5 ms·
Alcohol or Marijuana?
- ekianjo 12y agoPot is not just a matter of whether it's less harmful versus alcohol or not. If you are hanging with people who smoke pot, you become a passive smoker as well - this kind of issue does not happen with alcohol at the least. That's the same problem I have with smoking in general - I'm fine with people smoking on their own, but I loathe the attitude of rude smokers who think they can smoke anywhere, at any time, without considering their impact on others (including the disgusting smell that impregnates your clothes).
- cheepin 12y ago"The immediate answer, of course, is “neither.” But no parent accepts that. It’s assumed, and not incorrectly, that the vast majority of adolescents will try one or the other, especially when they go to college." The article builds off of this, and while interesting, it strikes me as too resigned that either binge drinking or marijuana use is to be expected. Evidence firmly points that "neither" is the correct answer by a large margin, but then we spend our time looking for the second best solution. This is a cultural problem, and the way forward is not to choose the second worst answer instead of the absolute worst: it's to create an environment where people can choose the best answer.
- moopling 12y agoIt seems to me that people often undervalue the short term effects of drugs. Sure they can reduce the length and quality of your life, but in turn they can also draw you closer to the other people in your life and give you wonderful memories. Everything in life is a trade, and it's pointless to overvalue a life less worth living.
- ux-app 12y ago> This is a cultural problem, and the way forward is not to choose the second worst answer instead of the absolute worst: it's to create an environment where people can choose the best answer. I don't agree. To think that we can solve substance (ab)use issues with cultural intervention is to deny the basic biological aspects. Many species simply enjoy altering their consciousness. Humans are very inventive in this regard but it's common throughout the animal kingdom. Instead of denying a basic human urge, we should stop criminalizing it. Properly support those that have developed a dependency and move away from the nanny state. Harm reduction should be the overarching aim.
- sliverstorm 12y agoWhen was this about pot legalization? I thought I just read an article comparing alcohol to pot; can we have a discussion relating to pot without having to talk about legality for the zillionth time?
- rosser 12y agoGP sounds more like a call for decriminalization and harm reduction than outright legalization. There is a difference. EDIT: And in response to your shadow edit: no, we can't. A significant factor in the abuse of drugs — and marijuana in particular, given its relative harmlessness — is their very illegality. The forbidden fruit seems to be far more tempting.
- sliverstorm 12y agoMade the edit before I saw your reply, apologies.. Maybe you're right, maybe its legal status is the only thing about pot that really matters, but it's such a multidimensional issue I hate seeing the conversation home in on legalization/decriminalization every time. A change in legal status will not solve all its problems (else why does alcohol have problems?), and we have just read an essay which spends very few words even talking about legal status, which I think supports my point that there are so many other important angles to talk about.
- rosser 12y agoLet's file all the, "But pot ruined my father's brother's nephew's cousin's former roommate's life!" stories under this thread, rather than cluttering the discussion with countless top-level threads that all offer variations on the same kind of N=1 anecdata.
- gone35 12y agoLet's not. In medicine, N=1 is no joke: the reason being that, when (i) there are so many unknowns, (ii) there is so little experimental data, and (iii) the consequences are so potentially severe, from a decision-theoretical point of view it makes no sense to ignore data at all, no matter how biased. You would be surprised how many of the 'black-box' warnings in common pharmaceuticals come from on N=1 individual reports. Hell, papers are written on individual medical cases... Now you might even argue that hearsay is not 'data', but in fact it is: for instance, there is quite a bit of NLP literature on trying to identify unreported side effects of medications from 'informal' channels like social media. Even if it's a second or third or fourth report, it is a report nonetheless, and should be taken seriously. So let's not be gratuitiously negative [1] about people's negative reports about marihuana, no matter how biased you might think they might be. This is one of the most dramatic public health changes since the Prohibition we're talking about, so what is at stake is the health of millions of people for possibly many generations --so even very small effects otherwise considered too rare to matter might have an outsize impact on large segments of society. [1] http://blog.ycombinator.com/new-hacker-news-guideline http://blog.ycombinator.com/new-hacker-news-guideline
- igl 12y agoI feel discussing weed vs alcohol really tiresome too. I never had "paranoia" smoking weed and I never started bar fights or stole cars while drunk. It's a personal thing. If you smoke weed and jump out of windows or smash people faces because you got drunk, you are probably already bent in some way. These are soft drugs and should be legal simply for drying out the black market. And have them available in a controlled manner.
- salemh 12y agoIt's interesting to me how alcohol-centric our(US. But is it any diferent in a developed country?) culture is. I can take a breather with my entire team to a beer bar, brats and beer, but I can't go to some "bar" and take two puffs off of a joint. Many things in social circumstance seem to depend on booze: >lets get a drink >lets hang out at _x_ house, bring a six pack >lets get drunk and watch __ The same doesn't work for marijuana at least in lots of verbal contexts (being over heard by your superiors.).
- SeoxyS 12y agoSounds to me like Alcohol has more potential to be abused and cause damage in the short term (bad decision making, drunk driving, risk of addiction), while Marijuana has has less high risk outcomes but more long-term negative effects when used casually (likely to lead to a less productive and successful life). Basically: pot makes you moderately dumber for the rest of your life, booze increases the small risks of catastrophic outcomes for short periods of time. I've tried pretty much everything; and then decided that Marijuana is something I don't want to - haven't had any in 5+ years. I drink Alcohol regularly, but seldom getting more than tipsy. I know my limits, and even if I do get drunk, I'm smart enough to not put myself in bad situations: I don't drive & drink, I know when to stop, and pay attention to my surroundings. I prefer that to the idea of losing 20% of my intelligence.
- ux-app 12y ago> I know my limits, and even if I do get drunk, I'm smart enough to not put myself in bad situations: I don't drive & drink, I know when to stop, and pay attention to my surroundings. At 34 I'm the same. But when I think back to all of the incredibly stupid and dangerous things I did under the influence of alcohol I realize that I'm lucky to be alive. There's no way to really know, but I think that in an alternate universe where pot is legal and alcohol is not it would be a net positive for society. Alcohol makes many people aggressive and drastically lowers inhibitions. In my experience pot makes people mellow and keen for some Donkey Kong and pizza!
- sliverstorm 12y agoAlcohol makes many people aggressive and drastically lowers inhibitions. In my experience pot makes people mellow and keen for some Donkey Kong and pizza! This is too narrow a viewpoint. Alcohol makes me mellow, friendly, hungry, and more into games. I know people for which pot makes them aggressive (I think as a result of paranoia).
- ux-app 12y ago> I know people for which pot makes them aggressive (I think as a result of paranoia). Fair enough. I think the general consensus is that alcohol leads to aggression more so than pot, but your own personal experience may differ. Are these people only using pot, or are they mixing with alcohol or other drugs? This is all anecdotal of course, but I've personally never seen 2 people high from pot act aggressively or want to fight etc.
- g8gggu89 12y agoWhy choose between them when you can have both?
- gregpilling 12y agoIn 5 years pot will probably be legal. It is in 23 states now http://medicalmarijuana.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=000881 http://medicalmarijuana.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourc... Personally I think Obama will legalize just before he leaves office, we will have to see. I would tell my kids "neither" and suggest pot over alcohol if pushed. Alcohol has caused several deaths of people in my life, and I can't say the same about weed. A few kids in my high school got killed in car accidents fueled by alcohol, and this has left an impact on me ever since.
- Retra 12y agoNobody you know has died of lung cancer?
- nickysielicki 12y agoPot can be consumed without smoking it.
- _RPM 12y agoHow about neither? Why does anyone need to pick?
- borgia 12y agoStudy after study, dataset after dataset, have shown marijuana to be a less dangerous drug than alcohol. It is also a less socially destructive drug. We've also seen that better access to drugs leads to a lowering in overall drug use. If my kids were to come to me and ask about alcohol vs marijuana, regardless of legality, I would tell them that they should aim to have small amounts of alcohol frequently and small amounts of marijuana very occasionally. If that put them in a situation whereby most of their life was sober, they still had a few drinks at an occasional party and occasionally had a joint or two, I think they'd be in good shape and still get to enjoy some great experiences that pure abstinence would withhold from them. It's not a good idea to use either drug heavily and frequently, particularly when one's brain is still developing. With that being said, almost everyone I know has drank frequently and often pretty heavily since their teens and I haven't witnessed any of them really suffering for it. I have, on the other hand, watched many people abuse pot from a young age and now, over a decade later, their life and mental health is a wreck. But perhaps they abused pot because they weren't mentally stable anyway and it just made things worse, but that this was somewhat inevitable? It's hard to tell, but neither drug used in moderation will do much damage and so, legal or not, it really just remains a case of "all in moderation".
- reality_czech 12y agoMarijuana is a fat-soluble drug. When you start consuming it, it gets stored inside adipose (fat) cells in your body. When your body needs to burn some of that fat, the drug will get released. So you never really get off of it until months after you stop using it. In contrast, alcohol and its byproducts are quickly metabolized and leave your body in a few hours. Neither alcohol nor pot is good for developing brains, but alcohol doesn't hang around. Pot does. Alcohol is certainly a more "dangerous drug" in the sense that it's easier to overdose on it than pot. Of course, if that's our measure, paracetemol (Tylenol) is more dangerous than either. It only takes a small amount of Tylenol to cause liver failure and death. And unlike alcohol, you probably won't throw up on an overdose. Honestly I get tired of these articles comparing pot and alcohol. They always miss the point. Yes, they're both drugs, but that's about where the similarity ends. Pot is a lifestyle drug because it hangs around in your body. Alcohol is something that you can take or not take on each day as you choose. It would be a lot better to legalize MDMA, or maybe some MDMA analogue that didn't have the neurotoxicity issues. Incoming downvotes from pot advocates in 3, 2, 1...
- cbd1984 12y agoPot is usually smoked, so it has an area effect. Alcohol doesn't. This would be less of an issue if smokers were more concerned with secondhand smoke, and if marijuana users in particular weren't so convinced that their drug of choice was not only harmless, but a force for good in the world. No, I don't want to get high off of you, and getting me high without asking me isn't doing me a favor.