breakers, power strips, etc. with switches. If you don't manage to destroy the volume, no aggressor will be able to access it. - Degaussing setups for spinning disks, activated by similar mechanisms. This stuff is pretty cheap, easily available. Anybody caught by these technically-incompetent police executing no-knock raids deserves to be caught. Hell, if you don't have a few 6TB volumes full of random bits, labeled "Evidence," you aren't doing it right. Gotta tie up those investigative resources somehow.
- cperciva 12y agoIt's worth noting that this is just the latest in a long series of episodes of harassment which Randi has experienced -- it's not just another case of gamers taking their competition offline, which is the most common swatting backstory I hear about these days. Rather than allowing herself to be driven out of the field as many other women have been[1], Randi is fighting back and recently founded the Online Abuse Prevention Initiative (http://onlineabuseprevention.org/ http://onlineabuseprevention.org/), which aims to help people protect themselves from harassment and to help tech companies and law enforcement to better respond to this problem. If anyone expected this to stop Randi, they're sorely mistaken. I know Randi as a FreeBSD developer, and she is one of the most fearless people I've ever met. [1] Not intended to cast aspersions on those women who have been driven out; if I faced the same experience I too would have been driven out of this field.
- belorn 12y agoPlease don't belittle victims of crime by describing their experience as "just another case of gamers taking their competition offline". People of both gender experience harassment in life, and at times it goes into the realm of becoming victim of crimes. It should not matter what gender you are or your chosen profession in life, by belittle it you are causing direct harm to other human beings. Please stop.
- fenomas 12y agoPlease assume good faith when it comes to subtleties of wording like this. Just because you feel the post could be interpreted as belittling doesn't imply that that was the author's intent.
- simoncion 12y agoThis isn't belittlement, it is -as was stated- the most common motive for SWATting. Angry 14-year-olds [0] (whether they're raging about getting pwnt in Call of Duty[1], or doing it for the lulz on *chan) are the vast majority of the folks who engage in SWATting. I urge you to carefully re-read the comment that you criticized. It's pretty clear to me that cperciva has no intention of belittling anyone. [0] Either chronologically or developmentally [1] Or whatever
- jkot 12y agoPolice on video has long assault rifles, but no protective gear (helmets, body-armor). Is not that bit suboptimal for indoors?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- voltagex_ 12y agoShe was SWATted and produced one of the most detailed and level-headed reports I've seen. How on earth is that blown out of proportion?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 12y agoYour first post appears to say that gamergate wasn't responsible for the swatting, just a couple of trolls using the GG name as cover; and that she was also engaging in similar levels of abuse and harassment. Maybe I misread it and that's not what you meant?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 12y agoI'm not sure discussing this is difficult. Making a false police report in order to send police to someone's home is obviously wrong and should be easy to condemn. Even this post you appear to be saying there's more to it than that. If you think she's lying you should gather evidence and post it rather than insinuating it. EDIT: I mean, unless you called the police station to check the details you can either believe her version of events or believe someone else's version. I'm not sure why you'd go for that other person's version without very good evidence.
- mikkom 12y ago> Discussing this madness is just impossible, especially if it turns into holier-than-thou. And it's especially hard if people discussing delete their discussion.
- raverbashing 12y agoKids (I'm talking about "mental age" here) are not aware of the consequences of their acts. They find it "funny" This also fits with their treatment of woman online. Hope they find it funny as well when they're prosecuted.
- csixty4 12y agoI don't want this to be seen as excusing this behavior or justifying it, so let's get that on the table right away. In some cases, they may be well aware of the consequences & just not care. I went through a phase in my early teens where I might have done things like this if it was a possibility. I grew up in a home where rules were arbitrary and basically boiled down to one thing: whatever I did or didn't do was wrong. My friends were all bad people and I was forbidden from seeing them. Their parents were all irresponsible people and I was forbidden from sleeping over at their houses. Mom fell asleep on the couch and I turned the TV off; I was treating her like a child and disrespecting her. Mom fell asleep on the couch and I didn't turn the TV off; I was wasting electricity. If I fell asleep on the couch with the TV on I needed to learn some respect for other people who had to sleep in the same house with all that damn noise. You get the idea. I acted out because nobody cared about how I felt, so why should I care about anyone else? I wish mandatory reporting was a thing back when I came to school with a red handprint on my face. As a pre-teen, I wanted to be the one making other people suffer for a change. Consequences didn't matter because I was already guilty of something, so why not have a real reason for it, have some fun along the way. Again, this doesn't mean there shouldn't be consequences for this behavior. But we should consider that some of these misanthropes are themselves victims of abuse looking for some sense of power or control in life and find ways to get them help.
- Svenstaro 12y agoIf they found it funny when they're prosecuted, the prosecution wouldn't be very effective.
- mrebus 12y agoPeople keep on saying it's kids(mental age), but I don't buy it. I was reading a book on psychopathy/sociopath(can't remember the name) but one of the theses were just how common they actually are. In times past these people would just be dicks to people around them. Now they can actual fuck with people with far greater reach. I think they are fully aware of what they are doing and only find it funny because they lack empathy.
- middleclick 12y agoI am curious, how do these trolls find the addresses of people whom they want to SWAT? Is such information easily available in US? I tend to keep my private and personal life separate but stories like these scare me.
- trwired 12y agoThis is usually a result of doxxing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxing
- Udo 12y agoMy guess is if you have haters willing to expend the energy, it's very likely almost anyone who has a significant online presence can be doxxed. In some cases, it's as simple as making a WHOIS query - for example, they could locate me from just my HN account in about two minutes.
- csandreasen 12y agoIt's really easy to have your information posted publicly without even knowing it. There's a whole industry in the US that buys up public records, cross-references them and sells them as 'background checks'. Buy a house? Your name and address is now a public record. Sign up for Cable TV/Internet with free phone service thrown in? Hope you checked to pay the extra 'unlisted number' fee because otherwise your name address and phone number are now in the phone book. Ever have to settle something in court? Your name and address, along with whatever you went to court over are now publicly available. In the past you'd actually have to go to some county government office to view the records, but these companies will collect them in bulk and sell the information on the internet. Most of them will let you claim it and take down the information for free, but then go on to offer sell you services where they go and send take down notifications to a bunch of other sites. It's a huge racket.
- pdkl95 12y agoI really need to read Pat Cadigan's book "Tea From An Empty Cup"[1] again sometime soon, which was probably foreshadowing for SWATing-style attacks. The story is centered around an online gamer who is killed in real life because of stuff that happens in-game. It explores the often-assumed belief that it doesn't matter what you do because "it's just a game" or "I was only trolling", and how for some people the line between fantasy and reality is not as obvious as it should be. [1] http://www.tor.com/blogs/2010/06/qlife-is-so-cheap-in-dc-q-being-a-review-of-pat-cadigans-tea-from-an-empty-cup http://www.tor.com/blogs/2010/06/qlife-is-so-cheap-in-dc-q-b...
- possibilistic 12y agoGiven the recent judicial president set for revenge porn cases, I feel we need a similarly harsh ruling for those found guilty of swatting. This is a crime that could easily result in the deaths of innocent victims, and the punishment needs to reflect that. Doxing for the purposes of shaming wouldn't be bad to punish either. I don't want us to become a vengeful police state, but this kind of cowardly behavior makes me angry. Aside from training the police, FBI, et al., how do we go about stopping this from happening more frequently?
- fenomas 12y ago> how do we go about stopping this from happening more frequently? I suppose there's more to it than just better police procedures, but I'm gobsmacked every time I read about a police force breaking down a door, or even drawing a gun, based on nothing but an anonymous email or phone call. It smacks of a system that's never encountered bad inputs before. In a way it's surprising that actual criminal gangs didn't catch onto this years ago, and start swatting their rivals.
- DanBC 12y ago> In a way it's surprising that actual criminal gangs didn't catch onto this years ago, and start swatting their rivals. In England it used to be the case that many reports to "Crimestoppers" (an anonymous tip-off line) were from drug dealers informing on the competitors. And here's an article from 2000 about informants http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2000/nov/12/ukcrime.tonythompson http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2000/nov/12/ukcrime.tonythomps...
- Snesker 12y agoI would not take anything this individual says at face value. Swatting is certainly a topic that warrants discussion, but this individual is not. (I'm going to be banned for this post)