4 ms·
disagreeing with the hivemind Using terms like "the hivemind" (which doesn't exist) is actually a good example of the thing the new guideline covers!
by jseliger 12y ago
disagreeing with the hivemind
Using terms like "the hivemind" (which doesn't exist) is actually a good example of the thing the new guideline covers!
- throwawaymaroon 12y ago...What are you doing? Talking about 'the hivemind' isn't under some sort of blanket ban, and you're shutting down a right to a viewpoint simply because you think it's 'too negative'? This is exactly the kind of thinking that becomes prevalent in the atmosphere towards negativity engendered by HN.
- Karunamon 12y agoThe parent poster is perfectly entitled to their viewpoint, but calling a community "the hivemind" is terribly insulting and needlessly inflammatory.
- throwawaymaroon 12y agoI see. So any time a community displays well-known herding behaviors in a destructive manner, we can not discuss this behavior because that would be insulting and inflammatory. (No shit it'd be insulting and inflammatory. Sometimes that's what the community deserves, and to believe otherwise is to believe in human perfection!)
- Karunamon 12y agoDiscussing it is one thing, dismissing anyone who disagrees with you as "the hivemind" is at the very least not constructive, at most actively harmful. Where's the proof of this "destructive behavior"? How are we supposed constructively discuss a problem that hasn't even been proven to exist? Put another way, it's an extraordinary accusation (HN has a pro-Google bias) that demands extraordinary evidence. We disagree that insults are ever necessary.
- throwawaymaroon 12y ago>How are we supposed constructively discuss a problem that hasn't even been proven to exist? We can't even begin if people demolish all introspective criticism. >We disagree that insults are ever necessary. There's insults like "fuckface" and "idiot," and there's "You're nothing more than a rich white guy whose money makes him feel like his opinions shouldn't be criticized." Personally I find the second more insulting. Basic namecalling isn't really my concern here as something worth defending. Describing the factual nature of someone's motivations and political manipulation is another matter.
- Karunamon 12y agoGenerally, getting into a protracted debate about someone's motivations has two effects: * The thread goes off topic * Lots of unsubstantiated and unfalsifiable accusations are made. (How would I prove I'm not a Google shill, for instance?) At the end of the day, you do not know what someone's motivations are for posting. Speculating on them is just meta noise, lowering the standard of discourse, and generally just plain harmful.
- throwawaymaroon 12y agoIn the context of my discussing someone's motivations, that was intended to be an example where those motivations were on topic and in particular not those of another poster. For instance, discussion of the motivations of Sam Altman in creating this suggestion-guideline: is he lashing out after the negative reaction to his bubble essay? That's insulting! It's also fair game! You can argue that as a statement it's inaccurate, given what you know or believe, but I hope you understand that that kind of statement is exactly the sort of negativity this thing seems designed to prohibit.
- Karunamon 12y agoAgain, we disagree. By even asking that question (suffixing an accusation with a question mark does not make it less of an accusation - something I'll beat the mainstream media over the head with to my dying breath), you're accusing the other person of taking an action in bad faith: retaliatory creation of a rule in direct response to reasonable criticism. On top of that, it's unfalsifiable! How would he go about proving that the guideline update wasn't a result of anger over reception of his article? Now, say that's actually correct. Okay, so? We can't have a substantive discussion how much of a villain you think someone might be. Indeed, the motivations behind the rule are unknown beyond what he tells us, and we can only speculate. Groundless speculation does not make for very good discourse - hence why it's a bad idea to even go there. What we can talk about all day long are the implications of that rule and whether it's a good thing or a bad thing. There are plenty of arguments to be made there. Sam's motivations aside, since we don't know them, shouldn't even really enter into it.
- ohjesusthatguy 12y agoIf you delicate snowflakes can't nurture the next yo! to a $10B IPO because some anonymous asshole on the internet told you your idea was a piece of shit, maybe you shouldn't have a $10B IPO... Just sayin.
- unconed 12y agoGetting upset over a term like "the hivemind" is exactly the kind of thing that turns off true rational debaters, and sets you on the path to a self-reinforcing validation box. Uncomfortable truths will always be unpleasant. Spot on criticism will always make people feel stupid. You cannot be nice and be right all the time. Furthermore, experience has shown that there are in fact a bunch of topics that are anathema here, which may not be debated, not even with correct citations and rational arguments. Hint: it's pretty much the entire "women in tech" debate. It's apparently forbidden to do anything but "listen and believe". Good bye HN, I always thought this place would be astroturfed into oblivion, but instead, it's the feels crowd who killed it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]