3 ms·
It's "the programmers way" to try to come up with some sort of moderation/policing system to solve this. Please do not come up with a moderation system. There
by andrewstuart 12y ago
It's "the programmers way" to try to come up with some sort of moderation/policing system to solve this. Please do not come up with a moderation system.
There should simply be a confirmation step after hitting submit, reminding the poster that they are valued for their positive contribution and giving the poster the chance to rethink their post and cancel if its too negative. Additionally when posting, require people to self-rate the level of negativity of their post when they submit from one to ten. Publish that number along with the post.
There's nothing at the moment that explicitly asks or reminds people of expectations when they post. What is it that makes you think posters know there is an expectation not to be negative? People don't read the community guidelines every time they post, UNLESS key points of the guidelines are presented to them.
The community moderation system, what it ends up being, will be gamed and abused and alienate and anger people. Don't do it. Witness the toxic mess of StackOverflow.
HN is not in a position right now to express concern about negative posts because it is not explicitly asking people to avoid negative posting, at the time that they post, and requiring the user to think about it. That is step one.
HN would be implementing a passive-aggressive solution by going to an indirect system that continues to allow people to post negatively and then gets the community to police it later. Address it up-front, at the time of posting. Let people be responsible for their own posts. Asked to think it through, posters will dial back the negativity.
- DanBC 12y ago> There's nothing at the moment that explicitly asks or reminds people of expectations when they post. New users are asked to read the guidelines when they post. I don't know how long that reminder stays there, but there's a linkto the guidelines right under the text entry box.
- andrewstuart 12y agoSome background document doesn't address the users present behaviour. If there is some critical behaviour you want reinforced then you can't hand wave vaguely at some background document. You need to drive people through a process that requires them to confirm that are behaving in the expected way. "How negative is this post?" 0: not negative 10: it's snarky
- Gatsky 12y agoThanks for this, it's a good idea getting people to rate how negative their comments are... it would certainly be an interesting exercise, although it may just show that those who leave negative comments don't think they are being negative, whereas the people that can be bothered rating the negativity of others are probably more sensitive to negativity.
- andrewstuart 12y agoSelf-rating the negativity of your comment is designed to force you to acknowledge that HN wants you to think and be reasonable. The OP's blog post suggests that "Gentle reminders by peers" will make the culture better. I think these gentle reminders by peers in practice will whip everyone into a frenzy of hunting for negativity, naming negativity, blaming for negativity, being defensive about negativity, judging and feeling judged, anger, outrage and despair with constant accusations and counter accusations about the definition of negativity. Some negativity is normal and natural and okay. HN wants less of it, so they should just ask people to make their own self assessment of their post at the moment of posting. Problem mostly solved, but it's pointless to try to completely solve it - the concept of negativity is open to interpretation and therefore everyone will have a different opinion. I think plenty of people will tone it back after being forced to judge their own negativity.
- kordless 12y agoNegativity is only bad if it's used to speak for other's feelings. You actually don't know if it will whip everyone into a frenzy. :)
- andrewstuart 12y agoReading through this thread shows quite a few people in a frenzy about negativity.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoThe community moderation system, what it ends up being, will be gamed and abused and alienate and anger people. Don't do it. Witness the toxic mess of StackOverflow. It seems like the reason HN will come up with a new moderation system is because dang isn't going to stay moderator for the rest of his life. I sometimes feel bad HN has claimed so much of his time. It must be at least slightly depressing to constantly deal with the worst parts of HN. We should send him a thank-you card or a cake or something. There are other candidates for moderator, of course, but would they be as thoughtful? As careful? Will they have the presence of mind to avoid hellbanning people if it would make the HN mod team appear in a bad light, as in this very comment section? (The squabble near the top of this post was HN at its worst, but dang probably couldn't ban anyone involved without giving the wrong impression.) One thing's for sure: A community moderation system definitely won't. But a community moderation system might be a better alternative to a careless moderator, since at least the poor decisions can be appealed. But that would probably be the first time in the history of the internet that something like that worked. So hopefully it will work. If not, I imagine the HN team will do what they've always done: undo the bad decision and think of something else. They're nothing if not persistent and creative.