5 ms·
You know, if you see a bullshit opinion or statement, there are ways of refuting it that don't need the level of aggression you are showing here. Here's an exa
by chris_wot 12y ago
You know, if you see a bullshit opinion or statement, there are ways of refuting it that don't need the level of aggression you are showing here.
Here's an example: homeopathy. If someone believes in it, then you can give counter statements without calling them an idiot. You can explain that you believe it's without basis through reasoned argument, and you absolutely should show respect for the other person. You don't even have to respect their opinion - heck I have zero respect for homeopathy - but that other person might have reasons for their stance.
At the end of the day, Hacker News works because it allows the free flow of ideas through discussion. HN knows that being wrong and failing are important to innovation because there are so many things that are non-intuitive that you need to give people space to think and act outside the box.
To allow for innovation needs robust discussion where you freely share your wild and unorthodox thoughts in a safe environment. A safe environment is one where you invite criticism and allow others to point out the flaws of your ideas, but you do so in the knowledge that they are doing it out of respect to try to help you improve your theories, plans or projects - not to treat you like a complete idiot not worthy of any respect. On the other side of the coin, you should be able to freely and constructively criticise without fear that you will be penalised by the community and that your criticism is given to help the other party limit their failure, or think of ways of improving their idea by ironing out flaws.
In essence, when you call another person an idiot, or treat them as such, you break the very model that makes HN successful. So with the greatest of respect, if you can't get your point or view across without denigrating the other party, I don't think HN was or ever will be the forum for you.
- mreiland 12y agoAnd yet, some would probably argue that refusing to engage at all shows a certain amount of respect for a person's right to have an opinion. The issue is one of using a word that can be applied to both sides of the argument. I was quite clear from the very beginning. This is about me not wasting time on people. It has nothing to do with respect or disrespect. Take ZenoArrow, for example. Why have I chosen to completely ignore him whilst seemingly engaging with others in this thread? Is it because he's been extra mean compared to everyone else? Because it isn't enough to simply disagree. In ZenoArrow's case it's the arrogance of his thinking he can manipulate me into whatever direction he wants to go. Why in the world would you bother engaging someone who is smarter than you are? It's a waste of time for all parties involved. > To allow for innovation needs robust discussion where you freely share your wild and unorthodox thoughts in a safe environment. You say this in a response to a subcomment of a flagged comment that attacked no person, nor idea. It simply stated that I dismiss people readily, and will continue to do so. Is that the sort of safe place for wild and unorthodox ideas, or is it only the wild and unorthodox ideas that everyone else has that's acceptable?
- ZenoArrow 12y ago"In ZenoArrow's case it's the arrogance of his thinking he can manipulate me into whatever direction he wants to go." We clearly disagreed, I'll not deny that, but the arrogance and manipulation you're referring to was an invitation to comment on something I believe is fundamental. I didn't tell you whether you had to agree, but instead was looking for the point at which our opinions diverged. I can't make you agree with me, nor would I necessarily want to, a world where we all thought the same would be lesser for it, instead I'd prefer to find out about the thoughts guiding our differences. Perhaps the problem was that I wasn't angry, that you needed conflict in order to bring out what you could've said. I can't be sure that it's true for you, but in my experience some people are fuelled by that sort of drama. It's not necessarily a bad thing, it's just not what I personally want.
- throwawaymaroon 12y agoYou just keep talking at him. You don't seem to understand that he's winning. Everything you're saying just slides off him. He's stated his position and believes it's confirmed by how he's been downvoted and flagkilled. For what it's worth, I think he's right, I think that whatever you think of his comment, the reception was disproportionate; but that doesn't matter now: he's gone. And you jabber on and on. You find his other comments so you can make him read more, desperate for another chance. You can't walk away. You hate to lose. I bet you want to respond with some gimmick about how you're concerned about him. Stop lying to yourself: he left the conversation with you, and you're alone talking to yourself. This is about you now. (Well, and me. But I'm trying to teach you something about how your constant search for a middle ground is in reality pretty condescending.)
- ZenoArrow 12y ago"But I'm trying to teach you something about how your constant search for a middle ground is in reality pretty condescending." Good. So why is it condescending? What do you find offensive about being reasonable with those you disagree with?
- tomjen3 12y ago>To allow for innovation needs robust discussion where you freely share your wild and unorthodox thoughts in a safe environment That may be useful, but that isn't HN. If your comment is positive about Javascript (which is actually a good language once you get to know it) or SPAs that comment is very likely to be downvoted. If you even find a place that actually allows discussion of unortodoc views, please tell me.
- chris_wot 12y agoI think that's the goal of this new guideline.
- eropple 12y agoSpeaking just for me: I've never downvoted somebody for liking JavaScript or approving of SPAs, though I disagree with the first and cringe at the second. But I've downvoted you enough to recognize your username because a ton of your posts sound like you're looking for a fight. Your behavior is regularly (and elsewhere in this thread, even) toxic and aggressively misrepresentative of people who don't agree with you. Maybe you should consider if the signals being sent your way mean what you think they mean.