5 ms·
> But where are all the successful large scale projects built with Haskell (or Clojure or whatever)? How about Erlang. Let's try it, just from the top of my he
by rdtsc 12y ago
> But where are all the successful large scale projects built with Haskell (or Clojure or whatever)?
How about Erlang. Let's try it, just from the top of my head:
* AXD 301 Switch -- Classic. Powers and control phone switch networks of whole countries. Claims 99.9999999% reliability.
* Basho Riak -- popular NoSQL database, highly scalable nodes are peers
* RabbitMQ -- popular message queue used by enterprises
* WhatsApp -- messaging application, processes billions of messages a day. Built and maintained by only a few engineers. Sold for billions of dollars.
* Klarna -- European payment processing
* Bet365 -- Sports bets
* Stock trading -- Allegedly Goldman Sachs uses it.
* Erlyvideo.org -- Video streaming service
* eNodeB -- Ericsson cell to internet gateway. There is a 50% if you want to look at cat pictures from your smartphone and Erlang breaks, you won't see your cat pictures.
* Wings3D -- A subdivision 3D modeler. I guess you can build your 3D cat and then send it over WhatsApp via a eNodeB to your friend.
Those are just I know of. So there you go. Maybe you should learn Erlang ;-)
- nilkn 12y agoThrow IRCCloud into that list, my go-to IRC client that I've been using for nearly two years.
- wyclif 12y agoYou don't like irssi?
- nilkn 12y agoThere is what I like to call The IRC Problem, which is that it takes a bit of work to really make IRC into an awesome, persistent chat environment. First, you need to be persistently connected so that you don't miss messages when you're not actually at your computer. Second, you need a decent interface to use when you are actively reading or chatting. Third, it would be great to have the same across all devices (phone, tablet, laptop/desktop), with everything syncing correctly. If you read some scrollback on your phone, you want your laptop to also know that you already read those messages, and vice versa. It's certainly possible to achieve all this with irssi and a combination of other techniques. However, you can also use something like IRCCloud and get every problem solved at a very high level of competence immediately, plus a bunch of other stuff (like push notifications and embedded social media, images, videos, tweets, pastebins, etc.). It's up to you. For me, I really just want everything to work and I don't care at all about doing it myself. It's a means to an end. The $5/month fee is not important to me given the product quality. I sort of liken it to Dropbox -- it's not about doing something that couldn't be done before, it's about just making it streamlined for those who don't care to do it themselves.
- jordigh 12y ago> First, you need to be persistently connected so that you don't miss messages when you're not actually at your computer. I consider that a feature of IRC myself. I don't need to be wired in at all times and read eveerything everyone says. If I'm not there, I'm not there, and if there's something important I really need to hear, I'll hear it when I'm there. If I don't hear it, it never was important. There is memoserv in many IRC networks that does relay messages when you come back online. I have seldom had important messages relayed that way either. Most conversations are not that important. I don't see IRC as something that should follow me everywhere across all devices. It's like radio or TV. Turn it on, turn it off. Not on all the time.
- solomatov 12y ago> How about Erlang. Let's try it, just from the top of my head. Erlang isn' purely functional language in the same sense as Haskell is. It's much more mainstream compared to it. Clojure has even less of it. It's basically LISP which is about 60 years old.
- rdtsc 12y agoWell OP asked about Clojure so Erlang fits the profile. But you make an interesting point in a way. One can ask, ok here are two non-strictly functional languages that seem to be fairly practical. Used for large distributed mission critical systems. Would they be better off written in Haskell? Would they have been written at all if creators only knew about Haskell? How large is the relationship between fault tolerant and safe systems as a product vs strong compiler type safety in the language it was written.
- solomatov 12y ago>But you make an interesting point in a way. One can ask, ok here are two non-strictly functional languages that seem to be fairly practical. Used for large distributed mission critical systems. I think there're at least these problems with Haskell: * The language is badly designed. See the number of extensions which aren't standardized but widely used. See also obvious problems such as requirement to use renames when importing code, and problem with record names conflicts which isn't solved for years. * The focus of the language isn't correct. Lazy evaluations creates a lot of problems both in program performance and complexity of the compiler. The most important parts are pureness and side effect control. * The language is already obsolete. Many its constructions and related complexities are redundant if we unify type and expression level, and get as a result dependently typed system. I hope some language in the future will implement these ideas, and we will have a widely used pure functional dependently typed language with explicit control of effects. I see two candidates for such a language: * Pure script - it's Haskell done right, compiledd to JS. Unfortunately, it doesn't support dependent types. * Idris - it's the language which I describe, but I fear that it's impossible to create a widely used commercial language without major industry players' support.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>Goldman Sachs uses it. Allegedly, Goldman also uses Excel spreadsheet macros. I wouldn't use the Goldman one.
- gclaramunt 12y agoExcel makes a great UI for sophisticated users, I don't see how it counts as a negative
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]