6 ms·
Obama signs executive order allowing government to seize hackers assets
- other_herbert 12y agoJust wow....
- FrankenPC 12y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- MCRed 12y agoAsset forfeiture is one of the most heinous violations of people's rights that has come out of the drug war. One of the effects of this is that it denies the accused the ability to defend themselves by making them immediately destitute and thus unable to afford good legal advice... which results in them being more likely to take bad plea deals etc. Worse, it is corrosive-- many police departments seize millions of dollars a year which they then use on toys for themselves. Thus it provides a financial incentive for corruption, and denies due process. Part of the corruption this creates is that if one tried to undo this law, those who abuse it have millions to spend on propaganda claiming that it would "Deny understaffed police agencies from millions they desperately need". Not to mention, executive orders bypass the legislative process and I am not aware of any authorization for them in the constitution.
- imroot 12y agoYou're also missing another part -- because they're destitute, they can't make bail, so they're more likely to take a horrible plea deal just so that they can get out of jail.
- shit_parade 12y agoAnd if anyone helps out those accused they will also suffer the same.
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoThere's a US code that requires national emergencies declared in an executive order to specify where in US code authorizes him to do so. According to the executive order, this law authorizes him to take unilateral action in certain circumstances: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1701 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1701 He seems to also be invoking a US code that allows certain conditions of a declared national emergency to override a legislative two-year sunset? https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1601 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1601 I am guessing that's why he cites it, so his executive order won't sunset. IANAL, I just read the executive order.
- em3rgent0rdr 12y ago"We're in a perpetual state of emergency" is the convenient excuse of the rulers.
- j42 12y agoTo anyone who thinks this could be hyperbolic; every single statement here is verifiable, from asset-forfeiture being applied overwhelmingly to people who are never convicted of a crime, to the police themselves admitting that seized funds are subject to NO regulation and are routinely used for "nice-to-haves" such as Margharita Machines, office parties, and other institutional costs. I'm all for capitalism, but it has created a vicious positive-feedback loop here that if unchecked, means this will NEVER change. 1) Ex-LE create "training" subsidiary programs like Black Asphalt and Desert Snow succeed because, they teach the "police" how to operate "efficiently" and increase their financial "earnings." This is perpetuated by the rationalization of many police that they are "underfunded," "constrained" and thereby justified in the name of "protecting the public." 2) LE adopting these programs see an exponential rise in intake, and news spreads. These training programs become the new "ideal," and earn large sums in the process for the "training" they provide--an increased incentive to keep developing them. 3) Somewhere in this process the police 'mentality' shifts from "how do I uphold the law and protect the freedoms it affords" to, "how do I get mine, while not majorly stepping outside the bounds of the law." In many ways it's ironically American, and yet, it's also very much an automatic symptom of this feedback loop where priorities are shifted in pursuit of personal gain and rationalizations are made that create a dangerous disconnect between a true "agent of the law" and a predatory individual with knowledge of said law who is inherently looking for ways to use that knowledge to take advantage of you. Frankly, I think we're all self-interested in some way and make many rationalizations in the pursuit. The point of legislation is to allow that in a healthy context, while preventing those rationalizations from substantially harming the culture and society. If we want to see any change here, I think designing intelligent disincentives is the only path that will produce a lasting effect. "Punishment" as deterrence isn't enough. Additional "civil liberty" stipulations aren't either, as we learned with the tax code--more complexity just makes more holes to be exploited. How do we curtail the ability for these programs to remain economically viable? Remove the incentive, and only then, perhaps the psychology will change.
- motbob 12y agoNothing can override a constitutional right to due process. That's what it means for the Constitution to be the "supreme law of the land."
- masterleep 12y agoSince we don't follow the Constitution 95% of the time anyway, who cares about another violation?
- GabrielF00 12y agoPlease provide a source for this completely hyperbolic statement.
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoThe constitution only applies to American citizens and to a lesser extent others living physically within the US and its territories. There is a bunch of material on this topic (both on illegals in the US and US territories) but as a start: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insular_Cases http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insular_Cases http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downes_v._Bidwell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downes_v._Bidwell Essentially even if you're in a US territory the US constitution only barely applies, and it doesn't apply at all to everyone not in either a US state or its territories.
- bdcravens 12y agoThe issue is that this EO can directly affect citizens (if you transact with a cyber-criminal, you're at risk of seizure)
- imroot 12y agoIf you think that this won't be abused, you're foolish. Paul Timmins gave a speech at NotACon in 2008 (or maybe 2009) about his experiences with getting arrested for the Lowe's breach in 2005. In the agents vigor to seize equipment for a search warrant, they tried taking his cable TV boxes, amongst everything else with a cord. It's my fear that if anything ever happens and they come beating down my door for any reason -- right or wrong -- and see my desk with three computers and four monitors on it, that they'll find a way to think that I'm "hacking" and then I'll be screwed -- no way to work equals no money for a criminal defense (and no money to make bail and leave jail) in most cases. The seizure laws need to be reduced, not expanded...
- paulhauggis 12y ago...so when will the US media admit that the current administration isn't enacting laws that are in the best interest of the US citizens?
- notdonspaulding 12y agoRelatedly, when will people realize that the executive branch should not be enacting laws at all?
- tsotha 12y agoAs soon as a Republican is elected. The media will remember that Constitution thingee then.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoWith all the recent progress on asset forfeiture, this seems like a huge leap backwards. Essentially any foreigner can be accused of a crime, have their assets within US institutions stolen, and then has to prove they're innocent to get them returned (assuming they can). Plus "cyber attacks" is such a broad brush. One that has been used against people who access unsecured URLs which aren't meant to be known (essentially security through obscurity). It may also make security research abroad against US-based organisations impossible. Most of the bug bounty programs are now extremely high risk.
- anigbrowl 12y agoAre there bug bounty programs for critical national infrastructure components?
- pmorici 12y agoI was watching a Revolutionary War area TV series the other night and one of the plot lines involves the British loyalists issuing Bills of attainder against suspected patriots effectively stealing all their property. It was one of the things that Americans were really ticked off about in those times, so much so that bills of attainder were banned when the constitution was written. How is this asset forfeiture w/o due process any different than a bill of attainder except for the fact that it takes place in the executive branch. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_of_attainder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_of_attainder
- anigbrowl 12y agoA bill of attainder is a legislative act targeted against a particular individual, eg 'Now be it decided that pmorici's property is forfeit by this act, which shall be known as the 'Mess with Pmorici Act'. This executive order details particular behaviors computer attacks on critical national infrastructure from outside the US - that would get someone put on the OFAC list maintained by the treasury. C'mon man, I just checked the Wikipedia link and it says the exact same thing in the very first sentence. I get the impression that you linked it without actually having read it, instead relying on the impression you formed from watching the TV show. Don't try to figure out the law (or much of anything else) from a TV show. As a screenwriter myself I assure you that anything designed to go on a screen is dumbed down to the point of being wildly inaccurate. We write to engage your emotions, not your intellect.
- pmorici 12y agoI'm aware of what it is. I'm pointing out that, despite procedural differences, the effect, curtailment of due process, is the same.
- shit_parade 12y agoWhat does it matter? Justice died some time ago in the US. Be good little citizens and don't dare challenge nor question those in power. Be sure to refuse any wealth not given to you by the government or risk having everything taken because they came from someone deemed unfriendly to the status quo. Instead be extra safe and only work for the government then you can fear no punishment.
- remarkEon 12y agoFrom the medium post[0] by POTUS: "These sanctions are meant to protect our national security, personal privacy and civil liberties. As such, sanctions will in no way target the unwitting victims of cyberattacks, like people whose computers are hijacked by botnets. Nor does this executive order target the legitimate cybersecurity research community or professionals who help companies improve their cybersecurity. And unlike some other countries, we will never try to silence free expression online or curb Internet freedom." (emphasis added) How will they know? Doesn't just the existence of an executive order like this curb internet freedom, even if they aren't explicitly trying to do so? [0] https://medium.com/@PresidentObama/a-new-tool-against-cyber-threats-1a30c188bc4 https://medium.com/@PresidentObama/a-new-tool-against-cyber-...
- j42 12y agoLegitimate question, because I don't see any reality in which overzealous DA's will not abuse this to exert pressure without due process. I pay my taxes. I am a law abiding citizen. If I want to store the majority of my assets outside of this country (in a fiat currency), preferably in a location that doesn't automatically cave to US economic pressure and/or with limited diplomatic channels, what are my options? Hypothetically, what would give you semi-reasonable freedom to transfer and spend that money, while still keeping it insulated from a government that wantonly steals from its citizens without discretion? ----- I always used to think in the "worst case" scenario the EFF would be the safe-haven of reason, able to exert equal and opposite pressure to any intimidation tactics, but I think that balance has forever shifted. I no longer feel safe or represented within this country, and while I still value my citizenship (a debate for another time), I think we all must recognize that personal insurances and safeguards are now requisite when dealing with the federal government. I'd rather be prepared.
- pmorici 12y ago"Hypothetically, what would give you semi-reasonable freedom to transfer and spend that money, while still keeping it insulated from a government that wantonly steals from its citizens without discretion?" Bitcoin.
- j42 12y ago> Fiat I love bitcoin. I'm a proponent, and a casual developer of related services. But there's no way I'd use it to store sizable assets, which should be obvious--volatility (particularly related to large sell orders) and the current state of exchanges, to say two? I'm also as optimistic as anyone, but the reality is simply that it's more likely bitcoin will devalue before established governments and the IMF, despite their MANY glaring problems. It's just not feasible as a primary means of asset storage or point-of-sale currency yet.
- delbel 12y agoPerth mint certificates is one option I can think of. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perth_Mint_Certificate_Program http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perth_Mint_Certificate_Progra...
- emptybits 12y agoYou do not even need to be accused of a cyber crime to have assets seized under this order. If you make any contribution to or provide any services to someone accused of criminal hacking, you may have assets seized. Aside from innocent individuals falling victim to unjust asset forfeiture, it seems to me that organizations like GitHub, Amazon, or Dropbox are exposed if they end up providing services to the accused.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- youngButEager 12y agoPeople need to accept and be willing to act on the fact that words on a piece of paper -- even if it's the U.S. Constitution -- mean nothing unless citizens are willing to stand up and insist they be followed. The challenge we all face is that we're too cowardly, generally, to stand up to tyrannical acts like this. The Patriot Act; mass spying on all U.S. citizens by the NSA and others; our military and taxes being wasted overseas in armed conflicts most of us would never agree to. Many complain. And do nothing. So, the words in the Constitution are selectively ignored. "We the People" are afraid to insist that document be adhered to. Stealing citizens' possessions, as this president just empowered, despite "presumed innocent", is just another failure on our leadership's part to enforce the Constitution. The only way to stop this kind of stuff is to insist these overreaches are set aside. Many of us have bookmarked the websites of the Washington D.C. offices of our 2 senators (there are 2 senators per state) and Congressmen. When something like this goes down we can quickly get the phone number/email addresses from the bookmarked pages of our Reps and call them, email them. Do that as a habit, it's easy, and you've let it be known that the government isn't allowed these arbitrary violations of our rights. Senator Feinstein: http://www.feinstein.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/washington-dc http://www.feinstein.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/washington-... Senator Boxer: http://www.boxer.senate.gov/contact/offices/ http://www.boxer.senate.gov/contact/offices/
- maratd 12y ago> Do that as a habit, it's easy, and you've let it be known that the government isn't allowed these arbitrary violations of our rights. You're kidding, right? The only thing that will happen if you send them an email or call, is that you'll get on their list and then they'll SPAM the shit out of you when it comes time for re-election. Consider yourself lucky if there's an unsubscribe link. > The challenge we all face is that we're too cowardly, generally, to stand up to tyrannical acts like this. This has nothing to do with cowardice. The options for voicing our displeasure are quite limited and the few options there are happen to be ineffectual. Sending them email, calling, protesting, etc. isn't going to do squat. The only way to get them to behave is to make it look like a scandal. They don't like scandals. Scandals put their careers at risk. E-Mail the New York Times instead. If the story starts playing in a negative light on every media outlet and doesn't die down after a few days, they'll start to get nervous and sweat a little.
- olefoo 12y agoOn a related note Ian Griggs just posted an excellent blog post ( http://financialcryptography.com/mt/archives/001554.html http://financialcryptography.com/mt/archives/001554.html ) about the corruption inherent in allowing agencies to seize funds for their own use. It's written mostly in the context of anti-money-laundering regulations and focuses on the Silk Road investigators who ripped off hundreds of criminals and extorted the subjects of their investigation. It points out that anytime a law enforcement agency is allowed to seize funds that flow to it's own budget, corruption inevitably follows.
- tsotha 12y ago... and allows the government to decide who qualifies as a "hacker". Don't see any due process problems here. Nope.
- tsotha 12y agoI used to play a lot of relatively high-stakes poker. Some of the people I played against had a fair amount of cash (tens of thousands) on them on any given Friday or Saturday. It was pretty well known if you got robbed it would most likely be the cops who rob you. So this isn't a new thing, it's just a little growth of an exceedingly poisonous tree.
- venomsnake 12y agoI may be breaking HN guidelines but I do want to express my Gratuitous Negativity towards that order. Too broad, too vague and gives way too much discretion to parts of the USG that are already known for abuse of power ...
- nickysielicki 12y agoObama's presidency makes me feel so swindled. I voted for this man. I debated friends and did my best to persuade them to do the same. I genuinely believed in his 'Change I can Believe In' shit. I trusted that he was an honest politician who believed what he said. Not as much as Paul (my primary vote went to him), but at election time I knew that he had no chance and I felt that Obama was at least better than Romney. I'm not so sure that's honestly even true. I feel as if the interests of young people are systemically downplayed as presidents are generally 50+ years old. I genuinely believe Obama is a good guy. I actually think George W. is also a good guy at his core as well. I just think they're incapable of truly understanding what the internet is about because they're not digital natives like we are. So they push these laws, and they push mass surveillance, because they fear what they do not understand. The unfortunate thing is that it looks like the internet of my childhood and adolescence will be dead by the time any digital native could have found herself in office. Gone are the days of the wild wild west. The average 12 year old online spends his time on a locked-down tablet watching youtube poops, watching YouTube channels with professional production, and interacts with his friends on Facebook. Its not necessary to learn about the computer to use the computer, and its not necessary to explore the internet to consume the internet. Its just profoundly sad. I might be pessimistic here but as someone who had their own computer in their room since I was six, (thanks to my father who was an EE) I know that the wild internet shaped the core of who I am; I feel persecuted by the masses of people who aren't curious enough about the computer systems they rely on.
- halite 12y agoGood points but I think internet as we know it now will evolve over time. Spaniards leaving Twitter for GNU social was interesting article, emphasizes the shortcomings of centralized services. I truly believe in future things would not be like today and maybe not easy to block as they are today.
- nickysielicki 12y agoSomething that I'm a big proponent of is that its likely impossible to persuade the masses to move to something new if it doesn't provide a large advantage for them. We need a social network that improves on Facebook and Twitter, not just in terms of preventing censorship, but in UX and performance and what it provides to boring Average Joe. It also cannot have any disadvantage. Forgive my lack of imagination here but I don't know if that's actually going to be possible. How can we create a distributed platform that Average Joe can use? Facebook requires only an email address, and all his friends are already on it. It's not impossible, but it is difficult, and I just don't see it happening.
- GabrielF00 12y agoI've now received "your personal information has been breached, here's some free credit monitoring" letters three times. Once from a major health insurer, once from a major retailer, and once from a large regional hospital. I've also been a member of several large websites that have had their systems breached. Given the sheer number of breaches, and the variety of organizations that have been breached, I suspect that most Americans have had their information compromised by hackers at least once. We're also regularly seeing breaches of major companies for the purposes of economic espionage, and disruption of service as a political or economic tactic. We regularly hear about breaches of government systems, including sensitive systems. Given that very sophisticated companies and government agencies are regularly suffering from breaches, I think we have to conclude that we are really struggling to build systems that provide adequate protection for our personal data. All of the comments in this thread have addressed the risks of government overreach, but none of them have looked at the costs of these breaches. At what point do we conclude that our technological tools are inadequate, and we also need additional legal tools to deter potential hackers who are overseas and out of reach of the US legal system?
- c22 12y agoSomewhat agreed, but couldn't our legal tools instead/also be focused on the organizations that take responsibility for storing our data? Fines for allowing user data to be breached may stimulate development of tools and methodologies better able to protect private data and rules that limit sharing of user data can protect us from even the well-financed malevolent actors. Focusing on this side of the coin may allow us to realize systems that actually do protect our data from being compromised as opposed to spending our resources tracking down individuals and attempting to apply legal tools which the most successful criminals will soon adapt to evade anyway.
- GabrielF00 12y agoI think the problem with this thinking is that even without explicit fines, the costs of a data breach are already incredibly high for companies. There's the potential loss of sales for a customer-facing business, as well as costs of class action lawsuits, system cleanup, etc. Sony Pictures was crippled by a cyberattack. Target's CEO was forced to resign. So, maybe fines would make this situation better, but CEO's should already be up at night worrying about cybersecurity. My inclination would be to pursue better security, but also to go after the really sophisticated cybercriminals that are currently outside the reach of our legal system.
- legutierr 12y agoI think that people participating in this thread might have a substantial misunderstanding of this executive order. This does not seem to create a policy whereby law enforcement can arbitrarily seize property owned by accused hackers. Asset forfeiture as a drug war tool is extremely problematic, and deserving of debate, but this is not that. Instead, this allows "the Secretary of the Treasury, in consultation with the Attorney General and the Secretary of State" to add a list of foreign hackers "located, in whole or in substantial part, outside the United States" to the "Specially Designated Nationals" list that Treasury maintains (at the Office of Foreign Asset Control). All US businesses, but especially financial institutions, who have an affirmative requirement to know their customers, have an obligation to not do business with entities listed on the SDN list. I am not a lawyer, but I have in the past written software intended to detect transactions by people on the SDN list. It is of finite length, it is publicly available for review, and individuals and businesses can only be added to it if an explicit decision is made at the cabinet level (as per my recollection). In general, I would think that HN would see this executive order as a good thing, because it will create a tool for the US to penalize criminal hackers that otherwise would be hiding in Russia, Iran or China. It is profoundly unlikely that these powers would be directed at any US persons, unless they were found to be dealing directly with the people enumerated on this public list.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThe source article absolutely reeks of editorial bias, and does a very poor job of explaining the order itself, though at least it links to it. As you say, it's actually very narrowly tailored, and basically just grandfathers in cyberattacks against critical infrastructure as a type of terroristic activity.
- enupten 12y agoWould they hold property in the US if they weren't US citizens ? I mean, what's the point ? Can this be used against the Chinese defence manufacturers, who are rumoured to have benefitted from the attacks on Lockheed-Martin ?
- anigbrowl 12y ago
- enupten 12y agoMan, what's with Obama ? He vetoes the insignificant Keystone, but allows Arctic drilling (competing with Russia now, are we ?). Now this ? (Okay the Iran deal is promising).
- dataker 12y agoIn high school, some teachers called security for 'suspecting me to be hacking'. I had just started programming and, because of a terminal(black background and green font), they seized my laptop and gave it to their analyst. Back in the day, I had no idea what my rights were, but I remember to feel violated and insecure. As a programmer, I fear ignorant law enforcers will actually undermine the hacking community, which elementary has nothing to do with crime.
- mubhij 12y agoThis needs to be a meme!
- feld 12y agoSo what is the definition of "hacker"?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- larrymcp 12y ago* hackers' assets
- tux 12y agoCan same law be used against "security researchers" or anyone running "security related" website ?
- Potando 12y agoSounds like if you pay Cryptolocker to recover your files then you can have you money frozen too. Perhaps this is a good incentive to stop people paying extortionists.
- DigitalSea 12y agoWhat constitutes a hacker? Has the US government learned nothing of what happened to Andrew "Weev" Auernheimer what he did landed him jail time and under this executive order he would have been considered a hacker and had all of his assets seized. We all remember what tragically happened to Aaron Swartz when he took his life due to excessive overreach from the Government after he took those PACER documents and made them freely available for everyone. I am seriously shocked, not surprised, but legitimately shocked what Obama has been doing of late in regards to cyber crime and so called hackers.
- tptacek 12y agoThe authority the President is exercising here was provided to him by Congress, in 50 U.S.C. 1702, and pertains specifically and exclusively to foreign transactions --- not because the Executive Order says so, but because the law it's based on does.
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoI don't get the extrajudicial stuff. Why not go to court, have someone found guilty, then put them on a list (e.g. for assets to be frozen)? If the evidence is so clear that the cabinet or white house or gov can add someone to a list, why can this not be done by an independent judge? Why the political aspect?
- stephenboyd 12y agoI'm not usually the pedantic type, but I think the Hacker (as in clever tinkerer) News front page is a bad place for headlines using the word hackers as 'computer criminals'.
- elmar 12y agoUS Presidential Order Allows the State to Confiscate Crypto Holdings ‘Without Prior Notice’ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9309612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9309612 “Now the USA can simply confiscate all crypto without any need for time consuming paperwork. This I believe puts USA in the lead (by a big margin) over China and Russia as far as dictatorial level usurpation of financial rights,”
- dang 12y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9310006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9310006