5 ms·
OnLive shuts down streaming games service, sells patents to Sony
- andybak 12y agoDamn. I've got two games I rather wanted to finish playing. Leaving my lack of ability to finish games to one side - I wonder how dangerous the patents are? I imagine Sony's strategy is to limit game streaming to owners of their hardware. If they are aggressive with their IP that could leave the rest of us shut out of an entire delivery channel.
- MattBearman 12y agoPlayers who took part in that hybrid plan will still be able to play their purchased games through Steam, but streaming games purchased through Cloudlift or the older Playpass subscriptions will no longer be usable after the end of the month. You may still be able to finish them.
- raverbashing 12y ago"The service and a $100 microconsole launched in late 2010, but suffered from noticeable latency and image quality issues in our initial tests." Did anyone expect differently? Heck, I expect this would present significant challenges even running on a LAN It's not a matter of technology, it's a matter of physical impossibility. I can ping google with 5ms latency. That's for the usual ping size packet, allows for 200 round-trips per second. Do you really expect to push inputs and get streamed video back (and encode and decode said video, which also takes time) with any kind of reasonable response time?
- frou_dh 12y agoIt's good-enough for less intensive / movement-oriented games. Not that that covers much of what people actually want to play, mind. Also some people are just not that sensitive-to or bothered-by bad quality media that the pickier amongst us would consider non-starters. e.g. there are plenty of people walking around noisy streets enjoying their music via earbuds that don't deserve to be free gift with a Happy Meal.
- raverbashing 12y agoYes, but they're hearing music as an afterthought in this case. Of course there are games in this category: those on a mobile phone/Portable systems. But their sales point is: "leasing games and equipment", however, if I'm doing this I expect good/high quality (like going into a LAN Gaming center) I agree low quality is acceptable in a multitude of cases, but it doesn't fit with their product.
- Eyght 12y agoBack in the early days of recorded gameplay there was a massive influx of gaming VODs to Vimeo, because they were basically the only mainstream video hosting site that had good enough quality. Iirc Vimeo even had to ban gameplay videos. Many games were not viable on OnLive, some because of latency and some because of fuzzy image quality. It was a good service for the super-casual gamer. But those all play games on their phones now.
- w0utert 12y ago>> It's not a matter of technology, it's a matter of physical impossibility. I would say (and I've been saying this all along) is that it's first and foremost a matter of economic impossibility. Under the assumption that you can make the technology work well enough for a sufficiently large group of potential customers, the business case for streaming games simply doesn't make sense to me. You need to invest huge amounts of money to build, maintain, and update (keep current) highly-specialized server farms that are mostly useless for other purposes, in the hopes that people will pay money to play games on them. All while hardware prices keep going down, and game visuals (including resolution and GPU requirements) keep going up. If you stop upgrading your server farms, within a year or 2 what would previously be top-of-the-line hardware will be so cheap (new in the case of PC's or second-hand in the case of consoles), that unless you are dead set on being able to play the same games no matter your physical location, you can get a much better experience for less money by just buying the hardware. It has always occurred to me that many people are still convinced cloud gaming is a good idea, but the repeated failures of services like OnLive seem to have proven this wrong for now...
- _nedR 12y agoI think the anti-piracy angle is what attracts the game industry. Sony probably envisions a future where GTA XXV is released exclusively as a streaming service. Such a DRM-system would be practically uncrackable (unless you hacked the server or the server code was leaked). Customers would have no say in the matter. This is the main reason why the industry promotes consoles so much. Red dead redemption was never released to PC even though i am sure a lot of PC gamers would want it.
- tracker1 12y agoNot to mention there are whole classes of games where the latency is less of an issue (RTS, board/card games, etc).
- vegardx 12y agoI've actually tried OnLive, and in less than ideal circumstances. I was amazed by how good it actually was, even with RTT for 120ms. Some games, like rally games didn't suffer that badly from the added latency. For things like first person shooters it didn't work that well, the latency and input lag was very noticeable. But get that down to a RTT of 20-30ms then I'm sure most casual gamers will hardly notice. The encoding and decoding is done in hardware and is negligible at best. Also something to keep in mind is that kids today are used to input lag. Both PS4 and Xbox One uses wireless controllers.
- ssiddharth 12y agoHonestly, 120ms is certainly not all that bad. I grew up in the sub continent playing Unreal Tournament and Counter Strike at ~100ms and it wasn't half bad. Sure, the latency is there but it takes only a short period to get used to it.
- vegardx 12y agoIt's a little different in this case, with OnLive the latency is also added to inputs. With games like CS and UT things are calculated on the client. Incidentally this is also why cheating is relatively easy: You have to trust the clients.
- raverbashing 12y ago> The encoding and decoding is done in hardware and is negligible at best. The CPU usage may be negligible, but not the latency. If you live on a place that still has Analog and Digital TV you can flip between both channels and see what's the delay between them. I've seen it being around 0.5s, maybe more, maybe less (Satellite TV is even worse, of course)
- vegardx 12y agoI can only speak from personal experience, but the latency added by encoding and decoding has had to be negligible, as we already had a really high RTT. And TV's are hardly anything to benchmark against. They are designed to be cheap, and I'm sure most of them do it in software as well, as it's way cheaper. Nobody notices a 300ms latency in the image, as they don't have any inputs to measure it against.
- CoolGuySteve 12y agoYou know, I was typing out a summation to show you that the latencies would only cause a frame or two of lag at 60 fps, but it's a lot easier if you just go try it yourself. Go download Steam on 2 computers, find a free demo or something, and turn on the In-home streaming feature. Press F6 to see the latency chart. Now add your 5ms input lag and a 10ms video serialization lag. The rest of the technology stack is pretty much the same. With my NVidia graphics card encoding and my Haswell GPU laptop decoding, the lag at home over wifi is only 12ms. It's definitely not a "physical impossibility" to do this over the internet if your ping is 5ms.
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago> if your ping is 5ms. Who the hell has a 5ms ping? Most home connections are DSL or coax, both adding lots of overhead and latency. DSL/VDSL is especially bad. My u-verse ping to the nearest cdn mirror was something like 20-25ms. My work comcast is slightly better with a 10-12ms to a local cdn. When I had residential comcast, I had probably double that. And that's ignoring all the overhead Onlive puts in. Sadly, onlive would probably clean house in the age of to the home fiber. Maybe 5 or so years from now that service would be more common, at least for gamers. This, of course, means that Onlive would have to deploy servers to every 5-10ms distance. So your typical metro region would be broken down into a few dozen zones, each with its own onlive server, game library, etc. It sounds like a cost nightmare. I think the onlive guys said that 50-150ms is doable for most games and sold a service that worked well with non-FPS games. The problem is, gamers are FPS obsessed and that level of latency is a killer. That's on top with games being cheaper than ever. A plain-jane PC can get on Steam and buy on-sale games for next to nothing.
- paulhodge 12y ago> The problem is, gamers are FPS obsessed and that level of latency is a killer. Console games typically have a minimum possible input lag of 60ms, and once you add in the controller response time, TV refresh rate, and the design of the game's engine, it's common to have 100ms or higher. For example Destiny on PS4 has a minimum input latency of 100ms ( http://www.displaylag.com/destiny-lag-factor-review/ http://www.displaylag.com/destiny-lag-factor-review/ ) Point is, consistent input latency is much less noticeable than people seem to think. When people complain about lag they're usually complaining about spikey/inconsistent lag. Consistent 150ms is not a killer. There are billion dollar games that have shipped with worse.
- lost_name 12y agoThere's a number of products that do this already. Sony even has an division named Gaikai centered around doing this (which is where those patents are probably wanted). - Playstation Now lets users play PS3 games on their PS4 in a similar fashion (games run remotely) - The PS4 lets you "remote play" using a PS Vita (your handheld to your console, remotely) - The Wii U streams content to the controller with remote play (this is different than the PS4 however, it is local only). - Steam allows you to stream games from one computer to another
- hkmurakami 12y agoIIRC the new Dragon Quest game does "cloud gaming" in this manner as well.
- post_break 12y agoI played FPS games with this service with no real issues.
- newobj 12y agoOnLive was good. I also thought the latency would be a blocker, but it really did just work. The problem for me was that I didn't want to stream PC games - I had a PC right there, so why bother? Now, if I could stream console games to my laptop (without owning a console) - sign me up!
- chatmasta 12y agoYou can cache the rendering logic on a local peripheral or computer, and then only send the data changes. Last I checked, when call of duty is played on Xbox, it only requires streaming rates of ~2mbps because the actual data in transit is relatively minimal. Of course, "caching the rendering logic" on a peripheral is not easily done when it's meant to render on a high performance local machine, but I would guess a lot of optimization tricks are available. Also when OnLive launched graphics cards were more expensive and less powerful. It may now be possible to get a lot done with a <$100 device.
- igl 12y agoLatency is low enough that nobody cares about making it faster. I was at a awesome ISP 10 years ago playing quake with < 10ms ping (through clever routing to certain servers). This is still unmatched, I would say that latency and connection quality actually decreased. Fluent "live" interaction over the internet is still decades away.
- tokenizerrr 12y agoI've been playing Tribes Ascend with a ping of 3-5ms ever since I started playing it. I'm in the Netherlands and the game servers are in Amsterdam so that helps, but to say it's unmatched is not true.
- X-Istence 12y agoI play CS:Go on my home Comcast connection, and on certain servers (and time of day) I will have 5 - 8 ms ping due to their location. It's awesome to have such low ping times.
- unwind 12y agoPlaying Quake on a "real" local client with input handling and extrapolation done locally is not necessarily the same as playing OnLive where your input is sent off for processing and the resulting video is returned. I haven't tried OnLive, but the scenarios are very different so I don't think the comparison makes sense.
- josh2600 12y agoI mean, it's not decades away... If you want < 10ms ping, you need to: 1) Be within 10ms of target datacenter (1,860 miles roughly) 2) rip out the TCP/IP handlers in all of the hardware along the route and replace with highly optimized, workload specific IP handlers (you'll want to do this in the kernel, OR in an ASIC if you're really serious about speed). 3) own all of the fiber along the route. Basically, if you can eliminate all of the finger pointing and just own the network end to end, you could probably implement this today, it's just that no one is at that scale except for maybe Google (note: I have no idea how Google runs their internal network, but if I had to guess, this is probably what they're doing). Edit: You can get this now, it's just hard and not worth the cost or effort to do (since no one will bear the cost of building a network like this for gaming, or really for any application I can think of... there just isn't a need for this kind of network performance).
- shurcooL 12y agoPrevious Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9313866 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9313866
- dageshi 12y agoLooks like Sony making a sidebet on the death of traditional consoles to me. If PC's effectively take over the console space then Microsoft is fine since they have the pre-eminent pc gaming OS. Sony on the otherhand doesn't, so I'm guessing they're investigating game streaming as an alternative and buying up IP to do it.