5 ms·
Postmodern Ponzi Schemes: Empirical Analysis of High-Yield Investment Programs [pdf]
- gwern 12y agoExcerpts: https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/A45SaBvuDNr https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/A45SaBvu...
- joshu 12y agoThis was a fascinating read.
- aidos 12y agoAgreed, really interesting. Not something I'd even heard of before. The world is definitely full of colourful little subcultures! I wonder about the discussions on cracking down on the various offenders. They claim that most people involved understand the scam - if that's the case, why even bother stopping people. I get that there are probably those who naively walk in and lose a bit of cash, but it seems pretty complicated to even get started. Arguably the resources are much better spent on educating people about dangers on the Internet. If they don't have this scam to fall for they'll just get done some other way.
- joshu 12y agoIndeed. I assume it's illegal to participate in these as well. The hidden banking system was also interesting to see. I think the problem of scam investments is only going to be bigger, especially with crowdfunding in the future. I worry about saying much about this though as an actual accredited investor and don't want to seem exclusionary.
- loceng 12y agoUnrelated, I am curious if anyone knows if anyone is doing or has done a paper on Bitcoin and explored the idea on how it is or isn't similar to a Ponzi scheme?
- kleer001 12y agoBitcoin isn't a ponzi scheme because nobody is being promised a gain in wealth.
- loceng 12y agoTell that to all of the investors putting money into the ecosystem (and amassing Bitcoin in hopes that the increased value will increase the value of their own Bitcoin)..
- stormbrew 12y agoMore specifically, no one is being guaranteed a specific (large) direct return in a specific amount of time. In a ponzi scheme the person who sells you the investment also gives you the return (from the investments of the next batch). They tell you they'll "triple your money in three months!" and they do. Until they don't. In a ponzi scheme there isn't even a thing, commodity or otherwise, being invested in really. You never own anything except the promise of return. Your money is going nowhere but to the last batch of people to buy in via the person you bought it from, and then when Mr. Ponzi decides its time, into his own pockets as he runs away as fast as he can. It's entirely possible to consider bitcoin a scam, or a bubble, but it really has no similarity to a ponzi scheme. It's a commodity asset that may have no long term value that's been over-zealously sold. [Added Note: It'd possibly be accurate to describe what Mt.Gox specifically was/became as a ponzi scheme]
- kleer001 12y ago> over-zealously sold. Right there. I think the technology is great, but it has been speculated into the stratosphere.
- gnaritas 12y agoYou don't know what a Ponzi scheme is, that's clear.
- omegavesko 12y ago
- dataker 12y agoI'm excited with the emergence of cryptocurrencies and the new equity crowdfunding JOBS Act, but I fear what scams people will exist, once people gather these two.
- javert 12y agoI don't worry about that. Poor people who can't afford to lose money generally don't invest in online ponzi schemes that require the use of exotic digital currencies. Realistically, the "investors" are people who want to gamble with their money. Who cares if they lose it?
- markmassie 12y agoThe millions of dollars raised by scammers through crowdfunding proves otherwise [1]. [1] http://pando.com/tag/scampaign/ http://pando.com/tag/scampaign/
- javert 12y agoWell, I was talking about high-yield investments and you are talking about crowdfunding. But that is my fault because the person I replied to was also talking about crowdfunding. However, I don't think people are spending money they can't afford to lose on crowdfunding projects, either. They are spending money they can afford to lose.
- nl 12y agoThat simply isn't true. Read this thread for many anecdotes about how desperate people are often the easiest marks for schemes involving ways to get unbelievable returns.
- omegavesko 12y agoYou're forgetting that many people are poor because they never got proper financial education. They're poor because they can't handle money, not the other way around. In fact, this demographic is probably the primary target of schemes like this. If you're smart enough to handle your money well, you're smart enough to not fall for stuff like this.
- javert 12y agoShould say [2012] in title. This is an old paper that apparently predates the point in time when bitcoin started getting used for this kind of scheme. For example this one [1]. [1] http://insidebitcoins.com/news/trendon-shavers-bitcoin-ponzi-schemer-charged-40-million-fine/24716 http://insidebitcoins.com/news/trendon-shavers-bitcoin-ponzi...
- gwern 12y agoI think the interest of this is pretty timeless - that such a bizarre gambling/investment subculture could exist at all... And the Pirateat40 example isn't really 'post-modern' but a more standard classical Ponzi where it poses as a possibly-real business: there was considerable doubt among quite a few people about Pirate possibly doing some sort of arbitrage on the relatively inefficient Bitcoin exchanges at the time, and it took the Ponzi growing substantially & Vandroiy making his famous bet against Pirate to make it clear to all and sundry that yes, it really was a Ponzi; after Vandroiy's bet, it might have been 'post-modern' but that period only took a few weeks (months?) and then it folded.
- javert 12y agoI think it's pretty timeless too. But still, I imagine there was a huge shift in this area after bitcoin became more well-known, so the fact that the article comes before that point in time matters. And given bitcoin's reputation, I just assumed the article was about bitcoin from the title. (I say this as someone who is a big fan of bitcoin.) You are right about pirateat40. I was paying attention to it at the time. It was not at all certain that it was a ponzi scheme. However, let me make one comment for other people who may not be so familiar with it. It became completely obvious that it was probably a Ponzi scheme, early enough for people to take their money out of it who didn't want to just gamble. Of course, I admit, that's a subjective analysis.
- downandout 12y agoThe interesting thing is that the whole purpose of the concept of an HYIP is to give potential victims a plausible explanation as to where their impressive returns will come from. As it turns out, you don't even have to do that to convince people to send you money. A few days ago I posted a link to a scam that Instagram has allowed to flourish, to the tune of 263,000 posts [1]. It didn't get any traction on here, but going through some of the listings speaks volumes about the about the psychology of scammers and their victims. In this case they simply tell victims that they are going to "flip" the money - whatever that means - and people are apparently sending them money in response. I was horrified to read one comment from a mother of 7 who said she had sent money meant for her electric bill to a different scammer, had lost it, and was hoping that the person operating the account she was commenting on was legitimate. He responded in the comments, apologizing for that other rogue, and assuring her that he was legitimate and that she should contact him ASAP to begin a "cash flip". Apparently these HYIP folks are thinking too much. [1] https://instagram.com/explore/tags/flipcash/ https://instagram.com/explore/tags/flipcash/ (For the record I reported many of these accounts to Instagram the other day, and as near as I can tell none of them have been deleted)
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoHaving looked at this, I presumed this is the start of a money laundering operation ... Maybe. It seems a quick way to get cash into a semi legit form. But it seems pretty dumb.
- downandout 12y agoNo, these appear to be just complete scams. No money ever goes back to the victim. They simply block the victims from contacting them on Instagram once the money is sent.
- plongeur 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rntm3yDAQuM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rntm3yDAQuM He'll flip ya! It's that simple ...
- plongeur 12y agoSchools need to teach elementary financial knowledge and concepts; so people learn why healthy scepticism is in order if somebody promises yields beyond inflation rate.