4 ms·
Even collecting it, without explicitly stating what you are going to do with it, should be punished and prohibited. If it can identify you, you should be clear
by mhuffman 12y ago
Even collecting it, without explicitly stating what you are going to do with it, should be punished and prohibited. If it can identify you, you should be clear what is to be done with it before you can make an informed decision to give it to someone.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoOn what basis?
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoBasic human rights?
- yummyfajitas 12y agoSo if I listen to a person speak and deduce that they are Marathi without telling them I plan to do so, I should be punished? Suppose lady has a conversation with me and deduces that I'm a man whore (happened to me a couple of weeks ago). Should she also be punished? Or is it merely the act of making deductions with math that should be punished and prohibited? So if I use intuition and heuristics it's fine, but if I mentally apply Bayes rule I should be punished?
- mhuffman 12y agoIf you are she can do millions of those in your head and use it for profit without telling the people that you are going to do so, and how, then yes. You and her should be punished.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoAccent detection is almost certainly thousands if not millions of calculations. So is white guy detection + overcharging for auto ride, let alone nice shoe detection plus upsell, emotion detection, or any of the thousands of things salespeople do every day.
- mhuffman 12y agoI think you misunderstand what I said -- not millions of calculations, millions of individualized data that uniquely identify a person, then use it without telling the person how. If people know you are using information to serve them a better ad, and agree to it, no problem -- if you have not made that clear, or use it for other purposes that they are not aware of, then it is a big problem and should be illegal.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoWhat about humans who recognize faces?
- yummyfajitas 12y agoIt's unlikely that anyone has millions of data points on any individual. Thousands at most (possible exception: high resolution images, kind of like what human eyes process every day). Rather, ordinary data from across millions of people is combined to deliver better ads. Again, not very different from what most sales people do.