13 ms·
I'm reminded of: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583696870704152576 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583696870704152576
by davidw 12y ago
I'm reminded of: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583696870704152576 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583696870704152576
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kang 12y agoPatio11 goes on a tweet storm here where he is wrong so many times. >"..Most advantages of Bitcoin which matter are captured by, and improved upon by, a LAMP app which simply holds account balances." The blockchain is a ledger fine. But mining & proof of-work are separate concepts from the ledger. Mining is not only digging gold for distribution but also checking that the money note you just received is 'not counterfeit' + 'unique'. > "Bitcoin is not a protocol in any meaningful sense of word.." Bitcoin isn't but blockchain is. It is an algorithm that enables value transfer over any medium of transmission. Similar to how morse code enabled data transfer where only signal was being transferred. Similarly, internet enabled information transfer where only data was being transferred. Blockchain is the 8th layer of the OSI model. >"..Bitcoin's disaster recovery plan is a) get a cabal of people together in IRC, b) shut down the entire payment network, c) sort things." Forget bitcoin. Its like looking at the internet and finding faults in hotmail as the first email service. > "A good portion of geek enthusiasm for Bitcoins comes from the fact that it is programmable money. But: Money is also programmable money." No. Forget money. Blockchain is the thing. Its like saying internet is all about email. Internet enables information transfer, now what is information-transfer in plain english? A letter. Hence messaging is the first natural application of internet. Blockchain enables value-transfer, what is that in plain english? Money.
- kang 12y agoDownvotes coz I call out patio11? explanation please?
- vinceguidry 12y agoNot so much the calling out as the tone, which is unwarranted for pretty much any discussion on HN.
- kang 12y agoPlease care to explain the tone. Is the word fuck banned on here? I wrote 'fuck bitcoin, blockchain is the thing' where I got just a little passionate and really meant 'forget bitcoin and see blockchain'. Even then, my comment wasn't rude in anyway.
- vinceguidry 12y agoWell, your comment starts off by calling him 'wrong'. That immediately sets a combative tone for the rest of the comment, which would have been perfectly reasonable otherwise. A lot of times if your tone is unintentionally off you'll get a few initial downvotes but other people will see your intentions and bring you up out of the grey, which is what happened here. You're continuing to get downvoted on other comments because they're contributing to a discussion nobody wants to see, the discussion about the discussion. It's best to just stick to the topic, and treat downvotes and the score in general as the ultimately meaningless internet points that they are. HN prizes the generally high signal-to-noise ratio of the comments. Also Bitcoin is a political topic, one that will draw lots of people who will downvote you just because they don't agree with you.
- vinceguidry 12y agoThis post seems to be getting more than usual upvotes for a comment deep in thread, and I can't edit it anymore, so let me add that I typically will consider deleting the first sentence of every email and comment I unleash on the world. It is often detritus that just doesn't belong there.
- anonbanker 12y agoRemember, kids: you will be downvoted for saying someone is wrong on HN.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoBitcoin is a topic that brings out a lot of irrational arguments and pejorative name calling ("boiler rooms", for example) in the HN community. There's some truly transformative tech at the core of Bitcoin, which is why it's been as successful as it has been (and will be) as a technology. On the other hand, there really is a contingent of supporters that primarily has a profit motive. I've come to see it like politics. People pick a side and then become extreme about it, to no one's real benefit. People are weird about money, in several directions at once. Bitcoin is money. Therefore people are weird about Bitcoin. That's my theory, anyway.
- moe 12y agoThat's my theory, anyway. Which the HN community helpfully confirms by downvoting your perfectly reasonable comment. I think Bitcoin tickles a rather deep-rooted fear in many people. Money is fundamental to everyone's existence and has always been exclusively issued and controlled by "the authority". Seeing a completely different system appear out of nowhere, and seeing it actually work (on a small scale), triggers a strong enough anxiety-reflex in enough people for every debate about Bitcoin to immediately derail into discussing BTC as if its definite purpose was to replace "real money", starting tomorrow, completely and entirely, and to devalue my pension fund in the process.
- vectorpush 12y agoUgh. This kind of arrogance is a significant contributing factor to the contentiousness of bitcoin discussion. Nobody is fearful of bitcoin, especially not with regard to the idea that bitcoin will somehow replace fiat money and "devalue my pension fund". It's intellectually insulting and it goads skeptics into sarcastic and unproductive debate. When enthusiastic bitcoin supporters parade around this kind of nonsense while simultaneously heaping on volumes of nebulous praise like "transformative", "revolutionary", "world-changing", likening bitcoin to the early internet, claiming it will stop wars, stop corruption, free the people and all the rest, it really puts up red flags for a lot of people.
- moe 12y ago
- geofft 12y agoHN pro tips: 1. Resist complaining about downvotes. It makes boring reading (and hence gets downvoted). This is literally one of the guidelines. 2. If you find yourself saying "Downvoted because I <position in an argument>, really?", the answer is always, no, downvoted because you expressed <position in an argument> in a non-constructive manner that nobody wanted to read. If you had expressed <opposite position> in the same way, you'd have been downvoted too. This might be that you were overly aggressive, this might be that you were insufficiently clear in making your point, this might be because both <position> and <opposite position> are dead horses, etc. But the answer is always no.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kang 12y ago"..they are pretty happy with a centralized system" And the centralised system is happy printing money calling inflation a necessary evil. If you understand blockchain and the current financial system you will realize then inflation is necessary to facilitate loans so that the economy can grow, but that loans are not required at all. So if I can't take a loan how do I raise the capital for a business? The IPO model. And blockchain is the programmed IPO model. There is a reason why people haven't figured out an algorithm to trustless-ly loan bitcoins. They never will.
- danbruc 12y agoSorry for the deleted comment, I just decided shortly after writing it that I don't really have the time today to argue on the internet. My comment stated that there is no value for user in all the decentralized verification process and just storing transactions in a trusted central database is good enough for most of them. Your response is more or less completely ignoring this and attacks the current financial system and what not, it does at no point explain why you can not centralize Bitcoin. What prevents doing the exact same thing as the Bitcoin network but with a central server for verification and storage instead of doing it in a distributed way?
- kang 12y agoNo. You got me wrong here. I totally agree that an end user has no value either way, but if the user chooses the centralized way, it gives someone the license to print money, wherein lies the problem.
- aboutus 12y agoI agree with you. Inflation is due to political maneuvers, and is not purely economical. In other words, without bad politicians, inflation wouldn't exist.
- patio11 12y agoMining and proof-of-work are not advantages of Bitcoin. They're strategies to distribute costs of its feature set. (Well, plus mining is Bitcoin's key marketing advantage -- it sets up incentive-compatible self-organizing distributed boiler rooms.) Being able to check that a ledger is accurate is a feature. It can be captured by a PHP app which uses MySQL transactions. This is, in fact, the most popular way to ensure ledger integrity even in the Bitcoin community (on exchanges, where transactions happen "off chain" because Bitcoin is wholly unsuitable for processing the type of transaction that mosts interests the Bitcoin community). The cost of verifying transactional integrity with MySQL transactions is, generally speaking, less than $900,000 per day, which is the present cost of verifying transactional integrity on the Bitcoin blockchain. I will respectfully decline to respond to the rest of your comment as it includes no statements which can be true or untrue about Bitcoin as a technical artifact.
- kang 12y agoThat is what I have trying to explain. Mining and proof-of-work are not just strategies but necessary requirement. Blockchain is not just ledger. I'll try to explain. The banks have a ledger of all the notes in circulation maintaining a record of the number printed on the note. Now when I give you a note, and its fake, you can figure it out by checking the unique factors. But lets say that my 3D printer is advnced and printed it so accurate that it is same as a real dollar. Now the way to catch this note would be to check if the number on this note also exists on some other note. So basically proof-of-work is you checking for unique factors(not counterfeit) and then somehow check all the notes in the world that none of them have the same number(unique). Both of these are in addition to the use of mining as a way of distribution of wealth. Could you just reply to why you don't consider the blockchain to be an algorithm? Also, I mostly meant that you are paying too much attention to what the media is throwing at us, in the form of bitcoin and exchanges. As a thinker, forget bitcoin and its code and just think about blockchain. Saying that blockchain enables value transfer and must be considered as the 8th layer of OSI model is technical artifact.
- patio11 12y agoCould you just reply to why you don't consider the blockchain to be an algorithm? I find this part of the conversation to be uninteresting, primarily because it attempts to make a distinction between "Bitcoin" and "the blockchain" (despite the fact that the Bitcoin consensus blockchain as annointed by the Bitcoin Core client at this moment in time is the only one of the infinite number of possible blockchains which is cared about) but can't make a distinction between "algorithm" and "protocol". This leaves me in a position where I say "Some people call IE6 a protocol. While one could rigorously examine the entire possible space of inputs and outputs associated with IE6 and attempt to describe some set-of-rules which would resemble a protocol, this is not what we mean when we say 'protocol' and it is, importantly, not the source of the benefits which IE6 fans say when they claim that IE6 is a protocol." To which "Why don't you think IE6 is an algorithm?" is rather non-responsive. (IE6 is, vacuously, an algorithm. Whee.) Saying that blockchain enables value transfer and must be considered as the 8th layer of OSI model is technical artifact. I find it difficult to extract any signal about the reality which I live in from this statement. When I say "technical artifact" I usually want to imply something about the reality I live in. For example, calc.exe is a technical artifact: it actually exists, on yonder computer, and I can right now walk over to it and calculate 6+5 with a reasonable degree of confidence that this will enlighten me. I would also say the HTTP specs are a technical artifact: I, or anybody with modest technical capability, can read the specs, open up telnet, fire it at www.google.com on port 80, and then type in a predictable series of letters which results in search results presented in the middle of a lot of HTML. I do not know of any comparable fashion in which "the blockchain" actually exists as distinct from "the data structure embedded in the much-more-complicated series of operations that is Bitcoin Core."
- jordigh 12y agoHey guys. We just have new rules. Avoid excessive negativity. There's a bit too many "fucks" in your post. Maybe you could edit your post to reduce the "fuck" count to 1 or 0?
- kang 12y agoReplaced 'fuck' with 'forget'. It was never used in any negative sense.
- swombat 12y agoYour post is weaker for it. The word "fuck" was appropriate to express what you wanted to express. The word "forget" is lame and forgettable. I'm sorry to see your post neutered by some kind of sudden appearance of a PC-police on HN, using the excuse of sama's post to try and restrict your way to express your ideas (which are not showing any of the kind of "gratuitous negativity" that sama talks about in his post). For shame.
- dang 12y agoThat's correct. Thanks for saying so. If there is any sincere misunderstanding it may be necessary to repeat this a few times, but hopefully it won't last.
- dang 12y agoI didn't see the original version of your comment, but it was probably fine. It's natural for there to be a few glitches while the community works out how to interpret what "gratuitous negativity" means in practice, but as a hint, we're mostly talking about being mean to others and/or being glibly dismissive of their work. We're definitely not talking about bowdlerizing conversation. We'd hate that as much as most HN users would.
- swombat 12y agoWhat do you mean "we have new rules"?? Where are those rules? Where the fuck can I see them? Who the fuck made them? Edit: Ok, I can see the link on the first page - hadn't seen the announcement. On the announcement: Where does it say anything about reducing the number of fucks in a post? It talks about gratuitous negativity. How does saying "Fuck bitcoin" or "Fuck money" involve gratuitous negativity? It's not directed at anyone. Seriously, if this place becomes some sort of Political Correctness bubble where swearing is discouraged in this way, that's an amazing distortion of the hacker spirit. Sam's article talks about not directing gratuitous negativity at people when you're arguing with them. That has very little correlation with your use of words like "fuck" or "shit". Seriously. The OP wanted to express a point about money and about bitcoin. It was best expressed with the word "fuck". The word "forget" doesn't get it across to me at all. That has nothing to do with the person he was responding to.
- seanwilson 12y agoI find Bitcoin fascinating so I'm not knocking it, but about this one: > "..Bitcoin's disaster recovery plan is a) get a cabal of people together in IRC, b) shut down the entire payment network, c) sort things." So say somebody finds a bug in the implementation that lets you do bad things like transfer everyone's balance to an attacker's account...what's the back up plan? Is there an equivalent with US dollars where such a thing could happen that has a back up plan? Putting myself in the shoes of Bitcoin's developers, I can't feel all but terrified that a simple buffer overflow or something similar could wipe out an entire currency. Or is there something I'm not understanding?
- mpyne 12y ago> Blockchain enables value-transfer, what is that in plain english? Money. A digitally-signed email enables value-transfer too. Depending on your risk profile you could even go for an authenticated TLS connection that just does a RESTful style POST to enable value-transfer. Value-transfer is not unique to a blockchain, or to Bitcoin's blockchain in particular, any more so than bubble sort is the only possible implementation of a sorting algorithm. CS majors know to avoid bubble sort because it is so inefficient, yet many refuse to apply the same lesson to POW-based systems like Bitcoin.
- geofft 12y ago> Bitcoin isn't but blockchain is. It is an algorithm An algorithm is not a protocol. A protocol is something that two people can independently implement and expect to be interoperable. Morse code is a protocol (in addition to an algorithm): you can read the Wikipedia article on Morse code, I can go to the library and read a book on Morse code, and we can reliably communicate. It is impossible to independently implement Bitcoin and reliably interoperate with the standard C++ implementation of Bitcoin at reliability levels sufficient for financial applications (as the 2013 BDB fork, between two versions of the standard C++ implementation, demonstrated). It might be possible to define a blockchain-based protocol that does not have this fault, precisely because blockchain is not a protocol, but is (as you say) an algorithm. To my knowledge, nobody has done so, and Bitcoin has certainly not done so. Why this is important is a different discussion. And yes, perhaps this will be fixed with the second generation of cryptocurrencies, past Bitcoin and its forks/variants, which you seem to favor doing to fix things. But I don't see why that makes patio11's claims wrong, since he was specifically addressing Bitcoin, not any blockchain-based system, or cryptocurrencies in general.
- kang 12y ago"It is impossible to independently implement Bitcoin..at reliability levels sufficient for financial applications" This is the real challenge to us crypto believers. Its hard but definitely not impossible(as demonstrated by the worth ofbitcoin today). Working on it.
- tptacek 12y agoWhat does the spot price of a Bitcoin have to do with the question of whether Bitcoin can feasibly and safely be standardized to a point where there are many interoperable implementations that don't share any heritage in code? Because that's the question you posed.
- kang 12y agoHe said it unreliable for financial transactions as demo'd by the fork. I said I agree but it is worth something even today as evident by the money people store in bitcoin already.
- reitzensteinm 12y agoBig fan of that tweetstorm, except for the Ross Perot bit. He received 19% of the popular vote - if that doesn't qualify as being a "serious contender" I'm not sure what does - short of winning. Afterwards, the democrats and republicans changed the debate rules to ensure they wouldn't be hit like that again, so they sure took it seriously. Perhaps he meant to say Nader?
- dexterdog 12y agoA serious contender who clearly altered the vote by being an option on the ballot.
- mahranch 12y ago> He received 19% of the popular vote That's not a significant number. 19% might seem like a lot, but he didn't pick up a single state. If he had, then he might have been a serious contender. A serious contender is someone who "has a serious chance of winning". Ross Perot never had a chance of winning, and thus, was never a serious contender. He got closer than most to being a serious contender, but still didn't cross that line. He was projected to lose by double digits by literally every pollster and odds maker.
- aboutus 12y agoBitcoin presents more opportunity and potential than anything I have seen since the arrival of the internet. It could be the biggest opportunity in our lifetime. There will be those who want an easy ride. They'll wait until the problems are solved and the infrastructure is in place. But for me, the exciting time is now, because the future is still being written. Let those who want to mock the efforts of others do so. The rest of us can roll up our sleeves and be builders of this new economy for the people.
- sanswork 12y agoHow did Apple mimic Bitcoin with Apple Pay?
- aboutus 12y agoAlthough I believe Apple Pay was inspired by Bitcoin, it wasn't core to my argument. So I dropped it.
- Mahn 12y agoI still don't understand how does Bitcoin present opportunity and potential when average consumers do not want it. It excels for things like buying drugs, so for that use case alone it will stay, but other than that, even with companies like Coinbase or Circle providing infrastructure to ease the process there's just no obvious advantage to consumers. It really seems like a solution in search of a problem.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 0xFEED 12y agoThere's a number of things in that which aren't totally correct. > No, seriously, the decentralized nobody-needs-to-trust-anybody payments network was shut down by an IRC channel's consensus* for 8 hrs.* It wasn't "shut down" in any sense of the word, the network kept working (in duplicate, no less). It was the decision of two pool owners with extraordinary hashrates to sacrifice their chain (which was actually the "correct" one as far as intentions go), rather than the core developers. Nobody has some magic key to shut down the network (though originally, Satoshi's alert key did enable a "safe mode", this is long gone) > Bitcoin is not a protocol in any meaningful sense of word. It is a single C++ codebase that you have to be bug-for-bug compatible with. That's the reality of distributed consensus. Matching it bug for bug is completely foolhardy (and many have failed at the task), you should be just linking in the consensus library which is currently being broken out of the bitcoin core source. > Most advantages of Bitcoin which matter are captured by, and improved upon by, a LAMP app which simply holds account balances. Except for the key one, that a LAMP setup running on a shared host isn't a distributed consensus. You could replace your car with a hamster wheel and it would still go round and round, but it's missing the core function of getting you to work. > Bitcoin presently costs on the order of $6.5k per megabyte of data added to the block chain. Which is why signatures are made with ECDSA, a very compact signature system compared with lamport or RSA. You don't want to be storing data in the block chain, and it's never been posited to be good for this (quite the opposite). > Time between Bitcoin blocks is not guaranteed (follows a Poisson distribution). Sometimes all pending transactions just stop for a while This isn't at all surprising, if they were regular then Bitcoin wouldn't be a functioning distributed consensus. You can get near instant, low trust "confirmations" by using a multisignature oracle which promises not to sign double spends. There's at least one company doing this at the moment, though it hasn't seen huge adoption.
- swombat 12y agoWould be interesting to see Patrick's answer to the above, particularly the first point... I pinged the tweetstorm to a friend of mine who's knowledgeable about Bitcoin and he seemed to feel Patrick was, erm, not particularly believable on this topic. For example, on the first point: this is akin to saying the bit torrent foundation closed down bit torrent! waah! it's impossible once they released the reference implementation, it was out of their hands this is the beauty of open sourced and decentralised technology, once it's out there it's difficult to control the analogy would be Linus going batshit mad and deciding to include binary blob drivers provided by the NSA in the kernel mainline, fine - nobody will use it, business continues as usual using a fork before that and he becomes irrelevant
- vvnraman 12y agoAt the risk of being reprimanded by the man himself, here is the tweet storm in text: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583696870704152576 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583696870704152576 1/I follow Bitcoin like some people follow Nascar crashes. Some quick thoughts in tweetstorm format: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697092306014208 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697092306014208 2/ It is an open secret in the Bitcoin community that merchants who adopt it see virtually no meaningful transaction volume. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697371378257920 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697371378257920 3/ Western Union spends roughly 1/2 of revenue on local offices by both ends of the transactions. Bitcoin remittances don't solve this. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697585719746560 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697585719746560 4/ Bitcoin presently costs on the order of $6.5k per megabyte of data added to the block chain. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697812438691841 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583697812438691841 5/ The entire market cap of Bitcoin as of 4/1/2015 is a fee paid to someone for work already done between 2009 and 4/1/2015. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583698553614143488 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583698553614143488 6/ Most advantages of Bitcoin which matter are captured by, and improved upon by, a LAMP app which simply holds account balances. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583699554563784704 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583699554563784704 7/ Bitcoin's Internet cheering squad is a spontaneously organized boiler room. This is Bitcoin's #1 engineering and marketing achievement. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583699782624911361 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583699782624911361 8/ The cheering squad improves upon techniques used to make Ross Perot and Rand Paul seem like serious contenders for the US presidency. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583700634764910592 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583700634764910592 9/ Bitcoin is not a protocol in any meaningful sense of word. It is a single C++ codebase that you have to be bug-for-bug compatible with. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583701008754147329 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583701008754147329 10/ Bitcoin's disaster recovery plan is a) get a cabal of people together in IRC, b) shut down the entire payment network, c) sort things. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583701441866371073 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583701441866371073 11/ No, seriously, the decentralized nobody-needs-to-trust-anybody payments network was shut down by an IRC channel's consensus for 8 hrs. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583702513469104128 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583702513469104128 12/ Time between Bitcoin blocks is not guaranteed (follows a Poisson distribution). Sometimes all pending transactions just stop for a while https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583702865098604544 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583702865098604544 13/ The media following Bitcoin, both enthusiast press and tech rags, are so incompetent at their jobs that it beggars belief. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583703396231716864 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583703396231716864 14/ One example of many: a single phone call or letter in Japanese would have sufficed to verify that Mt. Gox was insolvent in summer 2013. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583706966553276417 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583706966553276417 15/ A good portion of geek enthusiasm for Bitcoins comes from the fact that it is programmable money. But: Money is also programmable money. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583707625210060800 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583707625210060800 16/ This concludes my mini-rant on Bitcoin. I have a longer, more technical rant but will do it some other time. It would have been good to put a disclaimer in there that the rant applies only to the currency aspect of Bitcoin, and not the Bitcoin Protocol.
- placeybordeaux 12y ago> A good portion of geek enthusiasm for Bitcoins comes from the fact that it is programmable money. But: Money is also programmable money. I don't quite get this one. How is money also programmable money? Does he mean USD, USD as claimed by paypal, USD as claimed by venmo? One of the reasons I am excited about bitcoin is that for the first time there is decent infastructure for machine to machine payments that can withstand any one buisness failing.
- mpyne 12y ago> How is money also programmable money? Does he mean USD, USD as claimed by paypal, USD as claimed by venmo? Yes to all of those. Computers have been absolutely intertwined with finance and money for decades, so much so that it's become almost invisible to people. But just because it's so invisible you don't notice it doesn't mean that major economies haven't already been using "programmable money". > machine to machine payments that can withstand any one buisness failing. Business fail all the time, including business involved in payment processing with existing national currencies. That hasn't stopped machine-to-machine payments. On the other hand Bitcoin has suffered payment stops in its history, which Patrick mentions in the linked tweetstorm.
- adrianmacneil 12y agoI'm reminded of: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=532.msg6306#msg6306 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=532.msg6306#msg6306 > If you don't believe me or don't get it, I don't have time to try to convince you, sorry. - Satoshi Nakamoto Either way, this post is about the Bitcoin foundation, not whether bitcoin itself has merit. I feel that this discussion has turned more into a technical tit for tat of bitcoin.