3 ms·
obesity, even if not at this levels, is an understated problem, and seems to me the US is one of the worst hit. If you can, I'd recommend watching "Fed Up" [0]
by riffraff 12y ago
obesity, even if not at this levels, is an understated problem, and seems to me the US is one of the worst hit.
If you can, I'd recommend watching "Fed Up" [0], a documentary which tries to show that the problem is a bit more complex than just people being lazy ("light" food being effectively worse, complete lack of food education, lobbying at it's worse etc).
As many documentaries, it has a rather clear agenda, but it's interesting nonetheless.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fed_Up_%28film%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fed_Up_%28film%29
- maxerickson 12y agoWhat do you mean by understated? Whenever I see stuff about it, it's called an epidemic or a public health crisis. And it is often accompanied by statistics.
- riffraff 12y agoI mean that very little is done to actually face the problem. I probably should have said "underestimated", please forgive a foreign speaker :)
- maxerickson 12y agoI don't think that fits either, at least not in the US. It's true that there are not tight regulations about what foods people can buy, but there are extensive programs working to inform people, and to improve their choices and the like. There is even some evidence that suggests it might be working: http://articles.latimes.com/2012/may/07/news/la-heb-obesity-projection-20120507 http://articles.latimes.com/2012/may/07/news/la-heb-obesity-... ("Might be" because of In a news conference that was the centerpiece of a second annual "Weight of the Nation" conference in Washington, D.C., Finkelstein said it was unclear whether the galloping rate of growth has slowed because of public policy initiatives aimed at preventing child obesity, greater societal awareness of obesity's risks, or because Americans have hit the maximum level of fatness a population can sustain., that last bit would not be a success...)
- mkr-hn 12y agoThe new nutrition information boxes on the front of most things has helped me a lot. I still buy the same stuff, but being able to see at a glance what's in it helps moderate intake.
- riffraff 12y agoMore than 30% of the adult population is obese (not overweight: obese), and 17% of the children are. You seem to consider the fact these percentages are "growing less" as a success, but in my eyes, it is a failure to implement drastic measures, so (IMHO) you'd be also underestimating the problem.
- maxerickson 12y agoNot having a solution is not the same thing as underestimating the problem. On the other end of it, you have the question of how far drastic measures can go and still be compatible with a reasonable society. I was pointing at the change in the slope as evidence that the programs are (perhaps) having an effect, not that everything was all fixed and a great success. I'm perhaps optimistic, because I think countering obesity in children is the most important thing to be doing, and because I think that over time people will tend to learn habits that are useful in the face of food abundance (which is a reasonably recent phenomenon when you look at it in terms of generations).
- theandrewbailey 12y agoI was at a family funeral earlier this week. I was disgusted by the fact that aside from my mom and a cousin, every one is fat. I seem to be losing weight myself (I'm about 220 lbs.) very slowly, since my pants are starting to be loose. A few people around me have noticed that I have lost weight, at least around the middle.
- BSousa 12y agoI'm on the opposite camp and think Fed Up is not a good movie to watch and seems the author (Kuric I think) had a bone to grind mostly with the fast food and shitty food industry. I remember a scene about a mother going to the store, and buying 'light' oreos/chips/other stuff, and giving that to their kids instead of the regular ones to their kids and then complaining he didn't lose weight and taking as a conclusion that 'dieting' and 'exercise' doesn't really work. Never considered that maybe a carrot stick or an apple would be better, she would just buy diet soda/cookies/chips.
- riffraff 12y agothat is way I said that the movie has a clear agenda, but what you point out is exactly what she said is one of the problems:people believe that they can buy "light" stuff and that will be ok when it's in fact worse than non-light. This is very much the same as for cigarettes, and why the "light" label on those has been banned for years.
- BSousa 12y agoI watched it a few months ago so I maybe confused, but wasn't one of the main ideas the movie tried expose is that "move more, eat less" didn't work? I may be confused, but I think she spent a good part of the movie trying to explain why that didn't work by using cases like the 'light' food family for example.
- riffraff 12y agoyes, the movie makes a big deal of the fact that "just be more active" is not enough, and I agree with you that she seems to push it too hard. But she made it in relation to the fact that for some categories (i.e. the US has had a constant increase in obesity for kids ages 2-5 which are not naturally not "sitting all day" types) moving more is not enough, and I felt the underlying points are still valid (school food is crap, adults are unable to understand what "healthy food", that "eat healthy" is not "eat less" etc).