3 ms·
Physics teachers are so focused on the inward force because everyone already knows about the outward force. In other words, the whole point of the lesson is to
by snowwrestler 12y ago
Physics teachers are so focused on the inward force because everyone already knows about the outward force. In other words, the whole point of the lesson is to contradict what teenagers think they know. (Obviously, some teenagers don't react well to that, since teenagers think they already know everything.)
The goal is to help students break through assumptions and understand that our everyday experience results from interactions of forces, not just singular forces themselves.
A similar concept is the normal force. Everyone knows about gravity because they know what happens if they fall or drop something. But few people on their own will think of a force to explain why they are usually not falling.
It's like the joke that "it's not the fall that kills you, it's hitting the ground." Analyzed with Newtonion physics, that is literally true! My physics teacher used to say "gravity never killed anyone," which is the sort of counter-intuitive thing that drives teenagers crazy. But it's true--it's that nasty normal force you have to watch out for.
- ghshephard 12y agoRight - I had no problem with the introduction of centripetal acceleration, in fact, after newton's laws, that made intuitive sense. It was the statement that "Centrifugal force does not exist" which upset me. Your explanation does a better job in a throwaway HN comment than he did in a formal physics class.