3 ms·
On the subject of unofficial manuals and guides, people has been sued under copyright and trademark for writing and selling them (http://news.cnet.com/Warcraft-
by belorn 12y ago
On the subject of unofficial manuals and guides, people has been sued under copyright and trademark for writing and selling them (http://news.cnet.com/Warcraft-maker-sued-for-blocking-sales-of-unofficial-guide/2100-1043_3-6053716.html http://news.cnet.com/Warcraft-maker-sued-for-blocking-sales-...).
Since the title is "the GNU make book", a consumer could easily mistakes the book as made by the author of GNU make or/and published by the GNU project.
Edit: Missread the article. It was blizzard that got sued for filling the DMCA, not the other way around. A more relevant article is the Harry Potter Lexicon case where a guide to the harry potter works was deemed not protection by fair use. (http://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/8243/can-anybody-write-an-unauthorized-guide http://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/8243/can-anybody-...)
- DrJosiah 12y agoCorrection: Blizzard+Vivendi filed DMCA takedown notices to prevent sales. The writer of the guides sued Blizzard+Vivendi for filing invalid DMCA takedown notices and won http://lawvibe.com/world-of-warcraft-ebook-seller-wins-case-against-blizzard/ http://lawvibe.com/world-of-warcraft-ebook-seller-wins-case-... . Title-wise on jgrahamc's book, that's a different discussion, and completely unrelated to the link you provided.
- teddyh 12y agoThe copyright argument does not seem very plausible, and regarding your linked example: Unofficial guides and such should really be allowed, and I don’t see any consensus forming around disallowing them. Your point about trademarks is much more interesting, though; how many people have paid money for this “The GNU Make Book”, thinking that they have somehow supported the GNU Make project? Isn’t this exactly what trademarks are supposed to prevent?