4 ms·
"In principle, a solar sail can do anything a regular sail can do, like tacking." No it can't. Can it? So far as I understand, tacking requires the water of t
by ars 17y ago
"In principle, a solar sail can do anything a regular sail can do, like tacking."
No it can't. Can it?
So far as I understand, tacking requires the water of the ocean to redirect your momentum. There is nothing that would do this in space.
- wtallis 17y agoI don't think you could sail "upwind" using just a solar sail, but you could use the sail to reduce your angular momentum about the star and then let gravity pull you back toward the sun.
- olefoo 17y agoGravity, the spacecraft's own mass, and the angle of incidence of light on the sail. The definition of tacking for solar sails is that your vector is at an angle to that of the incident sunlight. In other words you are able to generate some sideways motion rather than just getting pushed.
- camccann 17y agoA wind-driven land vehicle can tack just as well as a sailboat can, and possibly better. If memory serves me, in the fully general case, all that's required is an exploitable difference in velocity at the interface of two media (ground/air, water/air, etc.) to extract energy and move in arbitrary directions (or even do counterintuitive things, like go faster than either medium as a sailboat tacking downwind does). In space, a solar sailcraft is embedded in a single medium. So, no, no tacking.
- ars 17y agoWhy has he been downmodded? Downmods below 0 are ONLY for spam, and "me too" like posts!
- InclinedPlane 17y agoThere are two forces in play: the propulsion of the sail due to the Sun's light, and gravity. By directing the thrust of the sail against the orbital momentum of the spacecraft it will be pushed initially slightly farther from the Sun but also slowed down in its orbit, causing gravity to pull it closer to the Sun.